The Top 3 finalists made their way back home for the first time since making the American Idol finals, and it appears David Cook got the warmest of warm welcomes in Kansas City.
While there, Cook performed a pair of concerts, was grand marshal of a parade in his honor and performed at a Kansas City Royals game. It appears the Midwest is behind their own David Cook, simply based on these pictures from the festivities.
Even though he started the season off strong, Jason Castro couldn’t save himself this week on American Idol. His song choices, ultimately, were bad. And his performances weren’t much better.
I’m just glad America actually voted on talent this week — the Top 3 finalists, a pair of Davids and a Syesha, certainly are deserving of their spots.
While Jason was interesting way back in the beginning of Season 7, the last handful of weeks have shown him slipping more and more into that place where even he can’t believe what’s coming out of his mouth. This week, that included versions of Mr. Tambourine Man and I Shot the Sheriff. Um, how could he have survived?
“Jason, I’d pack your suitcase,” Simon responded after last night’s performance.
So, that means the remaining three will make their hometown visits this weekend. We already know big plans are underway for David Cook in Kansas City, and I’m sure celebrations will be equally large for David Archuleta and Syesha Mercado, as well.
American Idol, David Cook, David Archuleta, Syesha Mercado, Jason Castro, Simon Cowell
David Cook performs Tuesday night on American Idol. Plans are underway in Missouri to celebrate the finalist’s success this Friday.
If he survives tonight — and he will — David Cook will be welcomed home to Missouri with a celebration unlike many others.
According to the Kansas City Star, plans are underway for the finalists to play a free concert at 11:30 a.m. Friday in the Power & Light District. The concert will be followed by a homecoming parade, the David Cook Homecoming Celebration Parade and Concert to be exact, in his real hometown, nearby Blue Springs. The parade is scheduled to start at 3:30 p.m., and that concert is sold out.
Blue Springs is so thrilled with their hometown boy that the city even has set up a David Cook hotline for news and information. If you’re interested, the number is 816-655-0490.
While his day already will be quite packed, Cook also is expected to be at the Kansas City Royals game Friday night. He’s on deck to throw out the first pitch, and he may even sing a version of Take Me Out to the Ball Game. If, for some odd reason, Cook gets the boot tonight, all plans for his homecoming celebration will be canceled.
It was another slightly uncomfortable night for the four American Idol finalists still standing. Syesha Mercado was brought to tears. David Cook lost his groove. Jason Castro was, well, a disaster. And David Archuleta continued with his robotic performances to try and secure his spot in the finals.
Season 7 is a bit played out at this point. It seems obvious David Cook should win, but it was David Archuleta that had the best week this time around. And it was Syesha Mercado who took the second-place spot, based on talent and this week alone. If votes are based on that, it certainly will be Jason Castro who packs his bags this week, as Simon Cowell suggested he do.
But this is Idol, the popularity contest to end all popularity contests. Not even Miss America could compete with this type of popularity voting, really. This leads me to wonder if Jason will end up being saved by the throngs of fans who adore his dreads. And if Syesha, though a definite contender in recent weeks, will fall victim to the fact she’s been a bottom two or bottom three finalists for several weeks now.
All in all, though, tonight left a lot to be desired. There were no majorly impressive performances. I think maybe I’m just waiting for some kind of true wow factor to come through with anyone. And I’m not getting it. There’s no way producers still can be calling this the best season ever. Because, if you look at any of these finalists as a possible winner, they just don’t compare to at least two or three previous winners. But that’s just my opinion.
American Idol, Jason Castro, David Cook, David Archuleta, Simon Cowell, Syesha Mercado
Kristy Lee Cook, Brooke White and Syesha Mercado rounded out last week’s bottom three contestants. After Cook’s elimination, the other two women were left with four other contestants — David Cook, David Archuleta, Jason Castro and Carly Smithson.
After last week’s exit of Kristy Lee Cook, the Top 6 American Idol finalists are left standing. This week, they have mentor Andrew Lloyd Webber — and all of America, of course — to please.
7:01 p.m.
The band shifted positions this week, just a month before the new Idol winner will be crowned. Tonight, the finalists are up against a huge catalog of music from Braodway composer Andrew Lloyd Webber. This could be a huge challenge for the contestants, even though many former Idols have been Broadway bound after the show.
7:06 p.m.
Syesha Mercado is first to take the stage with One Rock ‘n’ Roll Too Many from Starlight Express. This is a perfect theme week for Syesha, who has a bit of an acting background, and certainly has the attitude for theater. While she’s delivering a commendable performance, it may not have been the most challenging of song choices. All in all, though, Syesha brought the look, the attitude and the vocal power tonight.
“This may surprise you, but I feel, tonight, not only is this your element — I think you could be a huge Broadway star — I think that was your best performance to date so far,” Randy said.
“This is your happy place, and you’re real good at it,” Paula said.
“Syesha, that was very sexy,” Simon said. “I think this was one of your strongest performances so far.”
7:15 p.m.
He’s still not so good with the interviews, but Jason Castro may be able to bring something interesting to Memories from Cats. The song certainly is one of the most popular hits from Broadway, and Jason is doing his thing with it. He has a distinct sound, but it doesn’t work for a male singer. This is a powerful hit song most often sung by female leads.
“Musically, vocally for me, it was a train wreck,” Randy said. “It’s just not the kind of song … it’s just not for you.”
“The reality was, it came over as a young guy being forced by your mom and dad to sing a song at a wedding you didn’t want to sing,” Simon said. “You were miserable throughout. I was partly miserable throughout.”
7:26 p.m.
She was in the bottom three last week, but will Brooke White be able to climb out of that spot this week? Her song choice is You Must Love Me from the movie version of Evita. This week could be the kiss of death for Brooke, who messed up her performance and had to, once again, for the second time this season, start over at the beginning of the song. If she survives this week, it will be a big shock. At this point in the competition, it’s just not OK to have the big of a goof-up moment.
Sorry, Brooke. But this should be the end for you.
“For me, this wasn’t great,” Randy said. “The one thing that I did like that you did was, at least you did listen to Andrew Lloyd Webber.”
“You must never start and stop,” Paula said. “Having said that, this is the biggest show in the biggest platform … what I did love about this performance, Brooke, was that you didn’t overact.”
“This is why I love live TV,” Simon said. “It was so dramatic at the beginning. The trouble was, Brooke, it threw you. … This is a tricky one. I think you’re going to be very disappointed when you watch this back.”
7:37 p.m.
David Archuleta certainly has the talent to tackle Broadway. The youngest contestant’s song choice this week is Think of Me, another popular Broadway hit written for a female lead. The Phantom of the Opera song possibly is Andrew Lloyd Webber’s best-known work. David’s arrangement of the song is an updated, much more pop-friendly version of the tune. And it’s a great move, I think, for David to put himself back in direct competition with David Cook, who has been stealing the spotlight in recent weeks. No worry, little David, this showing proves you really do deserve the praise you’ve been given. I’m sure your dad will be thrilled.
“What is really cool is you’re exactly what this show is about,” Randy said. “Dude, it was the bomb. This boy is the one to beat.”
“I think it was absolutely perfect, David,” Paula said.
“David, I thought it was pleasant,” Simon said. “One of your weakest performances over the live shows. It’s just not one of those performances you’re ever going to remember.”
7:47 p.m.
