American Idol

Last night, the guys performed for the first time live for the American Idol audience while the girls sat nearby watching. Tonight, the tables are turned.

And, even though there were a few memorable performances from last night, I really expect this crop of female finalists to shine. As with every season, I think the girls are going to be able to outsing the guys. There’s that advantage to being able to pull out the highest of high notes.

So, are you ready?

7 p.m.

According to Ryan Seacrest, there’s a bit of flu and illness going around among the Top 24. It certainly could keep some of the girls from giving their all, but this also gives them a chance early on to show how they can push through even the tough times.

After the break, the 1960s are returning.

7:09 p.m.

Kristy Lee Cook is up first. After amazing the judges with her renditions of Amazing Grace, she comes to the competition with a fair amount of experience under her belt. If she makes some money on the Idol gig, she plans to buy back the horse she sold to pay for her chance to audition. So, does her version of Rescue Me have her on the right path?

I have to say her version of Amazing Grace is much more interesting than tonight’s performance. She certainly has a great, smooth voice, but I’m not sure Kristy Lee Cook, as a singer, can stand out among some of the tough competition she’s facing this season.

“Being sick, being the first one, that’s a double whammy,” Paula said. “But having said that, don’t ever let that get in the way of your shine. …”

“This is an important part of the show,” Simon said. “This section, we get to see what you’re made of. … The song didn’t really suit you. … I thought your performance was robotic.”

Joanne Borgella is up next. I have to admit, her combination of a great story — she’s a plus-size model — and her rich, inviting voice are really appealing to me. I can’t say she’s my definite No. 1 favorite, but she’s at the top of the list at this point. Let’s see if she can keep herself there.

Tonight, I Say A Little Prayer for You is the song she chooses. There’s no doubt she can do better with a different song, but you still can tell Joanne has a voice that’s unlike some of her competitors. I’m not sure where she stands right now …

“You know, that was pretty good,” Randy said. “The first part of it was a little weird for me. …”

“We’ve definitely seen you in the previous auditions where you have this unbelievable, strong sense of yourself,” Paula said.

“I didn’t like it at all,” Simon said. “… What you just did there was a very cabaret version of a cabaret song. … It was very, very substandard.”

7:25 p.m.

On the eve of her birthday, Alaina Whitaker is hoping to use her Carrie Underwood-esque looks to get her to the next level. The 16-year-old Oklahoma native (she really does have a lot in common with the Season 4 winner) has some of the same charm as the likable female finalists that have come before her.

There’s no doubt Alaina has been the highlight of the night — even though she’s only the third to perform. But I think her performance tonight proves she has a chance of going far in this competition. Definitely, she’s a great singer, and her rendition of More Today Than Yesterday was a great way to celebrate her birthday.

“It’s such a feel-good song,” Paula said. “… You proved that you come out here, you nailed it. You had the best ending that I’ve heard on that song.”

“I think you’re very good,” Simon said. “I do.”

7:36 p.m.

Amanda Overmyer auditions for her chance to be a Season 7 finalist.

She’s the female resident rocker this season. And Amanda Overmyer has a voice unlike any rocker chick that came before her — at least on Idol. Tonight she’s trying her hand at Baby, Please Don’t Go.

I won’t deny Amanda has her craft down, but she’s not what I’m looking for in my next Idol winner. She’s the kind of girl I’d love to see fronting a band at the bar down the street while I throw back a few beers. That’s definitely what she can provide to the music world.

“Amanda, I just love everything you do,” Paula said. “You’re authentic. … This is who you are.”

“I really like you,” Simon said. “I like you because I genuinely think you’re authentic. … I hope you stay around for awhile.”

7:45 p.m.

She’s one of the few female contestants we know little about. Amy Davis is a tradeshow model who hopes to make herself more known this year.

Tonight, she makes an attempt by singing Where the Boys Are. Already, in her first performance, Amy has created a look for herself that makes her stand apart from her earliest airtime (though it was little) on Idol. As far as the performance itself, Amy definitely could do better. It was just a little bland — needed some salt and pepper — for me.

“I didn’t think it was great, and here’s why,” Randy said. “… When you scoop up to the note, you have to hit that note dead on.”

“I’m going to say something very positive, the camera loves you,” Paula said. “… I don’t know if it was the most engaging song for you to sing.”

“There’s nothing much to add,” Simon said. “… As Paula said, you looked great. But you didn’t sound great.”

Brooke White sings her way into the next round during her Season 7 audition.

Brooke White, the resident nanny, is another one of my favorite girls this season. She has a great look and a pure voice. Her heart certainly is out in the open this season, which could help her find a spot in the hearts of America, too.

Tonight, Brooke takes on Happy Together. The performance as a whole is pretty good. It’s definitely enough to keep her safe this week and likely for several weeks to come. I’m just hopeful she can do a better job choosing songs in the future. Her incredible talent cannot be showcased on a tune like Happy Together.

“It doesn’t matter what the song is, you’re supposed to sing the living daylights out of it,” Randy said.

“What this competition is about is originality,” Paula said. “That’s what I love about you. You have your own thing.”

“I think you chose the right song,” Simon said. “But there are times tonight I feel like I’m in a washing up liquid commercial …” OK, Simon. You’ve been in America long enough to not say things like “washing up liquid.”

