Site Meter American Idol » Simon Cowell

Simon Cowell

Live blogging: ‘American Idol’ Hollywood Week begins

Tuesday, February 12th, 2008

It’s finally Hollywood Week, which has me more anxious for this season than ever before. American Idol’s best 164 contestants of Season 7 are coming together to try and make the final cut. This is where it all begins. So, let’s get to it.

7:02 p.m.

This time around, nobody is getting cut in the first two days. But by the end of Hollywood Week, it will be down to the Top 24. First up is Brooke White, who got her golden ticket in Philadelphia. She’s playing her song on the piano, the first sign this season will be much more interesting — and musical.

Brooke’s version of Beautiful is the kind of thing that makes the judges proud. She gets an automatic pass to the Hollywood Week finals, meaning she’s a step ahead of the competition. And deservedly so.

leomarlowe.jpg
Leo Marlowe faired well during his Omaha audition, but his first time on stage during Hollywood Week was, well, weak.

Leo Marlowe, among others, doesn’t have as much luck. Their first-day auditions don’t go as well. But they’ll be back for a second chance before Simon, Paula and Randy give them the complete thumbs down. This really should ensure we’ll be seeing the best of the best when the live shows roll around.

7:14 p.m.

This year’s addition of instruments seems to be hurting many of the contestants. Eventually, though, I think the idea of being able to play an instrument will separate the true musicians from the rest of the pack.

davidh.jpg
David Hernandez at his San Diego audition.

David Hernandez decided to leave the instruments behind him. Just taking the microphone, this San Diego finalist steps out and impresses the judges. His smooth sound is refreshing and, even though it’s the first time we’re finally seeing him, it’s rumored to not be the last.

7:23 p.m.

Amanda Overmyer was in a car accident just a week before her trip to Hollywood Week. A nurse and would-be resident rocker chick of Season 7 made it to Hollywood to sing The Doors. Amanda certainly is an interesting contestant, and her voice definitely sets her apart. I think she could be the contestant of the season that really splits fans’ opinions. Some will love her. Others will want her gone right away. Thoughts?

As with seasons past, Hollywood Week is filled with contestants who can’t remember the lyrics no matter what. I’m not sure how you get to this point and don’t burn the lyrics into your brain. Sure, the contestants are nervous. But this is the chance of a lifetime. And not remembering the lyrics? It’s almost as annoying to me as it is to Simon. But not quite.

It’s not just forgetting lyrics, though. Ghaleb Emachah just doesn’t have it. I’m not really sure how he made it through this far, and I don’t think he has a chance of saving himself during his second-chance audition.

7:36 p.m.

Josiah Leming made it to Hollywood — fake British accent and all — with one of the best stories of the season. The teenager has been living in his car, and behind a keyboard, he says he feels most comfortable. There’s something about him that’s interesting, and even Simon agrees. “I think out of all of the auditions, this is the one I’m going to remember,” he said.

ramiele.jpg
Ramiele Malubay found early success during Hollywood Week.

Danny Noriega, Ramiele Malubay and Carly Smithson are a few other early favorites to impress the judges during their first-day Hollywood auditions. But will relaxing for a couple of days in the hotel lead to some L.A. shenanigans that have caused problems like those faced by finalists during previous seasons? There are plenty of distractions that seem to get in the way for these singers, many experiencing their first trip to the land of celebrities.

7:45 p.m.

During the second day of the big week, contestants have plenty of reasons to be nervous. It’s make or break time. David Cook, a rocker who decides to take his guitar on stage, presents a memorable performance of Everything I Do by Bryan Adams. In another season certainly to be dominated by females, David could be a strong contender on the male side.

Simon doesn’t give him a “yes,” but Paula and Randy give him the thumbs up.

Robbie Carrico, Jessica Brown, Syesha Mercado and Colton Berry, among several other contestants, chose to sing Bryan Adams for their big auditions. It worked for some, not for others. All of the Bryan Adams leads me to wonder why so many contestants go for the same song. Where’s the originality? I think it has to be tough to sing the same songs as many others, because the judges are bound to bring comparisons into their decisions.

7:57 p.m.

After 164 people sang, 48 singers were given automatic passes to Thursday of Hollywood Week. The rest were forced for the second-chance auditions. In groups of 10, they only will have a few seconds to impress the judges. No instruments. No background music.

Suzanne Toon and Perrie Cataldo are among the singers in the first group of 10. Only two singers make it to through, and it’s not Suzanne or Perrie. I have to admit Suzanne may have been overlooked. Her audition certainly seemed to be better than many we’ve seen at this point in past seasons.

The innocent dance captain known for teaching abstinence, Amy Flynn, brought a voice coach to Hollywood. That voice coach was a Season 4 competitor. It seems like a big investment for Amy (or her parents), and it didn’t work out. I have to say I agree with the judges on this one.

After four groups take their turns at the microphone, the second-chance auditions only benefit four contestants. It seems this season of Idol really could be bringing only the best to the Top 24. I, for one, am hopeful we’ll all be having a hard time choosing an obvious two or three standouts once the live shows begin. That will make the season much more interesting — and popular.

8:09 p.m.

Entire groups are getting cut at this point in the competition. Tears are being shed. Hearts are being broken. So, would Kristy Lee Cook be able to remind judges just how well she could sing? A repeat of her original audition song, Amazing Grace, was what she put on the line.

Another one of my early favorites, Jeffrey Lampkin, also is on the chopping block. He certainly has one of the biggest personalities thus far in Season 7. His song, however, is not as strong.

Then there’s Angela Martin, who lost her father between getting the golden ticket and making the trip to Hollywood. The tragedy almost kept her from making the trip. So, will any of these standouts make it through?

For Kristy and Jeffrey, it’s “yes.” For Angela, the road ends. “I’m not going to stop, and I’m going to keep trying,” she said, keeping her spirits as high as possible.

“I got to Hollywood. Now I have to move on to something else,” Angela continued. “… I’m a strong person. And I just thank God for that.”

8:21 p.m.

It’s Thursday in Hollywood Week. And the several dozen survivors are hoping to make the final cut. Making the Top 24 is their hope, but they all still have to perform one more time — with background singers — to impress Randy, Paula and Simon.

David Archuleta, 16, is another early favorite. Simon already has called him “incredible.” But will choosing a Bryan Adams song be the way to keep the judges giving him a thumbs up? Opposed to some of the other Bryan Adams songs, David’s rendition of Heaven is further proof he’s bound to be a favorite this season. This kid has some great talent. (I must say, if nothing else, he’s going to be seen on Broadway in a few years … at the very least.)

“That was the bomb,” Randy proclaimed. “That was the best I’ve heard since we’ve been here, for days.”

Kyle Ensley finally impressed the judges. But Jeffrey Lampkin’s time back on stage, singing A Whole New World, didn’t do so well. I have to say, personally, the song choice couldn’t have been worse. It’s too bad, too, because his personality certainly could have brought a lot of fun to the competition.

