Site Meter American Idol » Blog Archive » Those for — and against — Sanjaya

Those for — and against — Sanjaya

by Reed Dunn
stephsanjaya.jpg
Stephanie Edwards give the crowd a thumbs up as Sanjaya sits to her left at Wednesday’s results show.

There’s been more talk about why he remained safe once again than there was over why Stephanie Edwards was booted from the show. Stephanie Edwards, you know, the one with so much more talent than Sanjaya may ever have — at least when it comes to singing.

But, no, I’m not bitter. Not at all.

On Sanjaya’s side, there’s Ashley Ferl, the 13-year-old who cried like she’d been punched in the face when she was at Tuesday night’s taping. Now the teenager is soaking up her own 15 minutes by appearing on the Today show, and talking to several other media outlets, including Access Hollywood.

That’s when she said this about her favorite “Idol” finalist: “His voice and his hair and his personality, just everything,” Ashley said. “He’s just like — phenomenal.”

Like, no, he really isn’t phenomenal. I realize I’m now getting angry at a 13-year-old. And that’s not OK. But fortunately there are plenty of people trying to get Sanjaya ousted. Including someone who goes by the name “J” and is creating her own buzz with “Starvation for Sanjaya.”

“Aside from the initial debacle with contestant Antonella Barba, season 6 was starting to look like it may be actually very good. The big voices of Melinda Doolittle and LaKisha Jones, the innovative styling’s of Blake Lewis, and the smooth R&B of Phil Stacey are just a few of the hopefuls with immense potential.

“However, there is one hinge in this broad spectrum of talent this year … Sanjaya Malakar,” “J” wrote on her MySpace page. Each day the page is updated with the latest in the campaign, which has the author vowing not to eat until Sanjaya goes home.

Yes, it’s crazy. But I like it.

, ,


2 Responses to “Those for — and against — Sanjaya”

  1. American Idol Fever » American Idol March 22, 2007 10:35 pm Says:

    [...] Recent Blog Posts Those for ? and against ? Sanjaya That?s when she said this about her favorite ?Idol? finalist: ?His voice and his hair and his personality, just everything,? Ashley said. ?He?s just like ? phenomenal.? Like, no, he really isn?t phenomenal. I realize I?m now getting …Vote for the Worst - American Idol American Idol?s rep with go way down. ( I kinda like that though ). Theres more?. But you get the idea. Recently Steph was voted out. The bottom was Chris and Steph. Phil should have been in the bottom. Chris made it through to the new …American Idol flavored ice cream last updated Mar 22, 2007 at 6:02 PM.Gwen Stefani on American Idol A few weeks back, Fox announced guest stars to be on the hit reality singing competition show. So far this season, Diana Ross, Peter Noone and Lulu have guested. Next week, March 27-28, Grammy award-winning artist Gwen Stefani will be …American Idol Sports 4 Professing Believers Last post by Laura at 12:50 am March 23 in Filings. [...]

  2. Gayle Says:

    If there’s even an ounce of truth to this whole thing, it’s pathetic. All the problems going on in the world, and someone picks THIS reason to go on a hunger strike?! Come on, people!

Leave a Reply


About American Idol

There's not a bigger show on television. That means there's always something to say about "American Idol." From updates on past contestants to the choices of today's finalists, you'll find it all right here at watchingamericanidol.com. Weigh in on your favorites, and sound off on who should go next.