Coming off of her best performance in a while, Carly Smithson may not seem fit for Broadway. She is an interesting talent, though, so she may surprise us all. Her song choice was All I Ask of You from Phantom. But Andrew Lloyd Webber wasn’t having it — he suggested she go with her other choice, Jesus Christ Superstar. Ladies and gents, I think this could work …
Look out! Carly Smithson is back, people. Mr. Webber was right. This certainly was a brilliant song selection for Carly — the remaining resident chick rocker. She has the pipes to really wail and show some attitude. I think it works well for her. What about those three celebrity judges?
“It’s no surprise to me that the bigger voices are doing better tonight,” Randy said. “It was definitely good, and I like the outfit. I think the outfit’s kind of fly.”
“I love what you did in the chorus,” Paula said.
“It was actually one of my favorite performances of the night,” Simon said.
7:54 p.m.
Rounding out the night is David Cook. His song choice is The Music of the Night, which is another famous tune from Phantom. Do these people know not of Webber’s other major hits? Apparently not. But there’s no question David really could make something quite special happen with this song choice — or any for that matter.
OK, I have to say it was a brilliant song choice for David. It’s well-known, he’s well-liked and he, well, is making it happen. It’s practically flawless, really. That high note? That was the vote-getter of the night, if you ask me. There’s something about David’s performances that just put him on a completely different level from his competitors.
“I said it before, I’ll say it again,” Randy said. “If you can sing, you can sing anything. Dude, that was an amazing vocal performance.”
“I thought it was fantastic,” Paula said.
“David, I think you’ve made the most of the song,” Simon said. “This isn’t the side of you I like, but you made the most of the song you were given.”
WHO GETS MY VOTE: David Cook. He may get my votes from here on out. Why? He deserves to win this entire show.
WHO SHOULD GO: Sorry, again, Brooke White. But your time has expired. Syesha Mercado proved she deserves to be here and you, well, you choked. And that’s not OK, no matter what Simon says. In fact, if you don’t go, Brooke, it’s time for Jason Castro to say bye-bye.
American Idol, Andrew Lloyd Webber, Jason Castro, David Archuleta, Syesha Mercado, David Cook, Brooke White, Carly Smithson
Mariah Carey performs during last week’s Idol Gives Back charity event. This week the Top 7 Idol finalists take on Carey’s hits.
She’s the diva to end all divas — no, I’m not talking about Paula Abdul. It’s Mariah Carey week, people. This could be amazing — or tragic — but the time has come.
7:04 p.m.
First up is David Archuleta, singing I Believe. This week was almost meant for David, who clearly can reach some notes his male counterparts don’t stand a chance of reaching. However, when he tried to hit the highest notes in his arrangement, he didn’t quite make it. Still, he shouldn’t have any trouble sailing through this week.
“I was little worried about tonight … and you probably picked one of the toughest ones,” Randy said. “… You can sing anything. That was the bomb, baby.”
“It must feel great for Mariah to be able to hear your interpretation of her song,” Paula said.
“I have to agree,” Simon said. “I thought it was very, very good. I don’t think we’re in for a lot of laughs tonight, though.”
7:13 p.m.
Carly Smithson is up next. Her Mariah song choice is Without You, which should be pretty incredible. Tonight definitely could be her chance to really shine and get herself out of the bottom three. Instead of trying to reach the heights of Mariah, Carly was smart in giving a nice, subtle performance. Still, it was entertaining and a performance deserving of keeping her around for another week.
“I liked that you challenged yourself with this big song,” Randy said. “The only thing is you’ve gotta believe and trust in yourself that you’ve got that lower range, too.”
“I actually think that, I liked that you showed some vocal restraint,” Paula said.
“I really wanted to hear you sing this song, even before Mariah week,” Simon said. “… Now, the difficult part. Could you pull it off tonight? I didn’t think you did. Sorry, Carly. I think you’re capable of it. … I thought it was an OK version.”
7:23 p.m.
Now it’s Syesha Mercado, who could really shine this week. This type of music really is best fit for her. But is she good enough to really shine? We’re about to see … Syesha chose Vanishing, which is an older Mariah tune. It’s probably a good song choice, since it’s a little less known. As far as female contestants, Syesha is closest to being able to show a range similar to the superstar mentor. I think it’s definitely a decent performance, but she’s going to lose points for the comparison factor.
“I was really afraid when I heard you were going to sing that song, but I’ll tell you something, you did a good job all things considered,” Randy said.
“This week, I think you’ve been extremely smart,” Paula said. “… You’re smart because you picked a song not many people know and you’re not compared to.”
“I think it, once again, technically, it was very, very good indeed,” Simon said.
7:32 p.m.
In a sparkling outfit, Brooke White is taking the stage. They’re milking the fact Brooke missed her sister’s wedding this weekend. Brooke chose one of the toughest Mariah songs ever, Hero. It’s one of the more recognizable songs from Mariah — perhaps her biggest song — and taking it on could prove to be a great challenge.
Brooke’s performance, including playing along on the piano, certainly is her own version. It’s good she didn’t try to mirror Mariah’s incredible talent. But, while it’s a really good performance, I’m not sure it has enough power behind it to really wow the voting public. All in all, though, it was much better than I expected. Just a little dull.
“I like the fact that you brought the whole singer/songwriter to the thing,” Randy said. “I was digging it until the bridge. … I appreciate the singer/songwriter look.”
“Every ounce of you is totally authentic to who you are,” Paula said. “You’re identifiable.”
“Brooke, I don’t think you had much choice other than to do what you did,” Simon said. “Having said that, it was a bit like ordering a hamburger and only getting the bun. In other words, the vital ingredients, the bit in the middle, was missing.”
Now it’s Kristy Lee Cook’s turn. She’s taking on Forever, which happens to be one of my favorite Mariah songs of all times. That said, I’ll try to be a fair critic. Even though she is making crazy faces, I have to say Kristy Lee really nailed this one. In fact, I think it’s the best performance of the night. I’m not sure if it’s going to be enough to garner votes from those fans who haven’t been voting for her in the past, but it certainly is a deserving performance in my opinion. No, it’s not as amazing as Mariah, but it was clean, clear and crisp.
“I didn’t think that was amazing, but I gotta tell you you definitely started stepping up at the end,” Randy said.
“You know what, it wasn’t just the end,” Paula said. “I think you’re a very smart girl. … Kristy Lee Cook … I’m like blown away.”
“You didn’t give me chills,” Simon said. “I think you managed with what you could. It was a little bit whiny at times. … It just wasn’t great.”
Maybe it wasn’t great, but it was great for Kristy Lee. And maybe that’s what I heard.
7:46 p.m.
I’ve been intrigued by what David Cook would choose to sing this week since I heard Mariah would be the guest mentor. His song choice is somewhat surprising. Choosing Always Be My Baby even surprised Mariah. I’m not sure what I would have picked for David as an alternative, but I didn’t think this was going to turn out all so well. But it actually is pretty interesting. It sounds a little like Lifehouse, but I think David certainly “worked it out” as Randy said. He really drove home the song at the end, which solidified his performance and pure, raw talent. If you’re a guy who can sing Mariah Carey songs and make them not sound like Mariah Carey songs, well, then maybe you deserve an Idol crown. I’m just saying.
“Dude, you know what? I think more than almost anyone on this show right now, you’re ready to make an album,” Randy said.
“That’s pretty awesome,” Paula said. “That song could be on a movie soundtrack right now, it really could.”
“David, it was like sort of coming out of karaoke hell into a breath of fresh air,” Simon said. “It was original. It was daring. It stood out by a mile. And this is the sign of a great potential artist, someone who takes risks.”