A few singers are battling with voice issues, including Syesha Mercado. One of the best singers in the competition — definitely one of my favorites — she overcame much of her sickness to push out a great rendition of Chain of Fools. I can’t wait to see more of her this season …

michaelj.jpg
Michael Johns

Michael Johns, another finalist from the San Diego auditions, is up next. The Australia native chose to sing Bohemian Rhapsody for his Thursday audition. It would seem to be a terrible choice of song, but Michael really showcased his skills with the song. One of the older contestants this season, the 29-year-old has the voice of an experienced artist. He’s not necessarily the one with the biggest range, but he certainly will garner his fair share of fans thanks to his time on Idol.

8:37 p.m.

We’re back, and Carly Smithson is, too. First a golden ticket winner in Season 5, she returned in Season 7 after not having legal paperwork to compete that season. It’s obvious she’s a favorite of producers and judges alike this season — there’s no single contestant who has been given as much airtime. (Plus, she’s already been a somewhat established recording artist, but more on that later …)

Obviously, Carly’s performance of Alone gets positive feedback from the judges. Personally, it’s not nearly as strong as the memorable Carrie Underwood performance during Season 4. And, just so you know, it’s not that I don’t like Carly — I just hate that she seems to be getting some type of sympathy coverage and is being a little overexposed.

Asia’h Epperson is another story. She is one of my very favorites (OK, so I have a lot of those) this season, and she deserves to keep going far in this competition.

Brooke Helvie’s fate was in Paula’s hands. She had Simon’s support. And Randy said “no.” For the first time in quite a while, Paula delivered the disappointing news — it was the end of the road for Brooke.

This year’s resident homeless contestant, Josiah Leming, was cracking under the pressure. He practiced very little after choosing a song, but he let the backing band leave for his rendition of Stand By Me. With his British accent and a sound similar to Daniel Bedingfield — or at least an attempted sound — it just didn’t work. Still, the judges put a lot into his previous auditions and keep him around for a chance at the Top 24.

8:54 p.m.

There are just a few moments left in the first Hollywood Week episode of the season. Most of the 164 golden ticket winners have been sent packing, and FerrasHollywood’s Not America plays in the background as big moments of the week are relived.

There are 50 contestants left standing. From that batch, Randy, Paula and Simon must narrow the field down to the Top 24 — 12 guys and 12 girls. It seems there’s plenty of arguing before tomorrow night — that ride in the elevator and walk across the room to see if they’ve made the cut.

I’ll admit I’d be a lot more excited about it all, if I didn’t know about the leaked list I’ve mentioned so many times before. It certainly appears to be on track with what has happened this far. I’m just looking forward to narrowing down my favorites of the season and seeing what these contestants really can bring once the show gets going with live episodes.

But what about you? Do you have an early favorite? Who is going to inspire you to pick up the phone and vote?

, , , , ,

‘American Idol’: Best of the rest

Wednesday, February 6th, 2008

ryan.jpg
American Idol host Ryan Seacrest wears a big yellow hat during the Atlanta auditions.

We’ve seen auditions in seven cities. American Idol Season 7 is off to a strong start, but what happens to all those Hollywood Week contestants that don’t get TV time during the auditions weeks? Well, tonight we get to see a few more of the bright spots.

Because I’m completely over the terrible singers, I’m continuing to focus on only the best auditions. Sorry for those of you hoping to read some nasty things about the best of the worst. I just can’t do it right now …

Amy Davis sang a version of Blue Bayou. Her audition wasn’t a knockout, but the judges think she has enough potential to maybe be molded into the next big thing. Personally, I think if you don’t have it at the start, you shouldn’t be given that chance. There certainly are plenty of already-good-enough singers in the competition. But maybe Amy will prove me wrong.

Cardin Lee McKinney has a strong voice, but she pushes it a little too hard. Her performance of One Night Only from Dreamgirls is good enough for the judges — at least Paula and Randy. I think she has potential, but I’m not sure she could make it too far. This is another example of a contestant who just isn’t strong enough from the start to really deserve that second chance. (I know, I know. It’s time to get a little more critical, though.)

JoAnne Borgella is a plus-size model. She’s performed the National Anthem at Madison Square Garden. Her Idol audition certainly is one of the best of the season. In fact, she’s an incredible contestant — and I think she has a voice that could stand out in the competition. Simon, however, does not. Fortunately, Paula and Randy are carrying her through to Hollywood. And remember those rumors I’ve referred to several times?

Chikezie Eze auditioned last year, and he’s back again for Season 7. I’m not sure how Randy passed on this guy last year, but I’m glad he didn’t let him go this season. Chikezie has an interesting name, to say the least, and he certainly has potential to prove Randy wrong. If nothing else, his name will set him apart.

Danny Noriega quite possibly is the smallest contestant in the competition. And his voice is one of the biggest. “You’ve got a very good voice,” Simon told him. Even with a little too much confidence, Danny is on his way to Hollywood. Could he be this year’s Sanjaya? I’m not sure, but I do think he could bring something interesting to the show.

So, who’s it going to be? Hollywood Week is just around the corner, and a season of excitement — and still more disappointments, I’m sure — is about to really get rolling. Keep it here for the latest from the stars of tomorrow and the stars from seasons past.

, , , ,

‘American Idol’: The best of Atlanta

Wednesday, February 6th, 2008

More than 12,000 people showed up to audition in Atlanta for Season 7 of American Idol. There were 20 golden tickets granted to the best in the crowd.

In order to prepare myself for getting down to the best of the season — and also my favorite parts of the show — I’m only sharing the highlights from Atlanta. In case you weren’t watching, here’s the cream from the Atlanta crop:

Josh Jones works with glass by day. At American Idol, he makes it through with a golden ticket … somehow. But he’s not a great singer. At all. I’m not sure what Paula and Randy saw in this guy. They made him sing with his back turned to them, after all. Why? Because he made bizarre faces. That’s not a good sign.

asiah.jpg
Asia’h Eperson

After Asia’h Eperson’s father passed away just a couple of days before her Idol audition, she switched up her song to LeAnn Rimes’ How Do I Live. Not only does Asia’h have an incredible story on her road to Idol, but she also has a beautiful look and incredible power to be able to move forward to this point. Three “yes” votes from the judges means we’re not done seeing Asia’h just yet. And, the good news to this sad story? Rumors suggest she could be around for some time …

Brooke Helvie was out to prove to Simon that pageant girls can sing. The truth is Brooke can sing. The problem? It was a pageant performance. Her giddy Kellie Pickler-esque appearance and attitude were enough to win over the judges. I, however, am not so sold.

alexandrea.jpg
Alexandrea Lushington

Alexandrea Lushington chose My Funny Valentine to try and win over the judges. Simon looked unimpressed. Bored even. But the 16-year-old impressed Randy and Simon. And me, which, let’s be honest, is who really matters. I can’t wait to hear more from Alexandrea, who I think could do well with the challenge of different theme weeks.

amanda.jpg
Amanda Overmyer

Amanda Overmyer easily could be this season’s rocker chick. Her voice is rough and raw. Her look is so Gina Glocksen, it hurts a little bit. But Amanda certainly is interesting. She’s the real deal. Imagine this girl in the corner of a smoky bar, performing in front of a rock band, and you’d not be far off at all. Let’s see how far she can go. “She’s the female Chris Daughtry,” Paula even said.

josiah.jpg
Josiah Leming

Josiah Leming is an 18-year-old living in his car. He chose to sing an original song, To Run. When he talks, he’s American. When he sings, he’s trying to be a British frontman. Still, there’s a little something cool about this kid. I’m not sure what I like about him — maybe it’s his love of Snow Patrol — but this may be the one time I actually am not laughing at a fake British accent.

