American Idol

David Cook may have gotten more votes than David Archuleta to take the American Idol crown. But it’s the younger David who is getting the numbers where it really matters — on the charts.

Crush, the first single from Archuleta’s upcoming CD debuted No. 2 on the Hot 100 singles chart, one spot higher than Cook’s No. 3 opening with The Time of My Life. Crush also made its way to the No. 1 position on iTunes (it’s now at No. 6) for top downloads on the day it was released.

We haven’t seen this kind of winner vs. runner-up chart battle since Clay Aiken showed Ruben Studdard who American really liked back in 2003.

Still, Cook has plenty of reasons to smile. Time of My Life sold 236,000 digital copies in its debut week, crushing Crush, which only was downloaded 166,000 times in its opening week. In time, I’m betting the reigning Idol champion will outlast the younger David. But you just never know …

He may have been the last to lose, but American Idol’s newest runner-up, David Archuleta, isn’t wasting any time on releasing his own music.

The teenage favorite from Season 7 will release his first single, Crush, to radio on Aug. 12 (available for airplay Aug. 11). The full-length debut is expected in early November.

Archuleta is working on the recording while also fulfilling his obligation to the American Idol summer tour. Other contestants, including winner David Cook and Kristy Lee Cook, also are working on their new CDs.

American Idol, David Archuleta

Jeff Archuleta strikes, again. And American Idol executives aren’t having it.

The father of Season 7 runner-up David Archuleta had planned a big, fat benefit concert tomorrow night to thank fans in Utah who supported his 17-year-old son on his run to be the next big thing in pop music. But, as with most things the older Archuleta has had his hands in this season, he didn’t go through proper channels.

As a result, Idol execs say the show is a no-go. What does it take for people to understand Idol practically owns these contestants until a year or so after their appearance on the show.

Jeff Archuleta still is leading fans to believe “Back Home With David Archuleta,” the show’s planned title, is not being called off for good. Just for now.
“They’re just going to reschedule the event for a later time,” Jeff Archuleta told the Salt Lake Tribune. “When all the minds met, everyone concluded this wouldn’t work out for this particular weekend, and they just want to reschedule it for toward the middle or the end of the [American Idols Live! summer] tour.”

Um, yeah. I’m pretty sure that’s exactly how it all is going to go down.

American Idol, David Archuleta

He was Fantasia Barrino’s favorite, among others, but it appeared David Cook didn’t think he’d actually take the title of American Idol Season 7. But he did.

These are sampling of photos after the announcement was made. Get used to seeing this face, because you’ll likely be seeing a lot more of it in the near future.

And the other David shouldn’t be forgotten, either …

Nor should last year’s winner, Jordin Sparks …

Now, stay tuned to WatchingAmericanIdol.com for news and updates about all of this season’s contestants and contestants from the past. And, if you attend one of the concerts this summer, share your story and photos with me to be posted on the blog.

American Idol, David Cook, David Archuleta, Jordin Sparks, Fantasia Barrino

David Cook and David Archuleta stand on either side of host Ryan Seacrest during Tuesday night’s finale performance show.

After a red carpet arrival event that welcomed several past winners and even more contestants — even celebrities including Teri Hatcher and Janice Dickenson — it’s time to crown a winner. American Idol Season 7 is coming to a close, and David Cook or David Archuleta will be crowned the winner.

On the red carpet, Simon Cowell took back his comments about it being a knockout and Archuleta being a sure winner. He said, after watching at home, he saw how well Cook held up in the contest. Now, it’s time for a two-hour finale packed with performances and, of course, the winner.

Last night, there were 97.5 million votes cast. And the split is 56 percent to 44 percent, Ryan Seacrest announces. So it’s a fairly close one. Now, let’s get down to it.

I have to say I am a little surprised Idol would have these two finalists pair up for Hero. It was a slightly off duet — a song way more fit for Cook than Archuleta. At least it wasn’t as awkward as the shameless plug for The Love Guru.

Syesha and Seal? Um, that’s a bit of a bizarre pairing, too.