8:01 p.m.

Alexandrea Lushington’s turn has come. She’s another shining star in this group of good singers, but will she make herself stand out above the rest?

Her rendition of Spinning Wheel was above average. I’m not sure what was going on with the highest notes — they seemed a little squeaky — but I think she’ll be safe. Alexandrea certainly has a lot of personality, and her voice is still pretty fantastic.

“I saw more confidence in your performance than in any other performance tonight so far,” Paula said.

“I didn’t get it,” Simon said. “I didn’t think the vocals were great.”

8:12 p.m.

Another little-seen finalist this season has been Kady Malloy. Simon called her the best of the season earlier this year, so we’ll see if that works out in her favorite. OK, this girl does Britney Spears impressions. I love it.

Groovy Kind of Love was a phenomenal song choice for Kady who, clearly, is the best performer of the night. Having not seen too much of her before now, I certainly think she’s proven she has a strong voice — and sense of identity — at this point in the competition. My guess is Kady has gained herself a large group of fans based on tonight alone.

“You know what, I love that backstage stuff,” Randy said. “This song was OK for me.”

“What we all knew when we first auditioned you, and what we fell in love with was your personality,” Paula said. “… I want to see the life of you more.”

“Actually, amazingly, for once, I agree with Paula,” Simon said. “That was like Night of the Living Dead. When you do the Britney, you’re brilliant. Then, when you do you, the lights go out.”

Even though her dad died two days before her audition, Asia’h Epperson kept his dream alive. So far, things are working out well.

Asia’h Epperson blew me away earlier this season with her rendition of How Do I Live. It was incredible, especially since it came two days after her dad died. All of this, plus her voice, also made her one of my early favorites this year.

Tonight, Asia’h chose Piece of My Heart to try and win America’s votes. And she chose to wear some gigantic earrings that were slightly distracting. But, as far as the vocals, well, they were pretty good. I know she can do better — we’ve seen it. Still, I think Asia’h could be the one to get my votes tonight.

“You did your thing with it,” Randy said.

“You had some really good moments in that song,” Paula said.

“For me, it was my favorite of the night,” Simon said. “You let you. You’re fun. You’re likable.”

8:27 p.m.

Ramiele Malubay has one of the most powerful voices this season. And she’s been one of the most exposed stars as far as airtime is concerned. Her look and story certainly has been followed since her original audition.

You Don’t Have to Say You Love Me was an interesting song choice for Ramiele. But I have to say it was pretty smart, too. It was unexpected, and she nailed it. I expect the judges will say she made it her own, which is crucial. Let’s see …

“You took your time, you started it slow, it built up,” Randy said. “… Very classy. Almost like a pro, man. That was hot.”

“You’re a force to be reckoned with,” Paula said. “… You had a really great performance.”

“I’ll be the first to admit, I didn’t like you when I first saw you,” Simon said. “… Tonight, you outsung every single person.”

8:37 p.m.

Next up is Syesha Mercado. And, while I know I’ve thrown around the term “favorite” a little bit, I have to say Syesha certainly made her way to the very top of my list of female finalists as soon as I saw her first audition. Let’s see if she can keep herself there.

Tobacco Road was not the song I thought Syesha would choose, but it seems to work for her. This performance is further proof Syesha has the voice, the look and the charisma to go far in this competition. And, based on this, I’m going to say she just took the “best of the night” honors … so far.

“All in all, I really liked it,” Randy said.

“Consistent,” Paula said. “Joyful. Fun. Big.”

“It wasn’t your best, best performance,” Simon said. “… You are probably one of the most talented girls in this competition.”

8:46 p.m.

She’s already one of the most controversial contestants this season. But Carly Smithson also has a powerful voice to back up her professionalism. The simple fact she didn’t have a work visa to compete in Season 5 certainly should help her gain some sympathy votes (not that she doesn’t have the talent) this year.

Shadow of Your Smile was a great song choice. And Carly certainly can sing — remember she did have a recording contract as a teenager. There’s no doubt she’ll make it quite far this season.

“The best vocal of the last two days,” Randy said. “The best vocal of the Top 24.”

“I know how hard this week was for you,” Paula said. “You don’t even have to power your voice.”

“I’m on my own here,” Simon said. “I didn’t get it. There’s so much hype about you. … I thought the song was way too old-fashioned for you. … Everything about it, for me, was a letdown.”

WHO GETS MY VOTE: There’s no doubt Syesha Mercado was my favorite of the night. I also thought Asia’h Epperson put a lot of soul and energy into her performance, and that’s worth a phone call or two for sure.

WHO SHOULD GO: This is tough, because there certainly are a lot of good singers on the female side. I think Amy Davis certainly was forgettable, which spells trouble. As far as a second person to get the boot, I think, unfortunately, Joanne Borgella could be in trouble (I’ll be throwing a couple of votes her way, just in case).

American Idol, Amanda Overmyer, Alaina Whitaker, Alexandrea Lushington, Asia’h Epperson, Ramiele Malubay, Amy Davis, Joanne Borgella, Carly Smithson, Kristy Lee Cook, Brooke White, Syesha Mercado, Kady Malloy