7:56 p.m.
Jason Castro closes out one of the most interesting episodes of the season — at least when it comes to the mentor. Mariah gave Jason some advice for his rendition of I Don’t Wanna Cry. While I have not been the biggest fan of Jason’s performance the last couple of weeks, I do think this week was full of interest. He did the best job making a Mariah Carey song not sound like a Mariah Carey song — even better than David Cook, who certainly stole the show. But this performance should really keep Jason in the competition.
“For me, I didn’t really love that,” Randy said. “I felt like I was at a weird beach luau.”
“Jason, I’d love to be at the luau, listening all night long,” Paula said. “You’re getting so confident and in that zone.”
“Jason, I’m going to have to agree with Paula,” Simon said. “I thought that wasn’t the best vocal of the night. Having said that, it was identified with you … it was a cool version.”
WHO GETS MY VOTE: Without question, the “best of the night” honor goes directly to David Cook. There’s not another David (or Jason) in the competition who can compare. If you doubted the older David in the competition deserved to win this show, tonight should have changed that.
WHO SHOULD GO: This is going to be a tough week, and it may even result in another surprising elimination. I have to say, after hearing the recap performances, Kristy Lee Cook may be in trouble. But Brooke White wasn’t exactly a standout, either.
American Idol, Mariah Carey, David Cook, Brooke White, David Archuleta, Syesha Mercado, Jason Castro, Kristy Lee Cook, Carly Smithson
It was charity begging at its finest as celebrities gathered around the Kodak Theatre for a night of asking Americans (and Canadians, too) for pledges to help raise money as part of the second annual Idol Gives Back campaign.
There were American Idol contestants, former winners and a whole lot of celebrities. It was a recipe for a night like the Oscars — long-winded talks on stage and a few bad fashion choices. Of course, with Idol Gives Back there’s a little added singing. So, here’ s a look in pictures at tonight’s big fund-raising effort, which actually took place Sunday. Oh, and if you still want, there’s time to make a pledge.
For me, Sarah Silverman’s appearance was the highlight of the night. I think she’s a stellar comedian. So offensive, and so funny. She knows when and how and where to push all the right buttons — even at a charity event. What more do you want?
David Cook joined fellow Top 8 Idol finalists to sing a couple of songs. I thought it was interesting — and I really liked it, actually — when the group gathered around the piano to sing Seasons of Love from Rent. It’s a great song, and I couldn’t wait to hear who would sing the big female vocal part … and I was really surprised it was Kristy Lee Cook, at least in the beginning. What I can’t understand is the all-white outfits the contestants wore. Haven’t we been through this?
It’s Annie Lennox. Of course it was incredible. She’s timeless.
Carrie Underwood showed up fresh from bridesmaid duties, apparently. Aside from the Hypercolor-inspired dress, her performance was good. It certainly wasn’t her best, but it was far from terrible.
Speaking of terrible, am I the only one who is questioning Fergie’s choice of outfits? What’s up with the spandex-meets-pleather pants? I just didn’t get it. To make matters worse, the outfit initially was topped off with a matching jacket and some bizarre skirt-like device that added just a splash of color.
And the award for the longest skit without a point goes to … Miley Cyrus and Billy Crystal. Maybe I missed it, but I knew in the first few seconds it was going to be a “Who are you?” “No, who are you?” skit. But it still went on for 10 minutes. Waste of time.
Robin Williams‘ skit was not much better. It was entertaining that he used a couple of plays on words to sneak in some inappropriate language on the family friendly show.
And, finally, Mariah Carey, the diva herself. While I generally think Mariah is about the most amazing vocalist on the planet, I’m not sure why she had to cover her own ears when she was singing. I mean, c’mon, how do you expect everyone at home to listen when you can’t even stand the sound of your voice? Of course, her voice still is incredible. It’s just that she didn’t actually sing too much of the song. And was there a fan blowing her hair? And that sparkling microphone? Give me a break, Mariah. You’re making it hard for me to defend Glitter. (No, seriously. That movie wasn’t that terrible. Did you even see it?)
American Idol, Sarah Silverman, Billy Crystal, Miley Cyrus, Robin Williams, Mariah Carey, Fergie, David Cook, Carrie Underwood, Annie Lennox, Kristy Lee Cook
Season 7 American Idol finalists perform Sunday during a taping for this week’s Idol Gives Back.
It’s the beginning of another three-episode week, and American Idol will let another singer go. And maybe raise a few million dollars in between. This is Idol Gives Back week, and each of the finalists will sing an inspirational song.
7:02 p.m.
First up is Michael Johns, who had a great week last week. His song choice is Dream On, which seems like a somewhat obvious choice for him. I have to say I’m back to the point of saying, “What’s up with this guy?” That whiny, screaming stuff? I don’t get it.
“I really believe that this is one of the important weeks for us,” Randy said. “… It had some pitch problems for me.”
“I couldn’t disagree more,” Paula said, giving praise (no shocker there) to Johns.
“You know what, Michael, I thought it was a very good performance,” Simon said. “… I don’t like it when you do an impersonation of a rockstar.”
7:11 p.m.
Syesha Mercado is committing one of the biggest sins in the Idol game — and it’s not performing a Whitney song. No, she’s performing a song from a former Idol winner, Fantasia’s I Believe. Of course, it’s not a sin when you give a great performance, and I think Syesha did just that … I’m not quite sure about that crazy high note at the end. But it was a surprise. Judges?
“It was OK, just OK,” Randy said.
“Not many people can take on songs like that,” Paula said. “You flipped it a little bit and made it all your own.”
“Syesha, to be fair, of course there’s going to be a comparison,” Simon said. “Technically, I thought you sang it very well. However, what it lacked for me, was that big, big wave of emotion.”
Now it’s Jason Castro’s turn. He has chosen Somewhere Over the Rainbow, but not the version Kimberley Locke brought to the Idol stage. This is a completely different, more Hawaiian approach. I like Jason, I really do. But I have to say, this seems a little too far off from what is expected on this show. Jason’s performance seems a little more fit for a subway station or even a not-so-crowded coffeehouse. I’m just not sure this is the type of showing that can keep him out of the bottom three.
“Yo, I tell you what,” Randy said. “Dude, Jason Castro is back … that was crazy, molten hot.”
“You have the most definitive sound,” Paula said.
Simon thought it was “fantastic.” I wouldn’t go that far. But, of course, I think we know who’s sitting in the judging chair.
7:24 p.m.
Kristy Lee Cook is this year’s chance at a true country artist, but she’s struggled to find a song that really works for her. This week she chose Martina McBride’s Anyway. It’s a perfect song for Cook’s voice. While she’s no Martina McBride, this is the type of song that allows her to showcase her vocal talents in the biggest way possible. There are plenty of notes to hold out and big notes to nail. And she did it … the best she could.
“There were a couple of little pitch moments, but I loved that,” Randy said.
“I think you outdid yourself tonight,” Paula said. “This was your best by far.”
“I thought you were very, very good indeed,” Simon said. “I also think tonight, tonight you look like a star, Kristy.”
7:32 p.m.
Our Lady Peace is one of the best bands to come from Canada. And Innocent is one of their best songs. So, it’s fitting that David Cook, one of the best finalists on Idol’s Season 7 would choose to cover the song. Of course, he did it well. It was a nice, smooth change of pace for David. That said, it wasn’t as great as his previous two weeks … but how do you top those performances?
“I’m a huge fan of yours,” Randy said. “… I’m not sure this was one of your strongest weeks right here.”