At least Jason Castro chose to sing Hallelujah. And other song from him may have been a waste of time. This certainly was a highlight for him this season, and I’m pretty certain it’s safe to say he’ll be singing that tune on the summer tour.

OK, so now it’s like Oprah. And you get a car! And you get a car! Sorry, I couldn’t resist. I love that Ford is giving the Top 2 finalists each a Hybrid Escape. And what’s up with David Cook acting shocked? Has he not watched this show in the past?

Now, it’s on to the Top 6 women performing a group number. Could Amanda Overmyer look any more unimpressed? I think the answer is no. She needs to show some appreciation or Donna Summers — she looks a little rough and confused — may just slap her across the face.

Wait a second. Ryan Seacrest is dancing. Is he drunk? I’m so confused right now …

After the break, we’re back to this season’s finalists. Paired up this time are Carly Smithson and Michael Johns, two contestants Seacrest says were voted off earlier than they should have been. I suddenly feel we’re all seeing a televised preview of the summer tour. While I like many of this year’s top contenders, I would not want to see that kind of performance at a live concert.

Now it’s time for the Top 6 guys, and it’s really about to get cheese-tastic up in here. A group performance of Summer of ‘69 is about as ridiculous as you could go. Of course, when the Davids — not Hernandez, but the others — take the stage, it completely turns everything around. Suddenly, when placed on a stage with the other men in the competition, it becomes even more clear the best two guys made it to the end.

And, since this is American Idol, why wouldn’t we bring out a Canadian? Welcome Summer of ‘69’s very own Bryan Adams, who also is at the finale tonight to promote his new CD.

Right now David Cook seems to be having the time of his life. And why wouldn’t he be? He’s sharing the stage with ZZ Top to perform Sharp Dressed Man, a song I’m sure he’s performed a time or two before. I have to say, I think Idol really has come a long way in giving contestants the opportunity to jam with seasoned artists during the finale. This has to make the experience that much bigger for guys like David Cook.

Next up is Brooke White, sharing the stage with Graham Nash. This actually is one of the cooler performances of the night. Brooke’s sharing a bit of a country/bluesy feel. And it certainly works well for her. She seems in the zone. I’m willing to bet she thinks this is a pretty cool experience. It’s amazing how much more relaxed she seems right now, in front of the largest audiences she’s played to this season.

I should have called that our favorite worst singer of the season would be making an on-stage appearance tonight. Why? Because he is our brother … our best friend forever. Wow. That outfit still is incredible.

David Archuleta’s celebrity duet is with One Republic on the hit song Apologize. I have to say little David sure does shine vocally on this track. And I didn’t see that coming. This just goes down as further evidence that this 17-year-old has some pipes.

After some recent vocal trouble, the reining Idol winner, Jordin Sparks, has rebounded nicely. Singing a track from her debut, Jordin seems more confident today than she did a year ago, wearing a different kind of gold dress. Still, seems to be holding back a little bit vocally. One Step at a Time on the CD has a lot more range than Jordin’s performance tonight. You still gotta love her, though.

There’s really no question about it. Carrie Underwood, the Season 4 winner, is about to deliver the biggest performance of the night. A well-established, award-winning artist, Underwood has made a big, big name for herself in the music industry. And, yes, it turns out her performance tonight is the best. When you have it, you have it. And Carrie Underwood, my friends, has it.

Before we get to the big announcement — when the sparks fly and confetti falls — the Top 12 finalists take the stage once, again. This time they’re singing some George Michael songs. The highlights? Carly Smithson and the Davids — all three of them, actually. Mostly it’s all about Carly, though. She certainly should take this act on the road (beyond the summer tour, even). I have to say, as a whole, this is one of the least offensive group performances of this season or any, for that matter. Still, group numbers are a downfall, if you ask me.

Now, it’s time for the one and only George Michael to take the stage. This is a big bonus for Idol. Sure they’ve had a lot of celebrities, but there’s something a little ultra cool about this one.

+++++++++++++++

OK, the time has come. With just a few minutes left, it’s time for one of the Davids — Cook or Archuleta — to take the Idol crown from reigning winner Jordin Sparks.

