It’s country music week, and Ryan Seacrest started the show on a less energetic note. He sent out thoughts to the victims and families of Virginia Tech. It was short and sweet, but it was nice to see “Idol” stop for a second to recognize the deadliest shooting in America’s history.
Martina McBride is tonight’s guest mentor. She’s a multi-platinum recording artist who certainly has a lot to provide to the top seven finalists. So, let’s get down to it.
Phil Stacey
Phil Stacey
“Where the Blacktop Ends”
Phil lived in Wichita, Kan., for a short time. It’s McBride’s home state (and mine, in fact), but does he have the country voice to make it work? The performance certainly was a lot better for Phil than some of his more recent offerings. In fact, it may have been the best he’s done this season. But, honestly, is it too late?
“Dude, you could have a career, a country music career,” Randy said.
“Well, it’s only taken 10 weeks Phil,” Simon said, going on to compliment the singer. “I don’t know if it’s going to be enough to save you, Phil.”
Jordin Sparks
Jordin Sparks
“Broken Wing”
“I can only imagine what it’s like to perform a song in front of the artist who recorded it,” McBride said.
Jordin has brought herself a long way in the competition, and the song choice certain was a good one. It seems she has been making all the right moves. This performance certainly was as stellar — if not better — than any of her other best weeks. Jordin is in it to win it, and she just might do it.
“Probably one of the most difficult songs to sing,” Randy said. “… Dude, that was the bomb. Another great performance.”
“I think you did a fantastic job, I really do,” Paula said. “… You built the song, and you did tell a story.”
“This is the first time since we have met where I actually believe, based on that performance, you could win ‘American Idol,’” Simon said. “It was that good.”
Sanjaya Malakar
Sanjaya Malakar
“Something to Talk About”
“My goal this week is to just do Bonnie Raitt justice,” Sanjaya said. So, why are you dressed like you’re about ready to clean houses? I’m not even sure what to say about the look. Or performance. It’s just creepy at this point. I can’t take this seriously. In fact, there’s nothing to talk about.
“That was just really like karaoke, dude,” Randy said. “It was very bland and boring for me.”
“Utterly horrendous,” Simon said. “I’m being serious. … It was as bad as anything we’ve seen at the beginning of ‘American Idol.’”
LaKisha Jones
LaKisha Jones
“Jesus Take the Wheel”
I’m not sure choosing songs by a former “Idol” winner is a good idea, especially when it’s basically a current hit by the most successful country “Idol.” But LaKisha did just that tonight. Her performance was decent, but it didn’t come close to comparing to the original version by Carrie Underwood. I’m not sure what to think about some of the choices LaKisha has made in the last few weeks.
“For me, this had some pitch problems in the beginning,” Randy said. “I think you could have done more with it.”
“Coming from where we’re sitting, I’m going to have to agree with what Randy said,” Paula said.
“It’s like eating a hamburger for breakfast,” Simon said. “It doesn’t go together. … It actually ended up like you were shouting at us.”
Chris Richardson
Chris Richardson
“Mayberry”
Choosing a Rascal Flatts song was smart. And, I think, choosing a lesser-known song by the country trio was an even better choice. Chris handled the song fairly well. I certainly think he may have helped himself, though I think he’ll still find himself among the bottom three contestants. But what do the judges think?
“You sang it OK,” Randy said. “… I just didn’t feel any connection, any sense of emotion.”
“The joy and the love you have on stage didn’t come through,” Paula said.
“I think sometimes this audience and me are hearing different things,” Simon said. “… What I heard was a very non-descript, nasally vocal.”
Melinda Doolittle
Melinda Doolittle
“Trouble is a Woman”
Is that Jennifer Hudson? OK, so Melinda definitely is back to a younger look this week. And she made a brilliant move by choosing a song that’s not extremely well known. Melinda can handle the music week after week. Her personality is starting to shine, again, too. So, I’d say this girl may be making some moves to position herself in the top spot.
“That’s another solid performance from our resident pro, Ms. Melinda Doolittle,” Randy said.
“Way to go,” Paula added.
“Melinda, I’m about to compliment you. And I’m going to ask you to lose the surprise,” Simon said. “It was fantastic. And I’ll tell you why. It was a great choice of song, I think you look … better than last week.”
Blake Lewis
Blake Lewis
“When the Stars Go Blue”
Country week certainly was going to be trouble for Blake more than anyone else. But, like a pro, Blake made this Tim McGraw song sound more like a pop ballad than a country song. There’s no doubt this guy deserves to be where he’s at in the competition. He is the best male singer this season.
“The arrangement suited you,” Randy said. “That was nice.”
“You kind of have the whole package,” Paula said. “You do. … It’s always fun to watch you.”
“It wasn’t a jumping-out-of-my-chair performance, Blake,” Simon said. “… It was OK.”
Who should get your votes? Jordin Sparks and Melinda Doolittle. These two should be battling it out for the title.
Who should go home? Sanjaya. There’s nothing else to say.
Who deserves another chance? Phil Stacey. But this is it.
American Idol, Martina McBride, Phil Stacey, Jordin Sparks, Sanjaya Malakar, LaKisha Jones, Chris Richardson, Melinda Doolittle, Blake Lewis