So, which Atlanta favorite has the best chance of taking the top prize? That’s got to be Asia’h Eperson. She’s got the look, the voice and the story to end all stories. At this point, she certainly is my Atlanta favorite.

, , , ,

Live blogging: ‘American Idol’ auditions in Miami

Wednesday, January 30th, 2008

The end is nearing. It’s almost time for the good part of American Idol to begin. But first, another stop on the audition trail — this time in Miami.

7 p.m.
There are more than 10,000 hopefuls lined up waiting to get their shot in front of the judges. It’s possible the Season 7 winner could be waiting in the sea of people. Will it be Shannon McGough? Her parents own a meat market, and she’s won several regional Idol competitions.

In front of the judges, she sings a Janis Joplin number. And by sing, I mean scream. And whine. And make really bizarre sounds. How in the world did she ever win anything other than maybe a meat-cutting competition? We’re off to a terrible start.

robbie.jpg
Robbie Carrico

Robbie Carrico is a former boy bander. Of course, he looks more Nickelback than N’Sync these days. His voice? It’s pretty good, actually. It looks like there could be another resident rocker — maybe this season’s Bo Bice.

With the support of Randy, Paula and Simon, it’s off to Hollywood for Robbie. And, if you want a spoiler, check this out.

7:13 p.m.

As far as the guys are concerned, after Robbie, it’s a string of nothing but “no, no, no.”

Will Ghaleb Emachah turn things around? I don’t think this Venezuelan has what it takes to be the American Idol. In fact, I don’t think he could even be positively entertaining if I were drunk — the state of mind Simon said it would take to enjoy Ghaleb.

Somehow, though, Randy is giving him a “yes.” It’s “no” from Simon … and Paula … of course she sends him through to Hollywood. It’s just the accent that’s holding him back, they say. Um, I guess I’ll have to agree to disagree.

corliss.jpg
Corliss Smith

Next up is the boy-crazy duo of Corliss Smith and Brittany Wescott.

Corliss chooses a jazz number, which she sings to Randy. It’s really entertaining, actually. She’s got a big, strong voice. She has something a little different to offer than the pop or country standards we’ve been hearing

Brittany has a decent voice, too. She sings to Simon, but I don’t think it’s as good as what Corliss brings to the table. Still, these two have some charm and talent that’s above what many other contestants bring into the room.

Simon gives them both a thumbs up. It’s two “yes” votes from Paula, and an additional pair of “yes” votes from Randy. So, you’ll be seeing these ladies in Hollywood.

7:26 p.m.

Suzanne Toon, a 21-year-old single mother, hopes to bring singing back into her life. After a three-year break, she stands in front of Randy, Paula and Simon putting her heart into what she hopes will turn things around for her daughter. She certainly has a strong voice, but I don’t think she stands out enough in this crowd.

ramiele.jpg
Ramiele Malubay

Ramiele Malubay, on the other hand, does have what it takes. Her rendition of Natural Woman is not only one-of-a-kind, but it is shocking that such a big voice is coming from a small girl. Simon says, “no,” but Randy and Paula send her through. I hate to say it (OK, not really), but I think Simon may be wrong.

syesha.jpg
Syesha Mercado

7:37 p.m.
It’s day 2 in Miami, and there are plenty of people ready to get things going. First up is Syesha Mercado. Her father struggled with drug abuse, a story not so unfamiliar to many other contestants from this show.

Her song choice is another Aretha Franklin tune. And much like Ramiele, Syesha has a set of pipes that are worth hearing. In fact, she’s a bit more promising.

“I think she’s one of the best we’ve seen in Florida,” Randy said. And I agree. Fortunately, so did Simon and Paula … so … we’ll be seeing her again.

Natashia Blach also will be getting more TV time. It’s on to Hollywood for Natashia, too. And deservedly so.

ilsy.jpg
Ilsy Lorena Pinot

Ilsy Lorena Pinot gets similar treatment after singing a Rhianna hit. It was an interesting song choice, which was probably what helped her out. It looks like this year, once again, will feature a great batch of female singers. As far as the males, Omaha produced the best thus far — at least from what we’ve seen up to this point.

7:45 p.m.

Follow up all those phenomenal female singers with several male singers who would get kicked out of a drunken night of open-mic karaoke. It’s not good. At all. Seriously, dawg.

“I’m tempted to say come back in a dress,” Simon said to one contestant. (I guess you can forget about what I was saying earlier today.)

After all that, top 20 finalist from American Juniors Julie Dubela enters the room hoping for another chance on reality TV with Ryan Seacrest. Her version of Me and Bobby McGee just doesn’t cut it. It’s a little too cheesy and over the top. And her outfit? Do I really need to start talking about clothes, already?

It’s “no” to Julie. But Simon does suggest she has a possible chance for a strong acting career. And the flashback footage to American Juniors actually is quite good. What happened to her 12-year-old voice? She certainly has, er, had vocal talent at some point.

7:56 p.m.

With only one contestant left, it’s clearly obvious Miami will end on a low note. Comedian Brandon Black hoped his singing would impress the judges more than his jokes. Of course, his singing was a complete joke, too. His white suit and the entire gig is just ridiculous. But he got some TV time, which clearly was what he wanted. So, good for you, Brandon. Mission accomplished. I guess.

Even though Brandon didn’t make it, there were 17 golden tickets to Hollywood handed out at the Florida auditions.

BEST OF THE NIGHT:
There were several good contestants tonight, especially considering the string of female powerhouses — Ramiele Malubay, Syesha Mercado and Ilsy Lorena Pinot — and judging by speculation of the Top 24, we’ll be seeing at least a couple of these ladies through several more weeks. And that’s a good thing. So, who’s my favorite from tonight? That has to be Syesha, a Nadia Turner (and I’m not just talking the hair) type contestant. She certainly should do well.

, , , , , , , ,

Live blogging: ‘American Idol’ auditions fly into Omaha

Tuesday, January 29th, 2008

Corn. Cows. And a few good singers? We can hope.