Final thoughts from the judges:

“I’m honored and proud to be sitting here,” Paula said.

“I want to congratulate both of you last night,” Simon said. “… It wasn’t quite so clear cut as we called it. … For the first time ever, I don’t really care who wins. You’re both terrific.”

So, let’s do this. And the winner is … “The winner, by 12 million votes, of American Idol 2008 is … David Cook,” Ryan announces.

This is exactly how this should have gone down. And David Cook is incredibly emotional. Celebrities in the crowd are cheering, and he’s tearing up.

“Thank you guys,” Cook said. “This is amazing. Thank you.”

American Idol, David Cook, David Archuleta

About the only thing these two have in common is a first name. And you’ve already heard every pun or play on the two Davids, so I’ll spare you another. American Idol Season 7 finale week is here. We’ve endured the bad auditions, the Top 24 — can you even still name them all? — and now, the moment everyone has waited for …

Tonight David Archuleta and David Cook each will sing three songs to battle for votes to win the Season 7 title. Of course, at this point, Americans have their favorites. But I do think it’s going to be a close one. So, let’s get to it.

7:05 p.m.

A slighty cheesy boxing theme has opened the show and, after last week’s coin toss, David Archuleta has decided to go second. After a few kind words from the judges and the final two, Ryan throws us to a break. But, when we get back, we’re promised some singing. Let’s do this.

7:12 p.m.

Round one gets started with a song selection from music legend Clive Davis. His choice for Cook is I Still Haven’t Found What I’m Looking For from U2. Don’t Let the Sun Go Down is his choice for the younger David.

Playing to the audience of 7,000, Cook’s performance looks and feels like a real concert from a seasoned artist. The screaming fans in the audience, every last bit of the performance seems perfected. He sounds good; and he’s putting on the show. This is what it takes to be the first true rocker Idol winner.

“It was hot, baby,” Randy said.

“Well, you may not have found what you’re looking for, but we have found David Cook,” Paula said. “… You’re in great voice tonight.”

“You know, David, I could see at the top of this show, you looked very tense, very emotional,” Simon said. “Taking all of that together, I thought it was phenomenal.”

Now it’s time for little David. As always, he’s consistent. And pure. This kid has talent, obviously, but he looks young on stage. He doesn’t have the look of a seasoned concert performer — which is what, I think, puts him at a disadvantage. Of course, the big voice on a little guy routine is always one to win over the fans.

“It doesn’t matter what happens, right now, you gotta know one thing, this is one of the best performances all season,” Randy said.

“I gotta tell you, my hearts still pounding, David,” Paula said.

“David, I’m going to be honest with you,” Simon said. “I thought last week you were OK. I thought tonight’s performance was, arguably, the best you’ve done so far.

“Taking everything into account, round 1 goes to Archuleta,” Simon continued.

Visibly, both of the Davids are overwhelmed. You can tell they are in their element. This means the world to both of them — and that’s visibly more obvious than any previous season. (And speaking of things that are obvious, let’s not forget Ryan’s fake tan. Wow.)

7:27 p.m.

Round 2 is all about the Songwriter’s Competition. Both Davids got a chance to choose from the top songs. Cook’s choice was Dream Big, which likely will be his first single.

I have to say, at first, this song sounds like it belongs on the Disney Channel. I would maybe even go as far to say it could be the closing number for High School Musical 3. But, with Cook behind the guitar on it, you really believe it could be a big radio hit. After all, those Disney stars have done more with less when it comes to a song.

“You were singing your face off,” Randy said.

“David, a song in your heart, a guitar in your hand … this is a great way to take a song we don’t know and fall in love with it,” Paula said.

“Using the boxing analogy, it was a bit of a lightweight, actually,” Simon said. “Keeping in mind this is supposed to be a winning song, this didn’t feel like a winning moment for me. … That was a 6 1/2 out of 10.”

Before David Archuleta tries his hand at an unknown tune … it’s time for another one of those famous Idol commercial breaks.

7:36 p.m.