“Tonight was no exception of you being so good,” Paula said. “You are so well defined as being the whole package. You are it.”
“David, I didn’t like this performance very much at all,” Simon said. “I thought it was a teensy, weensy pompous.”
The Show Must Go On by Queen is Carly Smithson’s choice. The song certainly fits her style — unlike that wacky outfit she’s wearing tonight. But I digress. No, wait. I can’t stop with the crazy, shiny gold belt. This performance is passable, but I’m not sure it’s all that phenomenal. I do think it will be enough to get Carly through to the next round, but she may end up in the bottom three …
“It ended up OK,” Randy said. “It was just OK for me.”
“There’s something I’m actually going to agree with a little bit,” Paula said. “Your voice, as always, is pretty much pretty perfect. I just didn’t feel engaged with you.”
“Carly, you look good,” Simon said. What? Really? Um, the gold belt. Is anyone else seeing this?
“I thought it was an unusual choice of song tonight. … You did lose control of the song there at the end,” Simon said.
7:46 p.m.
It’s David Archuleta’s turn to take center stage. His inspirational song choice is Angels. I actually think this was a wise song choice for David, who takes to the piano, adding a little extra drama. It also is aging him a little bit. It seems sometimes, no, almost all the time, David is trying to perform as if he’s a much older performer. As far as the quality of tonight’s performance, it was vocally where it needed to be. While subtle, the overall performance was pretty incredible.
“You know what I loved about this performance … when you did that little refrain at the end, that’s the David Archuleta I love,” Randy said.
“Best song choice of the night,” Simon said. “I’m not going to say it was your best vocal, however. … David, I’m nitpicking here, because you are going to sail through to the next round.”
7:54 p.m.
Closing out the night is Brooke White. She’s going to perform Carole King’s You’ve Got a Friend. Tonight, Brooke is mixing it up and letting someone else handle the piano playing. This is an interesting, slightly slow, version of this song. It seems Brooke maybe slowed the tempo a little too much. Maybe that’s not it, but something just doesn’t seem quite right. The song almost seems unrecognizable, and not in a good way. I’m a little bored with this one.
“For me, I don’t think it was your best performance,” Randy said.
“That song, I grew up to,” Paula said. “… I think it’s the perfect way to close the evening. Once again, you’re very definitive.”
“It was sort of like a pleasant walk in the park,” Simon said. “It was nice. Was it original? No. Was it pleasant? Yes.”
WHO GETS MY VOTE: It’s a tough one, but I think I may have to send this week’s honor over to David Archuleta, maybe? I actually thought Syesha Mercado provided another bright spot … but the Fantasia comparisons are going to be just a little too much for her.
WHO SHOULD GO: It maybe should be Jason Castro, based on tonight only. I definitely think Kristy Lee Cook earned her spot for one more week. But previous performances may not be forgotten.
American Idol, Brooke White, David Cook, Kristy Lee Cook, David Archuleta, Syesha Mercado, Carly Smithson, Michael Johns, Jason Castro
Last night I had a guest blogger, my friend Susan, sharing her thoughts on American Idol’s Top 9 contestants. Tonight, I’m back to share my thoughts on this week’s performances, which were mentored by Dolly Parton.
It was a great week for some — Michael Johns, Carly Smithson and Brooke White — and it was a little less exciting for others. Those others, including Ramiele Malubay and Kristy Lee Cook, just didn’t hold up. If one of these two female contestants goes home tonight, it will be no surprise.
So, let’s see how your votes came out.
7:58 p.m.
Things are getting a little bit of an early start tonight. In line with the theme, the Top 9 contestants are presenting their group performance of Dolly Parton’s 9 to 5. It’s a little less ridiculous, compared to other group performances … oh, wait. Yeah, if you’re watching, they did just gather around the judges as if they were in a high school show choir. Good grief.
8:04 p.m.
It’s time for the results. First up is Michael Johns, who had his best week to date, if you ask me. He actually proved why he was in this competition … and that’s been missing for me. To nobody’s surprise, he’s safe.
David Archuleta is up next. He, too, had one of his better weeks, at least in the last month. Obviously, he’s safe.
Now it’s Carly Smithson, who was one of my favorite singers from the night last night. It seemed she would be shown to the bottom three since she was the third contestant to hear her results tonight. But, rightfully so, Ryan sent her to safety.
8:14 p.m.
It’s time to take a few questions from fans calling into the show. Tonight’s questions are a little less interesting than in past weeks. What does Syesha miss about her home life? What other talent would David Cook want to have? Is there anyone Randy Jackson hasn’t worked with? Nothing too exciting, really.
Not only will Dolly Parton perform tonight, but the Clark Brothers also are taking the Idol stage after winning the FOX reality show The Next Great American Band. Their song choice, This Little Light of Mine, seems a little bizarre. Their entire performance is a far cry from what we’re used to hearing and see on this stage …
Now, back to the results.
There still are three spots left for the bottom three. Will David Cook take one of those spots? It’s no surprise, here, either. As it should be, David is safe.
Now it’s Ramiele Malubay’s turn. As it should be, she’s the first contestant to be sent to the bottom three. While she seems like a sweet girl, she just hasn’t hit her stride this season. I’m not sure what happened from Hollywood Week.
Kristy Lee Cook is prepared for her spot in the bottom three. Even though it was one of her better weeks, she still is headed to the bottom three. There’s no question she should be there.
8:29 p.m.
Idol returned to Nashville to see some past contestants that have gone on to make a career in country music. They caught up with Bucky Covington (Season 5) and Phil Stacey (Season 6). They also went to see rocker Bo Bice (Season 4), who credits Idol for his success.
“I’m just as proud to be a part of this alumni as can be,” Bice said.
There are just a few contestants left to find out the results. Up now is Syesha Mercado, who had a pretty good week with Dolly’s biggest song — I Will Always Love You. And the results? Syesha is safe.
That means it’s down to Brooke White and Jason Castro. Without question, Jason is the one who should round out this week’s bottom three. But that’s not how it’s going down. And wrongfully so. It’s at the point where the bottom three certainly could include some of the better contestants, but Brooke certainly has that little something different that’s really intriguing.
8:41 p.m.
Before Dolly performs or someone goes home, it’s time to promote Idol Gives Back, which begins next week. When it’s finally time for Dolly to take the stage, she performs Jesus & Gravity from her recent release, Backwoods Barbie. I’m not sure how she does it, but this woman continues to be an incredible entertainer, even at age 62. I can’t help but love me some Dolly Parton.
8:53 p.m.
Time is running out on tonight’s episode, and the journey has to end for someone. Randy thinks it will be Ramiele. Simon knows it won’t be Brooke.
The person going home tonight is … not going to be Brooke. She’s going back to safety, leaving her Idol roommates in the middle of the stage. Tonight, the journey ends for Ramiele Malubay. She just didn’t hit her stride past Hollywood Week. She certainly had a great start, but Ramiele quickly lost what it was that made her stand out in the beginning.
I’m not sure what happened — maybe it was the pressure — but I definitely think post-Idol, Ramiele will be able to record n album and make a music career for herself. Until then …
American Idol, Ramiele Malubay, Syesha Mercado, David Archuleta, Carly Smithson, Jason Castro, Michael Johns, Brooke White, Kristy Lee Cook, David Cook, Dolly Parton
American Idol’s Top 10 finalists — minus Chikezie — performed Dolly Parton hits tonight.
I’ve been a little busy today — OK, a lot busy … but more on that later — so I didn’t get to live blog. And I’m sad, because Dolly Parton is this week’s celebrity mentor.