Tonight Ryan Seacrest and his buddies hit the heartland in search of a Nebraskan or two to make American Idol Season 7 worth watching.

7 p.m.

There are 10,000 hopefuls waiting in line, and the corn-fed Nebraska jokes are certain to be a big part of tonight’s episode. Paula Abdul, however, seems to be missing. Her delayed flight means Simon Cowell and Randy Jackson will have to run the show without her … at least for now.

chris.jpg
Chris Bernheisel was promised a chance to report live for the Omaha Fox affiliate. But that was a promise made by Simon, so will it really happen? I hope not.

Chris Bernheisel has waited a lifetime for a moment like this. Oh, and he should have waited a few more lifetimes. The first singer in the audition room is a big fan of Kelly Clarkson — he even brought a photo album of pictures with the original American Idol winner. The Fremont, Neb., native has a personality, so they say, but the voice. Please. Make. It. Stop.

7:12 p.m.

Paula still hasn’t arrived, but some other freaks are waiting their turn. And then there’s Jason Rich, a 21-year-old from tiny Stout, Iowa.

His version of Keith Whitley’s biggest hit would be phenomenal — but he can’t remember the lyrics. Nerves are getting the best of this guy, who certainly seems like he would be the ideal candidate for the show. Still, he can’t get past a couple of lines of the song. And I think we all know what that means — hitting the door without the golden ticket. Or not.

Somehow Simon and Randy were willing to give him another show. According to reports earlier this week, he won’t make it farther.

jason.jpg
Jason Rich

Finally, Paula has arrived.

7:18 p.m.

rachael.jpg
Rachael Wicker

Rachael Wicker is a six-time arm-wrestling champion. For her Idol audition, it’s another country song. We are in Omaha, after all. Let’s bring on the stereotypes, why don’t we? Even without Simon’s vote, Rachael makes it to Hollywood Week.

First, though, she arm wrestles Paula. And Paula comments on her soft skin. This is such a bizarre show at times.

7:25 p.m.

From an arm wrestler to a former professional wrestler. OK, the bizarre antics continue. Sarah Whitaker of Council Bluffs, Iowa, may have been a professional wrestler. But a professional singer she never will be. Maybe this is the reason Idol never has been in Omaha before.

After Ryan and Paula trade places — ugh, already — Samantha Sidley takes her turn. She sings Norah Jones’ Don’t Know Why. And, even though she’s a little shy, it’s a pretty good rendition. Of course, the judges and Ryan continue on with their antics while Samantha is left waiting.

But the wait was worth it. Because Samantha is going to Hollywood.

Three more singers walked into the door, and three more people were sent through to Hollywood — Elizabeth Erkert, Denise Jackson and Michael Sanfilippo. Of course, as Elizabeth walks away, she tells the cameras she can’t wait to prove to Simon she can be America’s Next Top Model. Reality TV clearly has taken over the minds of America — even in the cornfields of Nebraska.

angelica.jpg
Angelica Puente


7:36 p.m.

Angelica Puente moved in with her grandma in Wisconsin after disagreements with her father. The 17-year-old wants to reconnect with her father, who supported her trip to the auditions financially, even though they aren’t talking. Her rendition of Celine Dion’s Power of Love was enough to win over the judges.

After the audition, Ryan calls Angelica’s dad to let him know … She’s going to Hollywood! It’s a sweet story, but Angelica isn’t good enough to top the list of females in the competition. Her nerves never would allow it. Plus, she’s trying way too hard to be Celine Dion.

davidcook.jpg
David Cook

7:46 p.m.

David Cook, a 24-year-old from Tulsa, Okla., was inspired by Chris Daughtry. He feels his voice is strong enough to carry him into the next round. Could he be this year’s resident rocker? Again, I reference a report from earlier this week that suggests maybe David will be gracing out TV screens for a few more months … sorry if I ruined a potential surprise. (Who knew there were spoilers in reality TV?)

7:54 p.m.

Until now, we haven’t seen too many terrible auditions. I guess tonight they decided to pack them into the end of the episode. And, for a second, I thought we maybe would escape the worst Omaha had to offer. But I was wrong.

leomarlowe.jpg
Leo Marlowe

The final singer of the Omaha auditions was Leo Marlowe from small town Charlotte, Iowa. The openly gay (we can only assume) contestant said, “My mom always said she raised the perfect homecoming queen, too bad it wasn’t one of her daughters.”

Leo sang A Song for You to earn his golden ticket to Hollywood. Could it be the time for Idol to finally embrace an openly gay contestant? Previous contestants have come out after their time on the show — R.J. Helton and Jim Verarros, just to name two — and suggest Idol producers would not let them focus on their sexuality.

“You’re very open, you’re not defensive,” Simon told Leo after his audition.

In all, 19 Omaha contestants were given the chance to hop on a plane to California for Hollywood Week. Tomorrow night, the auditions hit Miami to search for even more Idol hopefuls.

TONIGHT’S ONE TO WATCH:
It was a strong night for the guys, including this year’s obvious resident rocker. David Cook, who said he watched Chris Daughtry’s audition the night before his turn in front of the judges, is my favorite from tonight. I think he’s on track to be an audience favorite this season. I’m just not sure how he’ll handle a Motown week or anything country. Only time will tell.

, , , , ,

Live blogging: ‘American Idol’ auditions hit Charleston

Wednesday, January 23rd, 2008

And … we’re back.

Tonight Ryan Seacrest and the American Idol gang hit Charleston, S.C.

7 p.m.
After the first contestant had to leave the line because his wife’s water broke, Raysharde Henderson enters the room. He thinks he’s Clay Aiken. Of course, he’s not.

“God, it did remind me of Clay Aiken,” Simon said. “… I wouldn’t have been surprised if you would have done a magic trick in between.”

OK, Simon. That definitely was a good one. And I agree.

deanna.jpg
Deanna Prevatte

Next up is a waitress from Kellie Pickler’s hometown. Deanna Prevatte, 26, has the same silliness as Kellie, but she doesn’t have the pipes — at least not to sing Fancy. But she tried, even though she seemed a bit angry. Enthusiasm was lacking, to say the least.

So, unlike the last three cities, Charleston didn’t get started on a high note — at least not one that was in tune. Back after the commercial …

7:11 p.m.

Here comes a nerdy couple. Guess where they met? The American Idol Web site message boards. Oh, goodness.

couple.jpg

Randy Stark and Crystal Ortiz

Randy Stark and Crystal Ortiz probably should keep it to the message boards. Because, they were not good. And Randy probably should stop giving advice on the message boards, as it turns out.

Another couple is up next — this time it’s a brother and sister team. The two are a little outrageous. This is going to be great.

Michelle and Jeffery Lampkin, as it turns out, are really pretty great singers. As a duet, they have something to offer. I’m not sure about solo artists. Together, though, they’re entertaining. Maybe it’s just the enthusiasm. But Jeffery definitely shines.