We’re back, and David Archuleta is taking the stage with In This Moment, another unknown song from the songwriter’s competition. There’s no question this was the better song choice, lyrically, for this round. It’s a little too similar to A Moment Like This (even in the title), which was the song that put Kelly Clarkson on the map. But the only thing I really can say negative about this performance has nothing to do with the song — but what in the world is happening with that jacket he’s wearing? Anchors, really? Good song choice, though. That actually could be a song you hear him sing before tears stream down his face … should he be crowned the winner.

“Right now, you are so in the zone,” Randy said.

“It’s just another heartfelt performance,” Paula said. “It’s like you’re on fire tonight. It’s pure magic.”

“You definitely, definitely chose the better song there,” Simon said. “Round 2 goes to David Archuleta.”

Um, if my math is correct, that’s Cook: 0, Archuleta: 2. But that’s just Simon’s opinion. So, what are you thinking? Does the younger David have the title locked away after just two songs tonight?

7:45 p.m.

We’re back, and Round 3 is about to start. This final chance for the contestants to prove themselves allows them to be in full control of the music. This is their song choice, and David Cook chose The World I Know by Collective Soul.

David Archuleta chose Imagine, a song he already has performed this season. It was an incredible performance the first time around, but is it a mistake to repeat at this point? We’ll find out … but first, it’s David Cook.

There’s no question Cook chose a great song for himself. This is the type of music you certainly can expect from his post-Idol debut. I have to say, I have chills listening to him sing this song. There’s so much passion for music there. His professionalism is coming through more than anything on this one. Definitely, this is his best effort tonight.

“That was a very nice, sensitive side for David Cook,” Randy said.

“You’re standing in your truth, and you’re delivering unbelievable songs with originality and integrity,” Paula said.

“You know, David, look, I just want to say publicly you are one of the nicest, most sincere contestants we’ve ever had,” Simon said. “… I’m going to be completely honest, that was the completely wrong song choice for tonight.”

I have to say, even though it seems Simon is pulling for Archuleta (clearly), this was a great night for Cook. And I think he deserves the title just as much — if not more — than his competitor. Of course, we have heard how much praise Archuleta got for his first time singing Imagine on the Idol stage. We’ll find out if he gets that much support, again … after the break.

7:53 p.m.

And we’re back. David Archuleta is taking the stage with Imagine. While I think it’s kind of boring he chose a song America already has heard him perform, I am reminded of how incredible he can deliver this tune. If there was anyone out there who thought this kid wasn’t packed with a vocal gift unlike most people his age, these clearly need to listen up right now. Archuleta’s effort tonight is making it seem clear he should win the title … let’s see what the judges have to say.

“David Archuleta, I’m really happy and proud it’s the two Davids standing on the stage,” Randy said. “Dude, you are so good tonight. … The best singer of Season 7 is right there.”

“You’ve left me speechless, as I was when I first heard you sing the song,” Paula said. “You were stunning tonight.”

“Tonight, I think we’ve witness one of the great finals,” Simon said. “In my opinion, David, you came out here tonight to win. And what we have witnessed is a knockout.”

THE VERDICT: My feelings about these contestants have been mixed throughout the season. I started off thinking Archuleta was incredible, maybe one of the best singers in the show’s history. But as the season went on, I wasn’t sure he was genuine. His “oh, golly gosh” attitude seemed a little too good to be true.

At that point, I started really seeing more talent from David Cook, who I think has stayed true to himself and his style more than anyone else in the competition. He seems like the clear should-be winner for the past several weeks. So much so, I actually started losing interest in Season 7.

Then tonight happened, and I have to say, David Archuleta proved, once again, why he should be given the crown. This is a singing competition, after all. Would I rather buy a David Cook CD? Sure. Would I rather see David Cook in concert? Of course. But I know I’ll have that chance, too. So, I guess I’ve come sort of full-circle this year. David Archuleta, congrats on an incredible night — arguably the best showing from any finalist in the history of Idol. You deserve to win, kiddo.

