Site Meter American Idol » Blog Archive » Simon says

Simon says

by Reed Dunn


Maybe he’s not shocked. But there’s a chance Taylor Hicks is a little upset with the judge from across the pond.

During an interview via satellite with Oprah earlier this week, Simon Cowell said he preferred Chris Daughtry to the Season 5 winner. He threw out some insults, even though he tried to say they were not meant to be insulting. Yeah, right.

“Were you not a big fan of Taylor’s?” Oprah asked.

“I’m going to be honest with you, no,” Simon answered. “Um, I’ve heard a lot of singers like that before and I, and I, and this is going to sound terrible, I think if he didn’t have silver hair, he wouldn’t have won. Um, I don’t. I really don’t. I, I would have voted for Chris.

“I’m not saying anything bad about Taylor. You know, he’s a nice guy, he’s got a good voice. I think it became more of a popularity contest with him rather than talent.”

Is someone talking all over himself? Maybe just a little. Or maybe not. What does Simon really have to lose?

Simon also told Oprah this season has been rough for finding good talent in America. I think we’ve seen that this week. He did say there were two or three girls who have potential. Also, “there’s one guy who does stand out, but he doesn’t look like an American idol,” Simon added.

The talent, at least in previous years, has been regionally unbalanced, Simon told the daytime diva.

“Normally, in the South, we get better singers than say the West Coast or the North,” he said. “But I think, to be fair, everyone was as bad as each other this year. But the gold medal goes to Seattle.”

I’m not sure I can agree. I think the gold medal this year really may go to Minneapolis, Minn.


5 Responses to “Simon says”

  1. Babylinda Says:

    Ha ha ! No wonder Simon was not fond with the hairdresser that was the Taylor Hicks wannabe:)

  2. Rich Jordan Says:

    HAHA babylinda….the security on that episode was so funny, i was out of my chair laughing…that guy was out of his mind.

    and on that note, oprah is the suck.

  3. Karen Says:

    That hairdresser guy was weird and I would have called security too. I love Simon and although he is harsh at times, he is honest and delivers the lines.

  4. Babylinda Says:

    He was just giving Simon some style ! Really though I have always hated Simon’s hair!

  5. Regina Says:

    Simon was just being honest about Taylor. Chris was/is better.

Leave a Reply


About American Idol

There's not a bigger show on television. That means there's always something to say about "American Idol." From updates on past contestants to the choices of today's finalists, you'll find it all right here at watchingamericanidol.com. Weigh in on your favorites, and sound off on who should go next.

American Idol Author(s)
    » Reed-Dunn

TV Channel Posts

  • Kids TV on DVD Review: My Friends Tigger & Pooh Super Sleuth Christmas Movie
    My Friends Tigger & Pooh - Super Sleuth Christmas Movie is a special holiday movie of the Playhouse Disney show My Friends Tigger & Pooh. This movie was first released on DVD last year and it [...]
  • Friday!
    And the CM lady we most want to date is... Good choice...they're all lovely ladies. Here's this week's question: Who would you most trust to babysit your kid? ( polls) [...]
  • The Office: "The Surplus"
    Well, this is going to be embarrassingly pithy. It's roughly 11:45PM and we have to drive for seven hours tomorrow morning. Not to mention that we've been writing for this site ever since Survivor [...]
  • Survivor: Gabon: "The Good Things In Life Aren't Easy"
    Before we even start, let me just state that I'm pretty sure this quote didn't come from Corinne. You probably won't believe me and assume I backtracked to put this in here. But I assure you, it is [...]
  • Survivor Recapping - ep. 12!
    :02 - Ok, so I'm running a little late, and come int to Corinne yelling at sugar because she's stuck in a tribe of people she hates, and doesn't like Sugar talking behind her back. Just in time for a [...]
  • One More
    [/caption][caption id="attachment_684" align="aligncenter" width="328" caption="Matthew for Tommy Hilfiger"][/caption]Thanks to Jeliza (beatiful name, by the way) for telling me about DNA Models. [...]
  • Happy Survivor Day!
    After last week's recap show, it's time for the best episode of the season - the Family Visit! It never fails to bring drama, and turn even Jeff Probst into a bit of a sap. Here's his [...]
  • Guest Star News
    Grey’s Anatomy continues to draw big names to the small screen. Eric Stolz will guest star on Grey’s for a three episode arc in January. Eric will play a serial killer that comes to Seattle Grace [...]
  • Five questions: "Unfinished Business"
    Five questions about last Sunday's episode -- "Unfinished Business" -- still rattling around in my brain: 1. So what can Saul do to "get Holly out," exactly? I mean, short of a shooting in the [...]
  • The View December 4th Recap: Harry Connick Jr, Marlo Thomas, Drake Bell and Josh Peck
    Today on The View, all five hosts were present. There was not a single hot topic today. And I don’t just mean that the topics were not “hot.” I mean that during the “hot topics” segments [...]

Hot Off The Press

  • Ian Hemphill: nutmeg, cumin, spice blends
    Nutmeg: A good quality nutmeg (the kernel from a fruit that grows on a tropical evergreen tree) is oily and fragrant. The high oil content in nutmegs makes them difficult to grind, creating a [...]
  • Phi Sigma Phi collects can tabs for charity
    Children with cancer at the University of Michigan C.S. Mott Children's Hospital will be the recipients of more than 20 free treatments because of the efforts of Central Michigan [...]
  • Luigs named 2008 Rimington Trophy finalist
    Arkansas senior and 2007 Rimington Trophy winner Jonathan Luigs has been named one of six finalists for the 2008 Rimington Trophy, presented annually to the outstanding center in college foot [...]
  • Two Legends Coming To Town
    Two legends are heading to the Queen City over the next week ... in fact, on the same night! First, one of the best-known songwriters/singers in the world is heading into Charlotte for a gig at [...]
  • Listen for the Love!
    'Love is what's in the room with you at Christmas if you stop opening presents and listen.' Bobby - age 7 I stumbled across this quote online. It blew me away in it's simplicity and [...]
  • Book Review: Marwan: The Autobiography of a 9/11 Terrorist – Aram Schefrin
    By Mr. JM I looked forward to reading Marwan – when I first was given the book to read I glanced through the Author’s note. It seemed someone (Aram Shefrin) had done some research into who the [...]
  • Interview With Author Steven Verrier
    Hello and welcome to Fiction Scribe, Mr. Verrier! Thank you. I’m happy to be here. Tell us a bit about you – where you’ve been, how you got here, where you’re going. I’ve been [...]
  • Neopets Puzzle Adventure Review!
    When the ever lovely Melissa (Plugged In PR for Capcom) contacted me about reviewing the brand spanking new Neopets Puzzle Adventure, I expected fun, squeals, and squabbles from my girls. What I [...]
  • Albuquerque NM stories
    [caption id="attachment_1245" align="alignnone" width="240" caption="Photo by Mary MacIntyre Upon the mountain, three seasons at once"][/caption] Please also read previous post. Check out [...]
  • Albuquerque: Portait of A Western City
    [caption id="attachment_1236" align="alignnone" width="320" caption="May your home fill with joy today."][/caption] Albuquerque: Portait of A Western City edited by Mary Kay Cline Clear Light [...]