“Dawg, I thought you were the bomb,” Randy Jackson said. ” … Yes, to Jeffery.”

“I say ‘yes’ to Jeffery, and ‘yes’ to Michelle,” Paula said. And Simon agreed.

“I can’t split you two up,” Simon said.

7:23 p.m.

If they don’t sound bad enough on their own, make them sing a Carrie Underwood song. Yikes.

A captain on her high school dance team, 16-year-old Amy Flynn, is up next. After she’s done preaching abstinence (what’s up with that this season?), Amy takes on Reflections by Christina Aguilera. It’s not perfect, but she does have a sweet, innocent voice in there somewhere.

“I, personally, thought the song was too big for you,” Simon said. “… A lot of people are going to find you annoying, Amy.”

Still, Simon votes “yes.” As does Randy.

7:35 p.m.

london.jpg
London Weidberg

London Weidberg, 24, took care of her father until he died. A professional musician, she put her life and career on hold for her family. Now, she’s singing Billie Holiday to try and win over the judges.

Randy’s not sure it’s the best. Paula liked it. So did Simon, though he thought she was like a million other singers.

Still, it’s “Welcome to Hollywood!” for London.

London was one of 15 contestants to make it through on the first day of auditions in Charleston. Still to come, a baby’s bound to be delivered (they’re really milking that storyline tonight), and more terrible singers. How much longer until Hollywood Week? I’m getting a bit anxious.

DAY 2 — 7:42 p.m.

“I am expecting better today,” Simon said as the judges entered the room.

First up is Air Force pilot Lyndsey Goodman. She already has the military connection going in her favor, but can she sing? She tries with Black Velvet. I’m not sure she’s good enough for Idol. Nor do the judges, which surprised me.

aretha.jpg
Aretha Codner

She was named after Aretha Franklin, and she claims to be as good as Fantasia. So, why wouldn’t Aretha Codner try to sing some Whitney Houston? Even after messing up the lyrics, she carries on with her audition. It wasn’t good — not as bad as some of the folks entering this room — but it’s not good.

It’s an obvious “no” to Hollywood.

Joshua Boson
is worse. His rendition of Jennifer Hudson’s Dreamgirls hit is a disaster. You’re not going to love him.

“I can sing something else,” Joshua proclaims, trying to make a case for himself. “… This show is fake and rigged.”

Of course, the baby is going to make it into the judging room. Even if the military factor didn’t work for Lyndsey, this guy has an almost guaranteed chance of making it before he sings a note. Talk about unfair early exposure.

7:56 p.m.

With the end of Charleston auditions nearing, it’s not looking so good for most of the folks entering the room. They’re mostly exiting without the golden tickets. There are tears. And disappointment.

oliver.jpg
Oliver Highman

But, as you would expect, Oliver Highman returns to the auditions as a new father. I have been annoyed by this story all night, but I must admit I kind of got chills when Oliver started singing. There are few men in this competition who are memorable. Unfortunately, Oliver isn’t really one of them — no matter how hard the producers pushed his story.

I have to admit I’m shocked he didn’t get through to Hollywood.

Still, somehow, 23 people made it through from Charleston. Next stop, Omaha.

Best of the night: Honestly, there weren’t a lot of memorable auditions from tonight — good or bad. One of the good singers who did stand out was Jeffery Lampkin, who auditioned with his sister Michelle. Still, I don’t think he’s good enough to be the Season 7 winner. From what we saw tonight, I think it’s safe to say the winner likely will not be from the Charleston auditions.

, , , ,

Live blogging: Idol auditions take on San Diego

Tuesday, January 22nd, 2008

sandiego1.jpg
Will one of these American Idol wannabes from the San Diego auditions walk away the winner later this season?

We’re back. Tonight it’s San Diego where Randy Jackson is just waiting to yell, “You’re going to Hollywood!” Let’s get it started.

7 p.m.

“It was a total Idol invasion,” Ryan Seacrest said. More than 12,000 hopefuls were waiting by 9 a.m.

First up is Tetiana Ostapowych (the names this season, I mean, c’mon). Tetiana sings a confident, if nothing else, rendition of Someone to Watch Over Me. She’s a little like the independent singers of today — her voice is a bit unique and she has the looks to sell some records. Is she good enough?

“I don’t think you’re as good as you think you are,” Simon said.

Still, it’s three “yes” votes. And Tetiana is off to Hollywood.

Single dad Perrie Cataldo, 27, is the next in the room. His daughter listens through the door as he sings Boyz II Men’s I’ll Make Love to You. His heartbreaking story is what makes this show popular, and his voice certainly could keep him in the competition among the other men through thus far …

“Dude, yes, you’re on,” Randy said. And Simon and Paula agree.

7:11 p.m.

Michael Johns is first up after the commercial break. He has the looks, a strong voice — a little rock, not quite Daughtry, but still a good singer.

“A hundred, million percent yes,” Randy said. And it’s through to Hollywood. But … the bad singers are just around the corner.

That corner, as it turns out, is less than 10 seconds away. Bad audition after bad audition, there’s nothing good about the people coming through the doors. Then there’s Valerie Reyes, who thinks she’s Mariah Carey. I can’t figure out why people think they can sing like the world’s megastars. It’s just sad.

“Oh. My. God,” Simon said.

“I hope that’s good and not bad,” Valerie said.

“Yeah, it’s not,” Simon replied.

Now, I must take a few moments to talk about Randy Jackson’s unfortunate facial hair. I’ve let this go far too long. Randy, I’m not sure who’s giving you style advice, but the facial hair makes me think you’re about to star in a 1970s throwback film. But I’ll stop judging and leave that to you. It’s just a little difficult at the moment.

7:20 p.m.

There’s a mime. On TV. Are you watching this?

And a crawfish costume? Or was that a lobster? Wowza!

Now there’s someone trying to sing Whitney Houston. It’s Monique Gibson, and guess what? Yeah, she can’t sing like Whitney Houston. So she tries Mariah Carey. Then Brandy. I’m not sure she could sing Mary Had a Little Lamb in a kindergarten choir.

Next up is Christopher Baker, who’s creepily screaming and reaching for notes that don’t exist. Clearly he and Monique were a support system for one another, and they didn’t ask for outside help. From people who can sing, you know?

“Why are you staring at me when you sing?” Simon asked. “… There’s not a single person on planet Earth who would pay to hear you sing.”

So, he continues.

“Out of tune,” Randy said. “Out of tune.”

“Out of tune,” Paula adds. And he just keeps singing.

The last contestant of the day, a Mikalah Gordon look-alike (sort of), is Samantha Musa. She chooses to sing an Aretha Franklin tune while her sister shares a seat with Simon.

Samantha is really good, actually. She doesn’t sound like Mikalah Gordon, but she certainly has promise this season. And it’s off to Hollywood for Samantha. So, the end of San Diego’s first day wraps on a good note.

DAY 2: 7:34 p.m.