American Idol, David Cook, David Archuleta, Simon Cowell, Paula Abdul, Randy Jackson, Ryan Seacrest

Syesha Mercado performs Fever on Tuesday night’s episode.

Well, it’s no surprise. Next week will bring on the much-anticipated — and also expected — battle of the Davids.

This week marked the end of the line for Syesha Mercado, who complete Season 7 of American Idol in the third position. (No worries, Syesha fans. This is the time when Chris Daughtry’s road ended on the show, too.)

While it may not have been a huge surprise to see Syesha leave tonight, I think it was pretty surprising how nervous David Archuleta looked when it was announced he would be in the finals. He was visibly shaking, which maybe shows his vulnerability … and a little bit of genuine behavior. Before that, I wasn’t sure how sincere he was acting this season.

So long, Syesha. I’ll be waiting for your CD to drop. Now, I just have to decide which David will win.

American Idol, Syesha Mercado, David Archuleta, David Cook

While the competition has gotten a little too predictable at this point, the American Idol Top 3 all sang with everything they had with hopes of making it to the big show — next week’s finale.

You could see the exhaustion on their faces. They all just returned from trips to their hometowns for concerts, parades and celebrations galore. David Cook, Syesha Mercado and David Archuleta have given just about every ounce of themselves. Tonight was no exception, though the song choices remained a mystery — that’s something that’s been a running theme this season.

There’s no question David Cook secured his spot in the finale. Without question, and I’ve been saying this for several weeks, he needs to be crowned the Season 7 winner. His overall performances tonight were well above the competition in many ways. Plus, he’s obviously being groomed for the prize.

Going into tonight, Syesha didn’t have a chance. It seems everything about the show has been playing to the favor of the Davids. And, if truth be told, Syesha kind of showed the younger David she’s not messing around. But, I think it’s a classic case of too little, too late. Die-hard fans are devoted to Archuleta. Plus, they probably feel bad for him after his dad’s inappropriate behavior in recent weeks.

Truly, I thought Syesha gave her best performance of the season with Randy Jackson’s choice of an Alicia Keys song. She was totally in her zone. I didn’t think her version of Fever was too bad, either. In fact, I liked that she played to her acting strengths and had fun with it.

As far as David Archuleta, he probably should not try to sing radio hits from Chris Brown. It wasn’t bad, it just wasn’t “wow.” As far as the rest of his performances, they kind of all sound the same, at this point.

Now David Cook, that’s a different story. He brings his own sound to every performance. His influences certainly shined through when he chose to sing a song from Switchfoot. That’s his groove, and it’s certainly the type of tunes I think we’ll be able to expect on his debut CD. Because, even if he doesn’t win, Cook is guaranteed a recording contract.

When it comes down to it, I think we’ll be seeing our first David-off in the finale. There’s no real question, there. But I would love to see Syesha take one of the Top 2 spots. She has proven herself throughout this season, even though the rough patches.

Your thoughts?

American Idol, David Cook, David Archuleta, Syesha Mercado

It’s the night the judges, contestants and producers all throw in their best effort at choosing songs.

That all-access pass Jeff Archuleta has had throughout Season 7 of American Idol just got yanked.

The father of the youngest Top 3 finalists has crossed the line one too many times this year. So producers have taken away his access to rehearsals. Reports have surfaced that Jeff, father to David, finally pushed it too far when his decision to change the lyrics on Tuesday’s show — altering Stand By Me to include a verse of Sean Kingston’s Beautiful Girls — ended up costing the show more money. The extra song cost Idol extra royalty fees.

Of course, FOX has declined to comment. And Jeff seems to be nowhere in sight now, which probably is the smartest thing this stage dad could do to save his son’s chance at making it to the May 20-21 finale. Of course, America likely will feel sorry for little David, just because he has a dad who is stepping on his chances.

All three finalists were celebrated in their respective hometowns on Friday, part of what will be shown during this week’s episodes. The younger David returned to his high school in Murray, Utah for “David Archuleta Day,” while David Cook returned to the Kansas City area and Syesha traveled home to Florida.