And, even though I’m watching the show now, I’m having a guest blogger — my friend Susan — share her thoughts … and hopefully a few of my comments.
So, here we go:
Brooke White was up first tonight, performing Pardon’s “Jolene,” but only passably. Simon was perhaps a tad too harsh with his declaration that it was not good enough. I mean, clearly she’s one of the best contestants. It’s just sort of unnecessary to make her doubt herself.
Reed said David Cook’s performance was “kind of boring, I’m not gonna lie.” Cook performed “Little Sparrow” with his own arrangement. Before going on stage, he admitted his past weeks’ influences were other bands. That was a smart move. No one likes to see a performer take credit for other people’s work. One thing I think everyone can agree on is his new hairstyle. It’s better, right?
Itty bitty Ramiele Malubay belted out “Do I Ever Cross Your Mind?” I liked it more than the judges. Reed says that though he thinks this is the best performance she’s had on the show Malubay needs to go home. Oh, and Simon used the old cruise ship comparison when giving his opinion. Yeah, yeah.
Jason Castro picked a Dolly song I’m not terribly familiar with, “Traveling Through.” Sure, it was a bit Hanson-ey, but I kind of liked Hanson, so . . . yeah.
Carly Smithson knocked Reed’s socks off, but not all of the judges (Simon). I can’t believe Simon can listen to a performance as beautiful as Smithson’s and then pick on her for her outfit. Reed now says, “That was one of the top 10 best ‘Idol’ performances ever.”
David Archuleta, yeah, he was good. I just don’t like his sappy song choices. But, according to the judges, it was the best thing ever. I just don’t get it.
(Hey! Did you see Michael Kors in the crowd? He looked purple instead of orange. Weird . . . and awesome!)
Kristy Lee Cook should have rocked some Dolly, but she didn’t. Her rendition of “Coat of Many Colors” was “just not good,” according to Reed. Also not good, her fingernails. For the love of Sally Hansen, stop it with the half painted nails Kristy Lee!
So, Syesha Mercado fell into the trap that it seems happens almost every week. Look ladies, I don’t care if it’s Dolly week, you can’t do “I Will Always Love You” on Idol. Why? Because Whitney did it. You also cannot do Mariah or Christina. The judges will crucify you every time.
Michael Johns. Oh, Michael Johns. Michael Johns . . . how you doin? It certainly IS “Alright.” That’s all I’ve got to say. Oh, and Reed now admits that Johns is “good.”
My work here is done.
Tonight, they’ll sing songs from the year they were born. It should be a good night for American Idol. At least they’re not going for, yet, another week of Beatles songs. That really hasn’t worked for some of them.
7:04 p.m.
Ramiele Malubay
First up is Ramiele Malubay singing one of my personal favorite songs of all time — Heart’s Alone. It’s going to be a tough performance for Ramiele — born in 1986 — since the song is so well associated with Season 4 winner Carrie Underwood, who knocked it out of the park during her season. Ramiele did an OK job, but not good enough. She completely struggled on the high notes, making it seem a little too karaoke.
“It wasn’t the right song choice for you,” Randy said. “… It was a little pitchy, all over the place.”
“I’m really glad America has heard you sing and how big your voice is,” Paula said.
“I don’t think it was as bad as Randy said,” Simon said. “… The truth is, Ramiele, after what you sang last week … then you’re going to get through, again, this week on that performance. No question about it.”
7:12 p.m.
Jason Castro
Not only is Jason Castro celebrating the year of his birth, but he also is celebrating his actual birthday tonight. He chose Sting’s Fragile as the song from 1987 (I’m feeling super old right now) to represent his birth year. Even though it’s his birthday, I have to say Jason is continuing to slip a little bit in this competition. Tonight is no exception. I’m not sure what’s going on, but maybe he’s a little too focused on turning 21 and not on his performance. Not that it was terrible, I just think it could have been better.
“That was a very good choice of song,” Randy said. “I thought it was alright. … I’m still waiting to see that jump out vocal performance.”
“I think you’re staying true to who you are,” Paula said. “I agree, I don’t think we saw anything different.”
“Jason, I think you’ve had two bad weeks,” Simon said. “And I think it’s time you start taking this a little more seriously. … Everything about it was too laid back.”
Syesha Mercado
Now it’s Syesha Mercado’s turn. She also was born in 1987, and her song choice to celebrate her birth year is If I Were Your Woman. OK, now this is the Syesha I was praising early on this season. After a bit of a comeback last week, Syesha really proves this week why she’s still around. This is, without question, her best performance since cracking the Top 24.
“You know this is great, man,” Randy said. “… I think this is the best I’ve ever heard you sing, including when you auditioned.”
“What’s great about this performance, Syesha, is this is going to be the moment where everybody remembers Syesha flipped it,” Paula said. “… Everything was pitch perfect.”
“Syesha, it was definitely the best so far, but we’re only three in,” Simon said. “I think there is a limit on your vocal, and I think that song stretched it.”
7:27 p.m.
Chikezie Eze
Chikezie grew up singing in a home surrounded by Nigerian music. Tonight, he celebrates the year of his birth with a performance of If Only for One Night. While he said he was a little nervous about singing another ballad, Chikezie is delivering what I would say is one of his better performances. Then, again, he’s had a rocky year for me. But tonight, he’s doing quite well. Will he win? Not a chance. But this showing certainly could help him rebound and make it back for at least one more week.
“I didn’t love this for you,” Randy said. “It was just kind of boring for me, dawg.”
“I think you did a great job,” Paula said.
“Chikezie, I think you sang it well,” Simon said. “Having said that, I thought the performance, actually, was very cheesy.” (Um, Chikezie is cheesy? That’s almost too easy.)
7:39 p.m.
Brooke White
She was born in 1983, and it wasn’t all that long after that when Brooke White started playing the piano. Tonight, she’ll be playing the piano for a performance of Every Breath You Take by the Police. Um, uh oh. Brooke restarted the song just two notes into it. Could that goof up be a problem for the singer? Maybe. The bigger problem likely will be the fact her performance tonight is a little bland and not all that special. It certainly won’t be remembered — unless people talk about the fact she had to start over after the first couple of notes, and that certainly is possible. Definitely not Brooke’s best showing at all.
“Very interesting song choice,” Randy said. “… I almost would have loved it if you would have stayed without the band.”
“I enjoyed this performance so much more than last week’s,” Paula said. “… We always want contestants that are unique and have their own voice. And you do.”
“Brooke, I totally agree with Randy,” Simon said. “If you would have stayed just you on the piano, that would have sounded much more cool. … Definitely good enough to keep you in for another week, but you’ve just got to work this out.”
7:49 p.m.
Michael Johns
Michael Johns is up. He was born in 1978, and tonight he sings We Will Rock You from Queen. OK, so for those of you still holding on to the fact you think Michael deserves to be in this competition, I give you this performance as further evidence I just don’t get it. This is a complete mess, if you ask me. It’s screamy — and not in a good rock ‘n’ roll way — and he’s all over the place. But the audience is screaming, so who knows?
“Finally, finally you believe in yourself and you use that big old voice,” Randy said. “That was the best performance, for me, since you’ve been on this show.”
“This was your moment, your shining moment,” Paula said.
“Michael, this is the first time with you I saw star potential,” Simon said. “… Tonight, you just got it right.”
OK, so maybe I have a mental block against the Aussie. I promise I don’t have anything against people from Down Under. Hmmm.