Blake Boshnack has auditioned in 10 cities or so, and he still hasn’t been able to get through. But his mom, Leslie, always is by his side. So, Stand By Me was the obvious choice this time around. Will there be another try?

“We’re fine,” his mom said.

“There’s always next year,” Ryan said.

After another hour of dreadful auditions and broken hearts, contestant 8000 walks into the room. It’s a very free-spirited man who has dreamed of this moment. It’s Alberto Hurtado, who performs an original song, Live.

“It was so quiet and soft, I could barely hear you,” Randy said. Well, I could hear Alberto. And it was as bad as you would imagine.

Fortunately for us, it was a “no.”

7:47 p.m.

Remember Anthony Federov? He almost lost his chance to sing due to problems with his voice. Well, it’s a similar story for 16-year-old David Archuleta, who suffered from injured vocal chords a couple of years ago. Now he’s singing on Waiting on the World to Change and hoping to impress the judges.

“I actually think, man, all things considered, you sounded pretty good,” Randy said.

“You have a nice tone,” Paula added.

“I thought it was a great choice for a song,” Simon said.

So, it’s three “yes” votes and, “Welcome to Hollywood!” from Randy.

I’m not sure how far David will make it this season, but he definitely has the story. And the looks. And the age — there are few young teens going to Hollywood thus far this season.

7:55 p.m.

There’s one contestant left to see. It’s tattoo artist Carly Smithson, who auditioned in Las Vegas and made it through during Season 5. She later was disqualified because she didn’t have her U.S. citizenship in time.

So, does she still have it?

Um, yes. The answer is 100-percent yes. In fact, I say Carly is the one to watch. Not just from tonight, but she’s also the one to watch based on the previous Season 7 auditions.

“That wasn’t as good as two years ago,” Simon said. Still, he said “yes.”

“Carly, you’re brilliant,” Paula said.

In all, 31 people made it through from the San Diego auditions. That’s 84 people so far this season.

, , ,

American Idol premiere drops in ratings

Thursday, January 17th, 2008

judges_11.jpg

American Idol returned to television Tuesday, but not as many viewers seem to be tuning in this season. Still, Idol remains at the top of the list.

Tuesday’s premiere, which focused on auditions in Philadelphia, had only 33.4 million viewers tuning in, down 4 million viewers from the first show, according to reports from Nielsen Media Research. In a year when a writers strike in Hollywood has been putting a dark cloud over the future of television, Idol still is the most-watched show on television (sports excluded).

In fact, more people tuned in to Tuesday’s episode on Fox than were watching ABC, CBS, NBC and the CW combined. But, considering the writers strike, I thought ratings would be up. Still, 33.4 million is not reason enough to stop producing a show, right?

Live blogging: Idol auditions take on Texas

Wednesday, January 16th, 2008

dallas.jpg

Philadelphia is behind us. Dallas is upon us, and there are bound to be a few scary auditions as Season 7 of American Idol rolls on. Let’s just hope we can pick out a few stars in the Lone Star state.

7:03 p.m.
First up is Jessica Brown, a 24-year-old mother of two. Here’s the back story: She overcame drug abuse, got her life in order and credits it to Carrie Underwood’s Jesus Take the Wheel. Typical of a wannabe Idol winner.

It turns out she’s quite good. Jessica may get lost in the crowd, but for now, she’s standing out.

“Everybody is so emotional right now, because they didn’t think I’d ever, ever be here,” Jessica said after she got her golden ticket.

paul.jpg
Paul Stafford

Next up is roller coaster enthusiast Paul Stafford. He, too, was inspired by a former Idol contestant — Elliott Yamin. Unfortunately, his rendition of Wait for You is nowhere near what Elliott has to offer.

Just leave it to Paula to have something positive to say: “That was a very joyful audition,” she said.

7:15 p.m.

The former Idol contestant wannabe roller coaster rolls on. There’s someone who thinks she’s a little like Kelly Clarkson, and someone who looks a lot like Carrie Underwood. That person is 16-year-old Alaina Whitaker. The Tulsa, Okla., native performs. And, yes, she is a great country singer.

The judges are a little tough on Alaina: “I thought it was a good audition,” Simon said. “I don’t think you’re as good as you think you are.”

But she makes it through. And that’s a good thing.

7:27 p.m.

Bruce Dickson has never kissed a girl. But the 19-year-old has good looks and the things it would take to win the hearts of a few girls. His voice is good, but not ready for radio.

“I don’t see you as this R&B, bluesy singer,” Paula said. “I’m not sure who you are as an artist.”

So, no ticket for Bruce. But, oddly enough, plenty of jokes about not being a man because he hasn’t been kissed. Surprising from this family friendly crew.

pia.jpg
Pia Easley

Pia Easley is a model, singer and many other things. She has the soul of Nadia Turner, and she certainly could fit into the Idol equation.

“I thought that was a very good audition,” Simon said. “I like you … you’re interesting.”

If Pia makes it far in the competition, she certainly will be an interesting one to watch. Her personality, look and all things about her just scream fan favorite.

7:37 p.m.

Brandon Green is a little strange. He peels his fingernails and collects them in a plastic bag. But the good news is he can sing. His version of Rich Girl by Hall & Oates is interesting at the very least.

Simon, of course, says he’s “forgettable.” But I think he also said something like that to Jon Peter Lewis. And Brandon certainly could be a Jon Peter Lewis-esque character — without the pens in his pocket. I guess a fingernail collection will do.

kayla.jpg
Kayla Hatfield

Next up is Kayla Hatfield, who seems a little far out there. Her audition is a complete wreck — but Simon says “yes.” What? Seriously? Why are we even entertaining this? Did you not see yourself rolling your eyes, Simon?

Paula gives Kayla a “no.” And Randy plays into the goofiness of it all and sends her to Hollywood. This is why some people hate this show, in case anyone was wondering.

7:50 p.m.

It’s one horrible audition after another.

Then comes in the last audition of the day, Kady Malloy. The 18-year-old does vocal impressions, including Britney Spears and Shakira. Her Britney impersonation actually is quite good.

When Kady has her turn to sing like, well, Kady, she sings a Carrie Underwood tune and sounds like Carrie Underwood. Simon stops her. She tries another and Simon says, “I think, of all the people we’ve seen this year, you’re the best we’ve seen this far.”

I will say Kady is one of the more talented singers, but I think Simon may be sneaking a few sips of whatever Paula has been drinking.

8:01 p.m.

Douglas Davidson is a 28-year-old student from Austin, Texas. He is concerned with ruining his voice, because he read a Christina Aguilera video this one time … Oh, good grief.

When Douglas finishes his warm-up, he does what every voice-saving singer would do — try to sing Bon Jovi. Have I mentioned how painful these auditions can be? Maybe that’s just me. “What the bloody hell was that?” Simon asked. OK, good. Simon is back to himself in day 2.

8:14 p.m.