American Idol, David Archuleta

Even though he started the season off strong, Jason Castro couldn’t save himself this week on American Idol. His song choices, ultimately, were bad. And his performances weren’t much better.

I’m just glad America actually voted on talent this week — the Top 3 finalists, a pair of Davids and a Syesha, certainly are deserving of their spots.

While Jason was interesting way back in the beginning of Season 7, the last handful of weeks have shown him slipping more and more into that place where even he can’t believe what’s coming out of his mouth. This week, that included versions of Mr. Tambourine Man and I Shot the Sheriff. Um, how could he have survived?

“Jason, I’d pack your suitcase,” Simon responded after last night’s performance.

So, that means the remaining three will make their hometown visits this weekend. We already know big plans are underway for David Cook in Kansas City, and I’m sure celebrations will be equally large for David Archuleta and Syesha Mercado, as well.

American Idol, David Cook, David Archuleta, Syesha Mercado, Jason Castro, Simon Cowell

It was another slightly uncomfortable night for the four American Idol finalists still standing. Syesha Mercado was brought to tears. David Cook lost his groove. Jason Castro was, well, a disaster. And David Archuleta continued with his robotic performances to try and secure his spot in the finals.

Season 7 is a bit played out at this point. It seems obvious David Cook should win, but it was David Archuleta that had the best week this time around. And it was Syesha Mercado who took the second-place spot, based on talent and this week alone. If votes are based on that, it certainly will be Jason Castro who packs his bags this week, as Simon Cowell suggested he do.

But this is Idol, the popularity contest to end all popularity contests. Not even Miss America could compete with this type of popularity voting, really. This leads me to wonder if Jason will end up being saved by the throngs of fans who adore his dreads. And if Syesha, though a definite contender in recent weeks, will fall victim to the fact she’s been a bottom two or bottom three finalists for several weeks now.

All in all, though, tonight left a lot to be desired. There were no majorly impressive performances. I think maybe I’m just waiting for some kind of true wow factor to come through with anyone. And I’m not getting it. There’s no way producers still can be calling this the best season ever. Because, if you look at any of these finalists as a possible winner, they just don’t compare to at least two or three previous winners. But that’s just my opinion.

American Idol, Jason Castro, David Cook, David Archuleta, Simon Cowell, Syesha Mercado

Kristy Lee Cook, Brooke White and Syesha Mercado rounded out last week’s bottom three contestants. After Cook’s elimination, the other two women were left with four other contestants — David Cook, David Archuleta, Jason Castro and Carly Smithson.

After last week’s exit of Kristy Lee Cook, the Top 6 American Idol finalists are left standing. This week, they have mentor Andrew Lloyd Webber — and all of America, of course — to please.

7:01 p.m.

The band shifted positions this week, just a month before the new Idol winner will be crowned. Tonight, the finalists are up against a huge catalog of music from Braodway composer Andrew Lloyd Webber. This could be a huge challenge for the contestants, even though many former Idols have been Broadway bound after the show.

7:06 p.m.

Syesha Mercado is first to take the stage with One Rock ‘n’ Roll Too Many from Starlight Express. This is a perfect theme week for Syesha, who has a bit of an acting background, and certainly has the attitude for theater. While she’s delivering a commendable performance, it may not have been the most challenging of song choices. All in all, though, Syesha brought the look, the attitude and the vocal power tonight.

“This may surprise you, but I feel, tonight, not only is this your element — I think you could be a huge Broadway star — I think that was your best performance to date so far,” Randy said.

“This is your happy place, and you’re real good at it,” Paula said.

“Syesha, that was very sexy,” Simon said. “I think this was one of your strongest performances so far.”

7:15 p.m.

He’s still not so good with the interviews, but Jason Castro may be able to bring something interesting to Memories from Cats. The song certainly is one of the most popular hits from Broadway, and Jason is doing his thing with it. He has a distinct sound, but it doesn’t work for a male singer. This is a powerful hit song most often sung by female leads.

“Musically, vocally for me, it was a train wreck,” Randy said. “It’s just not the kind of song … it’s just not for you.”

