Site Meter American Idol » Blog Archive » Katharine McPhee debut not ‘Over the Rainbow’

Katharine McPhee debut not ‘Over the Rainbow’

by Reed Dunn

katharinecd3.jpgIf you were expecting to hear a more “Somewhere Over the Rainbow” Katharine McPhee, forget about it. That certainly isn’t the sound the runner-up of last season’s “American Idol” brings to the table with her self-titled debut.

The CD, which was released today, is a mix of all things pop and R&B. The music — almost from start to finish — is the kind of stuff you can expect to hear while shopping at the mall. In other words, it’s the kind of music that easily can be forgotten.

Maybe I’m a little frustrated, because I wanted to hear a ballad-heavy release from McPhee. Instead, bubble-gummish pop tunes such as “Not Ur Girl” and “Dangerous” sound more like the early work of Christina Aguilera and, dare I say, Britney Spears. It’s almost like McPhee is trying too hard to fit in somewhere, somehow.

And it sounds almost like she showed up a few years late. Or that she was a member of a Diddy-created girl group that decided to create an independent solo project.

But McPhee’s voice still is sweet. It’s just not the McPhee that led us to catch McPheever. Seriously, the only song that will give you faith in having supported this girl — at least if you were in it for the ballads — is “Ordinary World.” Another attempt, though it also falls short, is “Home.”

This definitely is not the strongest start for McPhee, but, then again, you never really know what radio will pick up these days. And, judging by the crazy amount of production that went into creating this sound-and-image combo, something just may stick.

Let’s just hope the best is yet to come from our sweet little songstress.


5 Responses to “Katharine McPhee debut not ‘Over the Rainbow’”

  1. Jose Alvear Says:

    Hey, that’s too bad.

    I was looking forward to a good CD from McPhee, but I guess that’s not to be.

    I’m willing to accept her a pop star, but she seems a bit mature for that. Guess that’s why everyone loved her ballads.

    I was thinking of buying it just out of curiosity. Maybe I’ll wait until I hear a single on the radio or something.

  2. Frank Miniaci Says:

    I have only been involved with platinum artists and I am sorry to say that you will have to be satisfied with platinum status for now. She has the chops to do even more on the small and big screen but for now, be satisfied. Not everyone can put out a blue-haired grammy release. Especially when AI is involved in the first project. It “is” a business you know. Personally I would remix half the CD. A few singles will probably be done for radio that way. This is certainly better than anything that has been fielded by Clay, Ruben, Fantasia, or Taylor. McPhee will be in the class of Kelly, Carrie, or Chris. She already is.

  3. Sally Says:

    It is composed of the most stupid poppy songs I’ve heard in a while. You can feel your brain cells dying as you hear one of the songs. I started saying “it’s hot” and became a valley girl after hearing McPhee’s CD. Do you have an enemy, but him this CD…

  4. Rich Jordan Says:

    I never really liked McPhee….she reminds me too much of this girl i grew up with…and didn’t like.

  5. Daniel Says:

    Speaking Over The Rainbow, There is an a popular new group on Yahoo
    called THE JUDY GARLAND EXPERIENCE. They feature amazingly rare audio
    files, photo’s, lively discussions, and more! The membership includes
    people who knew Judy, authors of books on Judy, people who have
    directed movies about her, longtime fans, new fans, and members of
    Judy’s family. The only thing missing from the group is you! Please
    stop by and check it out.

    http://movies.groups.yahoo.com/group/thejudygarlandexperience/

Leave a Reply


About American Idol

There's not a bigger show on television. That means there's always something to say about "American Idol." From updates on past contestants to the choices of today's finalists, you'll find it all right here at watchingamericanidol.com. Weigh in on your favorites, and sound off on who should go next.

American Idol Author(s)
    » Reed-Dunn

TV Channel Posts

  • Carlos' New Project...
    Hey, everyone!! Once again, the weekend is here and this time it’s a big one! I wanna wish you all a happy fourth and a safe holiday weekend. Have fun and be careful out there! Be sure to come back [...]
  • Happy Fourth!!!
    Hello everyone!!! I hope you’re all having a great Fourth of July today, for those of you out there who are celebrating it. Me? I’m just hanging out at home right now and bracing for all the [...]
  • Emily supports HR 1326 (chimps)
    We all know and love that Emily Deschanel is very active in the rights of animals. She's known for being a vegetarian, and has supported various causes over the years. Now, she's written to [...]
  • Emily as Dr. Farquad
    Saw the movie My Sister's Keeper last night - I left the theatre with mixed feelings. The film was beautifully done, and I say that after watching it with skepticism. I pretty much knew the storyline [...]
  • A Special Surprise: Interview with Ronnie's Wife!
    As the links to various MySpaces were found and dug up on the 1st after the cast reveal, I jumped at the chance to message Ronnie's wife, and see what she'd like all of us to know about the Gamer [...]
  • Reality Wanted Interviews!
    They'll go right here as they come in! First up - Jeff! [...]
  • Interviews are going up!
    At long last! We have interviews going up at CBS2! So check it out here, as Diane interviews. It's hard to hear Diane, as usual, so up your volume a bit! (I'm sure someone will youtube them too - [...]
  • Retcon Patrol: 2-05 "Domestic Issues" Part 5
    Today we continue our look for inconsistent or comment-worthy moments in the Brothers & Sisters second season with a look at the final part of Episode 5. Read Part 1, 2 3, and 4, and then hop right [...]
  • Independence Day Weekend Links
    Few notes before we get to the links. First off, we're not going to be posting twice today like we suggested yesterday. For whatever reason, it alluded us that this is 4th of July weekend and we have [...]
  • Clip of the Week
    This week's clip comes from Guiding Light. It is a clip from the Bauer BBQ of Danny and Michelle getting married. [...]

Hot Off The Press