Kyle Ensley is a junior at Oklahoma State University and a wannabe politician. He went on an all-day campaign to try and get himself in position to be the next American Idol. Simon bought it.

“I thought it was very academic,” Randy said. “… I’m going to say no.”

So, that’s a yes from Simon, a no from Randy and … “What the heck, I say ‘yes,’” Paula said. Again, I must mention this is not a good idea. This marks the second time in Dallas where Simon has used his power for wasting my time.

8:20 p.m.

A not-so-enthusiastic Tammy Tuzinski walks into the room to perform Power of Love by Celine Dion. But wait, instead, she starts singing (and I use that term loosely) If You Ask Me To. Apparently Tammy hasn’t been reading this blog. If she had, she would have known it’s a terrible idea to sing Celine Dion. Ever.

In case anyone else forgot, Mariah Carey and Whitney Houston are out, too. And I don’t care much for former Idol winner songs being repeated in the audition room. You’re just setting yourself up for comparison.

colton.jpg
Colton Swon

Colton Swon walks in to sing Boondocks by Little Big Town. The current country hit is a perfect fit for Colton, who also has the look and style that easily could be molded into the American Idol model.

“I thought it was OK, Colton,” Simon said. “I think there are a lot of guys like you singing in bars across America.”

I think Simon is right, but I also think Colton could have what it takes to grow and mature into a possible contestant worth watching if he survives Hollywood Week.

8:29 p.m.

Idol treats us to a lot of singers who aren’t that great, including a woman who used to be a man and a man who dresses like a woman. Just when you thought, “What this show needs is a farmer …” Wait long enough, and Drew Poppelreiter will show up.

“Farmin’, it’s in my blood,” Drew says before singing George Strait’s Check Yes or No. So, will it be yes? Or no?

Simon says “no.” Randy says “yes.” And it’s up to Paula, once again. “You know what, Drew, I’m going to say ‘yes,’” she says.

“Dude, I did it. I freakin’ made it. I’m going to Hollywood,” Drew said. “How about that?”

Next up is Kyle Reinneck, who claims to be a rocker. Of course, nothing says hard-core rocker dude like Kelly Clarkson’s Never Again. Don’t get me wrong — I think we all know Kelly Clarkson can rock — but this is not the kind of song you want to try and sing when you claim you’re hard-core.

“It’s a definite no,” Simon says. Two more of those, and he’s out the door.

8:43 p.m.

After the commercial break, we’re back with a bunch of Kelly Clarkson songs performed by a bunch of people who can’t sing. Actually, it’s just Since You’ve Been Gone. But the many different tones — all way off, of course — make it seem like many different songs.

nina.jpg
Nina Shaw

Then there’s Nina Shaw, who also hails from Kelly Clarkson’s hometown, Burleson, Texas. She sings a version of Whitney Houston’s I Turn to You. The judges aren’t completely impressed, but this girl really can sing.

Randy sees something in her, though. So it’s “yes” from him. “No” from Simon. And another “yes” from Paula. It’s on to Hollywood. So, could Nina be just like Kelly Clarkson, a contestant Simon almost overlooked in Season 1? It’s probably a little too soon to tell. I’m not seeing it just yet, though.

8:51 p.m.

After the final commercial break of the night, there’s one more contestant — perhaps the most outrageous of the night. He’s wearing a ridiculous costume, and I just can’t wait to hear what Simon has to say.

Oh, wait. I just realized his feather hat has wings. What?!

birdman.jpg
Renaldo Lapuz

So, Renaldo Lapuz, 44, starts singing, or “singing,” depending on how you see it. There’s no need to say it, but it’s a horrible screeching of a noise. And the judges encourage it with dancing and continuing to have Renaldo repeat the song. OK, now it’s getting entertaining. Paula is doing some kind of stomp dance … Now that’s entertainment.

“I have a horrible feeling that’s going to be a hit record,” Simon says with a laugh. Watch out, William Hung. Because Simon frequently knows what he’s talking about … I’m not buying it, should Renaldo get some kind of deal.

There may not have been a golden ticket for Renaldo, but 24 people from the two-day Dallas auditions were advanced to the Hollywood rounds. Next stop on the Idol search, San Diego. Until then, keep it here at watchingamericanidol.com to read the latest news and opinions about the show.

ONES TO WATCH:
Pia Easley certainly stood out more than any other contestant. She has a look that’s easy to remember, and the girl can sing. That’s what it’s all about, after all. Of the other 23 to make it through to the next round, let’s keep an eye on Colton Swon and Nina Shaw. The finalist I’d like to forget? That would be Kayla Hatfield. She’s just too much for me.

, , , , , ,

American Idol Season 7: Here we go, again

Tuesday, January 15th, 2008

Well, it’s the moment you’ve been waiting for since Jordin Sparks was crowned the Season 6 winner. This season, the American Idol crew traveled to San Diego, Dallas, Omaha, Atlanta, Charleston, Miami and Philadelphia in search of the next American pop star.

So, here we go … Welcome to the first night of live blogging for American Idol Season 7.

7:01 p.m.

“Somewhere in these massive crowds is this season’s winner,” Ryan said as cameras panned stadiums filled with Idol wannabes. While that winner is months away from being announced, the auditions had to start somewhere. This season — the first stop is Philadelphia.

philly1.jpg
One of the many interesting contestants to show up in Philadelphia.

7:06 p.m.

After losing 205 pounds, Joey Catalano was the first to enter the room in front of Randy, Paula and Simon.

“Based on the first round, I think you’ve done very well,” Simon said. And the season is off to a good start — Joey makes it to Hollywood.

7: 12 p.m.

Contestant 83754, Alaa Youakeem, came to America looking for an American girl. His rendition of a Bee Gees tune certainly was not a winner.

“I’m very impressed with how you phonetically learned the song,” Paula said, continuing her trend of trying to say only nice things. “… um … well …”

Good grief, Paula. Just say it. Alaa, you can’t sing.

alaa.jpg
Alaa Youakeem

7:16 p.m.

A backup singer for Taylor Hicks, Melanie, sings Unwritten by Natasha Bedingfield and finds herself going to Hollywood.

Then, as soon as the good leaves the room, James Lewis comes in wearing a mustard-colored suit. (It sort of reminds me of Margaret Fowler from last season.) The singing: Worse than William Hung. Way worse.

7:26 p.m.

After another commercial break — let’s not forget this show is known for these — there are plenty more bad voices. Men trying to sing like Mariah Carey. Women trying to be Whitney Houston. Nobody coming close to Carrie Underwood.

Junot Joyner comes into the room and starts off a little weak, but quickly turns the corner. So do a few other contestants, including Jonathan Baines, 17.

“You have a very good voice,” Simon said. And you know that means he’s good.

With a golden ticket in hand, Jonathan met his friends in the lobby to celebrate.

7:30 p.m.