American Idol Author(s)
    » Reed-Dunn

TV Channel Posts

  • Let the game talk begin...
    In between Ollie and April's bitching about Jerry and Keesha and calling them names before moving on to the next target to do the same (...I quit listening...) there was some game talk between Renny [...]
  • Retcon Patrol 1-11: "Family Day" Part 4
    Today we continue our search for inconsistent or comment-worthy moments in the Brothers & Sisters first season with a look at the fourth part of Episode 11. Read Part 1, Part 2, and Part 3 if you [...]
  • Good morning, BBCrazies!
    The house guests are awake and sucking down coffee while mumbling small talk. Dan wants to have a pool party, and Michelle is suspicious since he just got out of the Diary Room - although I think [...]
  • Watch Cheetah Girls 1 and 2 Next Week and Get Ready for 3 Premiering Friday
    Next week the Disney Channel's newest original movie is premiering on Friday. The newest movie is The Cheetah Girls: One World, which is the third Cheetah Girls movie. To get ready for this [...]
  • No Way Out II
    Tomorrow night, CBS will reair "No Way Out" part II. This is the beginning of the end for Gideon, and one of the best episodes of Criminal Minds. CM's main competition for the nine o'clock [...]
  • The WB.com Officially Launches August 27
    In case you haven’t heard, the defunct television network The WB, which merged it’s television network with UPN two years ago to form The CW, is coming back. Well, sort of. They are officially [...]
  • This week of the scheduled View re-runs
    In case you are curious which re-runs are airing this week on The View, here is the list, along with links to the previous re-caps, where available: MON., AUG. 18 (OAD: 4/21/08) – Guest [...]
  • Weeds: "The Love Circle Overlap"
    So we've accused Rescue Me of making it up as it goes along, but this strikes me as ten times worse. Like, do they write these episodes after the previous one airs? Everything just ends abruptly and [...]
  • Michael Sabatino Returning to Guiding Light
    Michael Sabatino will be returning to Guiding Light as sleazy lawyer Vince Russo. Sabatino was on the Guiding Light back in 2000, 2001. He is also married to Crystal Chappell (Olivia) in real [...]
  • Jenna as Sydney Bristow
    You probably know this already but Jenna Fischer once said in an interview that she tried out for the part of Sydney Bristow on Alias. Only, she was turned down because she was told she wasn't "sexy [...]

Hot Off The Press

  • 5 ways to speed up your PC
    Free up disk space By freeing disk space, you can improve the performance of your computer. The Disk Cleanup tool helps you free up space on your hard disk. The utility identifies files that you [...]
  • Know Your Green
    Of course the majority of us want to live a greener lifestyle and have either purchased reading material or DVDs or CDs to learn more about how to change, but what are some of the words that are [...]
  • Choosing Your Battles - When Frugality Becomes an Obsession
    I am the first to admit to being obsessively frugal at times, but my frugal mania has become more tempered over time and I have settled myself into a steady pace that works for me and for those [...]
  • Angelina Jolie Replaces Tom Cruise
    I'm not sure how many of you have already heard the news but Tom Cruise got replaced in the upcoming movie, "Edwin A. Salt," by a GIRL! Yep, that's right the character he was suppose to play in a spy [...]
  • Double-Dig to Improve Soil Health
    Double digging is a great way to improve nutrients and the overall health of your soil. Double digging loosens soil down to a depth of 18 inches. Why is healthy soil important, it increases [...]
  • Survivor Cast Spoilers!
    Well, you wanted spoilers, and they are still slow in coming in. They've kept a tight lid on this season so far! We know that the contestants should be home now, and usually the first plane ride back [...]
  • Did I Just Dream It?
    I swear I started writing a post last night about Jazmyn, one of my cats who lives with my mother in law. And yet, it is nowhere to be found. I didn't publish it but saved it as a draft. But it's not [...]
  • Date Nights...
    Despite the stories being told and spread about Lindsay's past relationship with Courtenay Semel, Lindsay has no qualms showing who she prefers to spend her time with now. Saturday night, after [...]
  • Coffee House Inspires a New Kind of Smoothie
    There a little coffee house downtown where I live - Crossroads Cafe - that is vegan friendly. On their listing of soups, you'll find "Three Bean Vegan Chili." They have soy milk. One time, they even [...]
  • New Homes Going Up in New Orleans!
    Thanks, guys, for your approval on the letter to Ms. Barr! I want to open the floor up to you on that one - if you've got a letter you'd like to send Ms. Barr, put it in the comments or contact me! [...]