Carly Smithson
Carly Smithson was born in 1983 in, as you should know by now, it was in Ireland. Tonight, she celebrates her birth year with a great classic — Total Eclipse of the Heart. If the judges think Michael Johns found his place, this song certainly is a perfect fit for Carly. While I think she came in a split second late in a couple of places, I definitely am glad to see Carly performing this type of songs.
“Very interesting song choice for me,” Randy said. “I like it, I didn’t love it.”
“You probably could take every song I’m not crazy about but make me a believer and go buy it,” Paula said.
“Carly, something didn’t quite work,” Simon said. “… I didn’t enjoy it as much as I thought I was going to enjoy it. … Something didn’t quite work there.”
8:03 p.m.
David Archuleta
David Archuleta is missing school while being on Idol. It could mean he will miss his prom. Awww. Little David. Tonight he celebrates his birth year, 1990 — um, yeah. So, what song did he choose? It’s You’re the Voice, an odd song choice if you ask me. (Do you think his dad, Jeff, screamed at him before the show to sing this song? I think he may have picked this song … and it’s not the best choice.) While the performance is sufficient, it felt a little too much like a Michael W. Smith concert from 1990, and that’s not how you win Idol — even if you are favored to win. I just didn’t get this song choice.
“It was a strange song choice for me … but it proves, once again, if you can sing, you can sing whatever,” Randy said.
“I think all of us was trying to figure that one out,” Paula said.
“I actually didn’t like the performance at all,” Simon said. “I thought it was reminiscent of a theme park performance.”
8:14 p.m.
Kristy Lee Cook
Kristy Lee Cook’s year of birth is 1984. Tonight she sings the Lee Greenwood hit God Bless the USA. It may seem like an odd song choice at first, but I actually think it’s one of the best moves Kristy has made this season. It’s definitely a country song, and it works well with her voice. Plus, the patriotic card? That never hurts. The song isn’t a huge challenge, but she handled it well. This is the kind of stuff Kristy can sing and not be out of her vocal league. Will America be impressed? There’s no telling, really.
“Great song choice,” Randy said. “I thought it was a very nice performance from you.”
“It was a good choice, a very good choice for you,” Paula said. “… Your voice is sounding much stronger. You’re growing.”
“Kristy, your best performance by a mile, I think,” Simon said. “I have to say, that was the most clever song choice I have heard in years.”
8:21 p.m.
David Cook
Closing out the night is David Cook. This rocker on the rise could give David Archuleta a run for his money when it comes to stealing America’s hearts. He was born in 1982, and he’s been rocking the guitar for most of those years. Tonight, he performs Billie Jean, but not in the style of Michael Jackson. This, in fact, was another brilliant move by David. His rendition tonight really shows off his edgy rock voice, and the song is recognizable. And, just like the patriotic rule, that always helps contestants. But, when it comes right down to it, David really is the best contestant in the competition at this point. There’s no question about it.
“David Cook, I gotta say, you’re probably the most original, the most bold contestant we’ve ever had,” Randy said. “… You might be the one to win the whole lot. Hot. Blazing, molten hot.”
“You do it right to the edge without going over,” Paula said. “I think you’re brilliant.”
“David, that was brave,” Simon said. “… I have to tell you, it was amazing.”
WHO GETS MY VOTE: His first name is David. But his last name isn’t Archuleta. David Cook proved, once again, he has more to offer than anyone else in the competition. Even the youngest member of the group can’t stand up to this kind of talent.
WHO SHOULD GO: This is a tough call, but I think Ramiele Malubay — being sick or not — really struggled more than anyone. She just hasn’t pulled together a really memorable performance yet in the finals. That being said, this could be a really interesting week. This week’s elimination may surprise us all, especially considering a couple of the weaker contestants had a strong week … and the mid-level singers didn’t all show their best. Now isn’t the time to just get by. So, don’t be too surprised if you see someone like Jason Castro or Brooke White in the bottom three.
American Idol, David Cook, David Archuleta, Chikezie Eze, Jason Castro, Michael Johns, Kristy Lee Cook, Syesha Mercado, Brooke White, Carly Smithson, Ramiele Malubay
It’s news American Idol could deliver in five minutes. Of course, it’s going to be a full hour before we know which Season 7 contestant won’t quite crack the Top 10. At least we’ll get to hear our old friend Kellie Pickler perform tonight.
So, let’s get to it.
7:58 p.m.
Ryan Seacrest anounces this year’s celebrity mentors will include Dolly Parton, Mariah Carey (which was confirmed earlier this week), Andrew Lloyd Webber — does that mean we’re getting a Broadway theme? — and Neil Diamond.
I’m not even going to comment about this lame group performance … I’m just going to pretend it isn’t happening.
8:08 p.m.
After the first of what’s sure to be many commercial breaks, we’re reminded about the good and bad from last night. The good, in my opinion, included David Cook, David Archuleta, Carly Smithson and Syesha Mercado. The not-so-good included Kristy Lee Cook, Amanda Overmyer, Ramiele Malubay and even Michael Johns.
First up for her results is Brooke White. Even after a not-so-stellar performance, she’s the first to be given a spot in the Top 10.
Carly Smithson was the first contestant to be given a seat as part of this week’s bottom three.
Next up, Carly Smithson. In one of the biggest shockers of the season thus far, she somehow is in the bottom three. I have to say, while it’s surprising, it’s not all that unexpected. Think about winners and top contestants from the past … if America is thinking, “Oh, I don’t have to vote for them, they’re definitely safe” … well, this sort of thing happens.
What about David Archuleta? He, too, will join Brooke White on the American Idols Live tour.
So, Michael Johns, a person I’ve struggled to really support, is up now. Simon questioned his song choice. America did not. He also is safe.
8:20 p.m.
As if the Ford music videos weren’t annoying enough, we now have to watch a how it’s made segment. What’s wrong with just having a 30 minute episode?
Now, it’s time for more results. It’s David Cook’s turn. No surprise here. David’s safe.
Kristy Lee Cook was among the contestants placed in the bottom three this week.
What about Kristy Lee Cook? She certainly was better this week than last, but she joins Carly in the bottom three. This was not a shock.
Jason Castro is next. He also will be going on tour with his fellow finalists.
Then there’s Ramiele Malubay, who has been struggling. But America appears to be behind her, giving her that one more chance I suggested last night.
8:29 p.m.
There are a few more contestants awaiting the news of their fate in the show, but first it’s time for a few calls from Idol fans. It turns out Simon doesn’t want to talk about his expensive cars, but he is willing to agree to recreating the Season 2 kiss scene with Paula.
Now, it’s time to see Kellie Pickler — and, of course, Ryan makes a joke about her breast enhancements. “She’s grown in so many ways,” Ryan said, clearly making reference to the plastic surgery. Kellie’s working on her sophomore album and is touring with Rascal Flatts, but she’s still getting some miles off of her biggest single to day, Red High Heels.
8:44 p.m.
And, we’re back. It won’t be long before Idol Gives Back returns, too. Tonight we get to see some footage with Fantasia and Elliott Yamin handing out netting to families in Africa to try and help fight malaria.
Now, it’s time for more results. It’s Syesha Mercado’s turn. In my opinion, she had the performance of the night — and America may have agreed. Because she, too, made it to the Top 10.
Amanda Overmyer rounds out the bottom three American Idol finalists this week.
That means it’s down to Chikezie and Amanda Overmyer. The one joining the ladies in the bottom three is Amanda Overmyer. Chikezie is safe. Aside from the shocking news of Carly Smithson in the bottom three, there’s no doubt America got the other 66 percent right.