Temptress Browne, a high schol middle linebacker (yes, as in football), enters the room. She’s a pet lover who’s hoping to make her sick mother proud. She attempts to perform And I’m Telling You by Jennifer Hudson. It’s awful, as you might expect. I’m having a bad feeling this song may come up again and again this season. I really hope that’s not the case, but I just have a feeling …

7:39 p.m.

Mark Hayes, 18, creates an interesting cricket sound with his voice. The cricket sound is much, much better than his rendition of White Christmas. (Seriously, a Christmas tune? Do I really need to explain how this is a terrible idea?) Needless to say, you probably won’t be seeing Mark Hayes on TV, again, any time soon.

Next up, Udgeet Sampat. Um, next, please? Seriously, I’m begging. Why do I torture myself during these early weeks? I just don’t know. It’s so terrible, I can’t even laugh.

OK, I do have to admit I have a little soft spot in my heart for the clips of several bad contestants singing their rendition of the same song. In the case of Philadelphia, that song was I Love Rock ‘n’ Roll. Good times.

7:50 p.m.

Once again, I’m frightened. There’s not much to say about Alexis Cohen, except the 23-year-old seems a little freaky — and not necessarily in a good way — when she walks into the room. Her voice? Not great, but definitely not terrible. Just different. But not even close to the worst we’ve ever heard. It’s just that her character is a little too far out for American Idol.

So, Alexis Cohen, it’s time for the door. And a rant against Simon. It’s the biggest outrage of the year, and it surprisingly took almost an entire hour to get there. Oh, wait, she gave the camera the finger. Two fingers, actually. So we got to see the little American Idol logos covering Cohen’s hands. Classy.

8:02 p.m.

Angela Martin, 26, has a touching story. She got pregnant when she was a senior in high school. Her daughter has a disease that complicates her growth. So, Martin is at the Philadelphia auditions with her family and friends by her side. There are a lot of tears.

“It’s not about fame for me. It’s about getting her the best care, the best therapists,” Martin said. “… I’m going to get that for her.”

Stevie Wonder’s Signed, Sealed, Delivered is her song of choice. And she’s really good. But is it good enough for Randy, Paula and Simon?

“It was a good audition,” Simon said. “… You’ve picked up a lot of bad habits. … You just need to de-weddingize.”

“Yes,” Randy said. “Yes,” Paula said. “Yes,” Simon said.

So far, it looks like Angela Martin is the one to watch. Of course, we probably haven’t seen all the best Philadelphia had to offer.

8:13 p.m.

It’s day 2 in Philadelphia, and the crowds are lining up. Randy, Paula and Simon take their seats.

Screamer after screamer after screamer enters the room. Then there’s the much-too-old Milo Turk, who entered the room wearing an outfit made for The Flintstones. His original song, No Sex Allowed, just had to be heard by the judges. It’s not worth talking about, really. Let’s just try to erase it from our minds.

8:20 p.m.

Kristy Lee Cook, a horse trainer and cage fighter, delivers a version of Amazing Grace. Another tough song, she sounds a little bit like LeAnn Rimes.

“I like you, and you’re very sincere,” Simon said.

Three “yes” votes means it’s, “Welcome to Hollywood!” for Kristy Lee Cook. She definitely could go far, if she can get her nerves in check.

8:27 p.m.

More bleeps from angry people who can’t sing.

Then there’s a creepy Paul Marturano, who sings a stalker-esque song he says he wrote for Paula Abdul. “I’m not really much of a talker … so I guess I’ll stalk her.” These are just a sampling of the lyrics. Honestly, the entire song is a one, big creepy joke. A rhyming joke that leads to security sending him packing.

On a more serious note, Beth Stalker from Grand Blanc, Mich., enters the room. She recorded an album at the age of 4, and she’s been singing in restaurants near her hometown as an adult. Even without Simon’s vote, backing from Randy and Paula are enough to send her to Hollywood.

Simon’s opinion is that she’s forgettable. At this point, I have to say I agree. We’ll see what Hollywood Week brings.

8:39 p.m.

After getting his entire body waxed, Ben Haar returns just to get some air time. He was going to sing Don’t Cha by the Pussycat Dolls. But Simon wasn’t having it.

Next up is Chris Watson, a 20-year-old from Dover, Delaware. His version of Uncle Kracker’s Follow Me is one of the best performances by a male this year. Praise from Simon, Randy and Paula means we’ll probably be seeing a little bit more of this smooth singer — at least a trip to Hollywood is in his future.

8:48 p.m.

In some mixed-up world, a Star Wars fanatic makes her way into a room. She’s as nerdy as you’d expect (no offense Star Wars fans). Christina Tolisano, 24, sings Don’t Let the Sun Go Down on Me as her grandparents wait in the hallway. She certainly doesn’t have the worst voice — remember the guy in the mustard-colored suit? — but she’s just not good enough.

It’s an obvious “no” across the board. “Give my love to the Wookie,” Simon whispers as she leaves the room. Then she cusses in front of her sweet, old grandparents. And I laughed. Does that make me a bad person?

Brooke White, a nanny to twin girls, is the last to enter the audition room for the Philadelphia round. Her version of Corinne Bailey Rae’s Like a Star is sweet and innocent, just like the singer herself.

“I thing we’re all saying a unanimous, ‘yes,’” Paula said. I honestly can say, I hope this girl does well.

That means 29 people are through to Hollywood from the Philadelphia auditions. And, from what we’ve seen, I have to say my odds-on favorite has to be Angela Martin. For tonight, she’s the one to watch.

Tomorrow, it’s off to Texas for the Dallas auditions. Until then, feel free to share your thoughts.

, , , , , ,

Simon Cowell talks about ‘Idol’ Season 7

Friday, January 11th, 2008
cowell_1.jpg

There are few people — if any — who would argue American Idol would be a done deal without Simon Cowell. His honesty and, sometimes, mean spirit are more than a small percentage of what makes the show such a success. People want to love — or hate — what he has to say.

This afternoon, Cowell had a lot to say during a short press conference to promote Season 7 of American Idol, which premieres Tuesday. The good news is the frown-faced judge says this really could be the best year ever.

“I think three or four of the contestants we’ve got this year would have gotten recording contracts even without Idol,” he said. “I think they’re that good.”

Simon continued to say, “The good news is that this is a much better season than last year … (it’s) one of the strongest years that we’ve had in a long, long time. It’s younger, I think the talent is more current, they’re more interesting people. So I go into this season a lot more optimistic than I went in last year.

Hopefully this season will be better than the last — though I do think Jordin Sparks is quite a talent. It’s just all those celebrity appearances clouded my vision to see the best of the best really shine.

, ,

About American Idol

There's not a bigger show on television. That means there's always something to say about "American Idol." From updates on past contestants to the choices of today's finalists, you'll find it all right here at watchingamericanidol.com. Weigh in on your favorites, and sound off on who should go next.

American Idol Author(s)
    » Reed-Dunn