8:54 p.m.
With the bottom three standing center stage, Ryan is sending Carly Smithson back to safety. So, it’s down to two of the worst contestants left in the competition …
And it’s Amanda Overmyer who will be leaving us tonight. Finally, I’m in agreement with these results. While I think she certainly has some spunk, I just don’t think she’s the American Idol. Apparently America agrees.
The good news for Amanda is there’s no question she’s going to be packing smoke-filled bars across the Midwest in months to come. She won’t need to have the American Idols Live tour to play for some audiences — and I don’t really think she cares how big the audiences are … just as long as there are audiences.
American Idol, Amanda Overmyer, Kristy Lee Cook, Carly Smithson
American Idol Season 7’s Top 11 contestants will perform hits from the Beatles.
It’s Beatles week, again. And the Top 11 American Idol finalists are ready to give it a second shot. So, who’s going to stand out during this expansion on last week’s Lennon-McCartney songbook? Well, we’re about to find out.
7:01 p.m.
With 500 people in the audience and 11 singers ready to do their thing, it’s time to get things moving. First, though, we have to hear what the judges have to say about what it took to get us to this point. Boring.
7:07 p.m.
After the usual introductions, we’re ready to get to the performances. First up is Amanda Overmyer. Her song choice — Back in the U.S.S.R. Maybe I’m just not feeling the female rock chick thing, but I don’t get it. Sorry, Amanda fans. This is almost as bad as Kristy Lee Cook’s showing last week. Could someone please explain what I’m missing?
“Paula and I were sitting here saying this is the perfect song choice for you,” Randy said. “… It was just a little pitchy in the beginning. … For me, I gotta give you a 7 out of 10 for that one.”
“Amanda, it was what it was,” Simon said. “It was predictable. It was a bit of a mess at parts. It’s the same thing week after week.”
7:17 p.m.
Last week she was terrible. I’m still a little bitter she didn’t get the boot. But Kristy Lee Cook is still here, so I hope she enjoys this second chance. Her song choice is You’ve Got to Hide Your Love Away. While it’s much better than last week, this still is far from Kristy’s best moment on stage. I don’t know if this was the kiss of death — she did survive beyond last week, after all — but it doesn’t do much for helping push her above some of this season’s other favorites. It was just a little too bland for me.
“It was an interesting arrangement,” Randy said. “… It felt a little boring and a little safe.”
“This is the best you’ve ever looked,” Paula said, focusing on the positive. “It was a little safe, and just kind of, it was good.”
“Kristy, I think you need something like hypnosis or something,” Simon said. “The problem is you’re not a good performer. … It’s like musical wallpaper in as you notice it, but you can’t remember it.”
After forgetting his lyrics last week, David Archuleta is back this week hoping to have another Imagine moment. The Long and Winding Road is his ammunition, but will he hit the target? Tonight’s performance is further proof why David is the early favorite and pick to win the competition. His voice is so pure and smooth, and you can’t help but like the vulnerable 17-year-old. The only thing he really needs to worry about at this point is shining too early in the competition. American is easily bored and, therefore, could be over him before he even has a chance to make it to the final two. Until that happens, though, we all can hope for more amazing performances … like the one he just delivered.
“David, check it out, baby,” Randy said. “David Archuleta has brought the hottness back …”
“This probably, for me, is the most exciting and wonderful performance,” Paula said.
“OK, David, last week was a complete mess,” Simon said. “This week, I thought you were amazing.”
7:35 p.m.
Michael Johns is up next. While I think he’s been a little underwhelming since Hollywood Week, he’s hopefully going to bring something interesting to his rendition of A Day in the Life. The arrangement is an entire mess. It sounds like a collage of many different songs. It’s just not working for me. I say put Michael Johns in the bottom three this week, America. I don’t know who’s favoring this guy among many of the other contestants. Again, could someone please explain?
“It wasn’t one of your best performances,” Randy said. “… The thing is, you gotta remember, you’ve got that big old voice.”
“I was able to catch a little sound from dress rehearsal, and you were pretty phenomenal then,” Paula said. “… You lose the connection a little bit with the audience.”
“The long and short of it was it was a mess,” Simon said. “You didn’t hit the right notes, the song went all over the place … it doesn’t work as a minute and a half, Michael.”
7:45 p.m.
After the commercial, it’s Brooke White’s turn. She’s been a rising star the last few weeks, and I hope this week is no different for this charming performer. Last week, she took on Let It Be and really made it work. Tonight, she takes on Here Comes the Sun, another great Beatles jam. This is such a great song that many Idol fans of all ages will know. That’s a definite help. Plus, the coffeeshop voice Brooke brings to her performances, it’s just working out for me. There’s something about Brooke that’s just relaxing. It’s great to just sit back and listen to her sing. The movements tonight were a little uncomfortable looking, though. Brooke still is one of my favorites …
“That performance was really awkward for me,” Randy said. “… You were never really connected to that song for me.”
“What was hot for me was that you can’t help but smile when you watch you,” Paula said. “… You have really good low tone to your voice.”
“I just knew Brooke, when you were choosing that song, that you would be dressed in yellow and the lighting would be yellow,” Simon said. “I thought the performance was terrible. … That’s what it’s all about, song choice.”
7:57 p.m.
David Cook, just like Brooke White, has been shining more and more each week. So, how will he do this time around? The Missouri rocker is doing Daytripper this week. This guy has it. Simon is right that, if America votes on talent alone, David Cook could be the one to beat. This, so far, is definitely the best performance of the night.
“Yo, Mr. Cook, dawg,” Randy said. “… Dude, I don’t know if it was your best performance, but it’s another solid look for David Cook.”
“You’re ready to go sell records,” Paula said. “You’re ready to go sell lots and lots of records.”
“David, I don’t think that was as good as you thought it was, actually,” Simon said. “… You’ve lost your element of surprise a little bit. This, again, was a little predictable.”
8:07 p.m.
We have some space to fill, clearly. But after a couple of wasted minutes, it’s Carly Smithson’s chance. After a strong week last week, Carly chose to sing Blackbird. This is the slowest tune, the closest thing to a ballad we’ve heard from Carly. And it’s proof her music career will return with a record contract — with or without winning the Idol title. It’s great to hear her taking on a different kind of song than we normally would expect from her. Forget David’s performance, because Carly just took the lead tonight. Her timing was perfect. The pitch was right on. And it worked. Incredible performance.
“Yo, another great performance for Carly Smithson,” Randy said. “Very nice.”
“So, Beatles song, week two, and you choose a song about a blackbird,” Simon said. “I don’t think that was a very smart thing to do.”
8:19 p.m.
After one more break, we’re back with Jason Castro. He’s getting a little less awkward — and I do mean a little — in the interview process. For Beatles week, Jason chose Michelle, which required learning a little bit of French. I think it was a decent song choice for Jason, who glided through the lyrics and showed a slightly different side of her vocal talents. But it always will be his smooth voice that makes him shine the brightest.
“Good choice, Michelle,” Randy said. “It was a little interesting for more for you. … It was just alright for me, man.”
“You have a very distinct charm about you,” Paula said. “Having said that, I feel like you get a little disconnected away from your guitar.”
“This is all getting a bit strange,” Simon said. “Where you’re lucky is that this is a TV show and not a radio show. Because your face sold that.”
8:29 p.m.
It hasn’t been the best night for the finalists, and Syesha Mercado really needs to have a good night. After being in the bottom three last week, Syesha has to be hoping her rendition of Yesterday will get her back in the game. This is, without question, my favorite Beatles song. So, it’s going to be hard for me to judge the performance without keeping that in mind. First off, though, I think it was a brilliant song choice for Syesha. It’s a song many generations know — thanks to remakes by groups like Boyz II Men — and her simple, heartfelt performance certainly is working out. I know I keep saying this, but Syesha is taking the lead for the best performance tonight. She’s using her voice in some ways we haven’t heard, and the judges have to be a fan of that … right?
“In my estimation, very, very, very good performance tonight,” Randy said.
“It’s great to see how you chance and how you let yourself be very vulnerable,” Paula said.
“Syesha, I thought that was probably your best performance so far,” Simon said. “It wasn’t incredible, but you chose the best song. … I think that song and that performance should keep you in this competition.”
8:39 p.m.
Next up, it’s Chikezie. He’s performing I’ve Just Seen a Face, and he’s planning on adding instrumental technique — in the form of a harmonica — even though he admits he doesn’t know how to play any instruments. While I don’t think it’s the best performance ever, I think Chikezie is doing a lot better in the last couple of weeks than he was doing earlier on in the competition. Tonight’s performance should be enough to keep him in the competition. That’s really about all I have to say.
“There was some good parts for me and some bad parts for me,” Randy said
“When you sing a ballad, when you start singing, it is so pure, on pitch,” Paula said.
“I thought it started off OK, and then you played the harmonica,” Simon said. “And then turns into Achy, Breaky Heart at the end.”
8:49 p.m.
The last contestant to take the stage tonight is Ramiele Malubay. Her choice from the Beatles is I Should Have Known Better. This type of theme certainly has to be a little difficult for someone like Ramiele. This just isn’t her style, but tonight she’s doing her best to make it work. Aside from the Kelly Clarkson-esque outfit, I think the performance is enough to keep her safe beyond these difficult themes. It’s not the best she can do, for sure, though. Not even close.
WHO GETS MY VOTE: It wasn’t the best week for anyone, but I’m giving a few votes to Syesha Mercado. She certainly was the best tonight, especially considering she was in the bottom three last week. I’m also going to make a call for Carly Smithson, who, despite what Simon says, did a great job mixing it up tonight.
WHO SHOULD GO: Please put Amanda Overmyer out of my misery. Please?!? I’m begging at this point. Or Michael Johns. I just don’t get what he’s trying to do. And I’m only giving Ramiele Malubay one more chance. I think she’s been kind of cheated with really rough theme weeks for a singer such as herself, so I’m giving her another shot … but that’s it.
American Idol, David Cook, Amanda Overmyer, Kristy Lee Cook, David Archuleta, Brooke White, Chikezie Eze, Michael Johns, Syesha Mercado, Jason Castro, Carly Smithson, Ramiele Malubay
The Top 12 contestants on Season 7 of American Idol arrive Saturday at the premiere of Dr. Seuss’ Horton Hears a Who.
David Archuleta had a rough night. Brooke White was on top of her game. But the vote was in America’s hands, so who will be the first of the Top 12 finalists to leave American Idol Season 7? After 29 million-plus votes, we’re about to find out … at the end of the hour, I’m sure.
8 p.m.
Jim Carrey, voiceover star of the upcoming Dr. Suess’ Horton Hears a Who, opens the show with a painfully obvious — and pointed out by Ryan Seacrest — promo for the FOX-produced film. This is one of the most annoying parts of the … oh, wait, a group performance with terrible choreography and a montage of Lennon-McCartney songs. Gross.
You would think having a choreographer like Paula Abdul sitting at the judges table would be enough to get more than a little hip swivel out of these contestants. But apparently that’s not the case.
8:08 p.m.
After the first of what’s sure to be many commercial breaks tonight, we’re back and welcomed with a recap of last night’s performances. In case you missed it, many of the contestants did quite well. A few — Michael Johns and Kristy Lee Cook, among them — struggled a bit.
Now, the results:
Carly Smithson, Michael Johns, Jason Castro and Syesha Mercado are asked to stand. Carly, obviously, is safe. Michael Johns, who definitely didn’t have the strongest performance this week, also is safe. Jason, the guy who consistently is getting better (though last night wasn’t as great as last week), is safe. And, Syesha? The show-opening contestant last night … well, she’s the first contestant in the bottom three.
Before any more announcements, Syesha has a chance to sing at least one more time. There’s no question it wasn’t her strongest week, but she is one of the most interesting female contestants. What are you thinking, America? Give Syesha some love. Still, I don’t think she’ll be the one going home tonight.
8:21 p.m.
We’re back. Oh, and remember how I said there’s not much more annoying than group performances? I almost forgot about those ridiculous Ford commercials. So painful.
Now, more results. Chikezie Eze, Amanda Overmyer, Kristy Lee Cook and David Cook are asked to stand. Chikezie is safe. Amanda, after a somewhat screamy week, also is safe. David, who has been improving week after week since the beginning of the show, also will be returning next week. Kristy Lee Cook, who certainly should be going home this week, joins Syesha. Now we have to hear that terrible version of Eight Days a Week once again.
This is the perfect example of why contestants should get to perform the song of their choice — not the one America didn’t like — for what potentially could be their last performance on the show. The sad part about Kristy Lee Cook is that she certainly was a frontrunner in the earliest parts of the season. Had she been able to make the right song choices, she certainly would have been around longer … and maybe she will be. But I’m not so sure she can survive this catastrophe.
8:33 p.m.
After another break, American Idol is doing something kind of cool. They’re taking calls from fans across the country. The questions, of course, are kind of boring. Wait, someone just asked why Ryan and Simon don’t duke it out on stage. Brilliant. (Bloody brilliant, the Brits would say.)
Now, a guaranteed decent performance … from Katharine McPhee, an Idol alum with a killer voice.
8:46 p.m.
The last four contestants take the center of the stage. Three will be safe. One will be in the bottom three. First up, David Archuleta. After a weak night, he’s safe.
Next up, Brooke White. She had an incredible night last night, and she, too, is safe.
David Hernandez and Ramiele Malubay are left … and, rounding out the bottom three is David Hernandez. While he didn’t have the best performance last night, I do think he may have lost some of America’s support due to the news of his being a gay stripper before Idol.
After David’s possible final performance, Ryan promises to send someone to safety … but not until after the break.
8:55 p.m.
Before we find out who’s going to go, Ryan wants the judges to make a decision. “It’s probably the right bottom three,” Randy said.
“The whole country’s talking,” Paula said. “You guys are superior this season.”
“I think America got this absolutely spot on,” Simon said.
The first person sent to safety is going to be … Syesha. This definitely is no surprise.
And … the first to go … is David Hernandez.
I have to say America did not get this right. At all. Kristy should have been gone. And David certainly deserved another chance. I’m not 100 percent sure what happened here, but I have a gut feeling it’s David’s past that got him voted from the show at this point.
Kristy Lee was a complete disaster. I guess it could have been worse … But I’m not really happy to see David go just yet. Did he deserve to be in the bottom two? Probably. Should he be gone? I think you get my thoughts at this point.
What about you? Do you think America got it right?
American Idol, David Hernandez, Brooke White, Jason Castro, Amanda Overmyer, David Cook, Ramiele Malubay, Michael Johns, Katharine McPhee, David Archuleta, Kristy Lee Cook, Chikezie Eze, Syesha Mercado, Carly Smithson