“The reality was, it came over as a young guy being forced by your mom and dad to sing a song at a wedding you didn’t want to sing,” Simon said. “You were miserable throughout. I was partly miserable throughout.”

7:26 p.m.

She was in the bottom three last week, but will Brooke White be able to climb out of that spot this week? Her song choice is You Must Love Me from the movie version of Evita. This week could be the kiss of death for Brooke, who messed up her performance and had to, once again, for the second time this season, start over at the beginning of the song. If she survives this week, it will be a big shock. At this point in the competition, it’s just not OK to have the big of a goof-up moment.

Sorry, Brooke. But this should be the end for you.

“For me, this wasn’t great,” Randy said. “The one thing that I did like that you did was, at least you did listen to Andrew Lloyd Webber.”

“You must never start and stop,” Paula said. “Having said that, this is the biggest show in the biggest platform … what I did love about this performance, Brooke, was that you didn’t overact.”

“This is why I love live TV,” Simon said. “It was so dramatic at the beginning. The trouble was, Brooke, it threw you. … This is a tricky one. I think you’re going to be very disappointed when you watch this back.”

7:37 p.m.

David Archuleta certainly has the talent to tackle Broadway. The youngest contestant’s song choice this week is Think of Me, another popular Broadway hit written for a female lead. The Phantom of the Opera song possibly is Andrew Lloyd Webber’s best-known work. David’s arrangement of the song is an updated, much more pop-friendly version of the tune. And it’s a great move, I think, for David to put himself back in direct competition with David Cook, who has been stealing the spotlight in recent weeks. No worry, little David, this showing proves you really do deserve the praise you’ve been given. I’m sure your dad will be thrilled.

“What is really cool is you’re exactly what this show is about,” Randy said. “Dude, it was the bomb. This boy is the one to beat.”

“I think it was absolutely perfect, David,” Paula said.

“David, I thought it was pleasant,” Simon said. “One of your weakest performances over the live shows. It’s just not one of those performances you’re ever going to remember.”

7:47 p.m.

Coming off of her best performance in a while, Carly Smithson may not seem fit for Broadway. She is an interesting talent, though, so she may surprise us all. Her song choice was All I Ask of You from Phantom. But Andrew Lloyd Webber wasn’t having it — he suggested she go with her other choice, Jesus Christ Superstar. Ladies and gents, I think this could work …

Look out! Carly Smithson is back, people. Mr. Webber was right. This certainly was a brilliant song selection for Carly — the remaining resident chick rocker. She has the pipes to really wail and show some attitude. I think it works well for her. What about those three celebrity judges?

“It’s no surprise to me that the bigger voices are doing better tonight,” Randy said. “It was definitely good, and I like the outfit. I think the outfit’s kind of fly.”

“I love what you did in the chorus,” Paula said.

“It was actually one of my favorite performances of the night,” Simon said.

7:54 p.m.

Rounding out the night is David Cook. His song choice is The Music of the Night, which is another famous tune from Phantom. Do these people know not of Webber’s other major hits? Apparently not. But there’s no question David really could make something quite special happen with this song choice — or any for that matter.

OK, I have to say it was a brilliant song choice for David. It’s well-known, he’s well-liked and he, well, is making it happen. It’s practically flawless, really. That high note? That was the vote-getter of the night, if you ask me. There’s something about David’s performances that just put him on a completely different level from his competitors.

“I said it before, I’ll say it again,” Randy said. “If you can sing, you can sing anything. Dude, that was an amazing vocal performance.”

“I thought it was fantastic,” Paula said.

“David, I think you’ve made the most of the song,” Simon said. “This isn’t the side of you I like, but you made the most of the song you were given.”

WHO GETS MY VOTE: David Cook. He may get my votes from here on out. Why? He deserves to win this entire show.

WHO SHOULD GO: Sorry, again, Brooke White. But your time has expired. Syesha Mercado proved she deserves to be here and you, well, you choked. And that’s not OK, no matter what Simon says. In fact, if you don’t go, Brooke, it’s time for Jason Castro to say bye-bye.

American Idol, Andrew Lloyd Webber, Jason Castro, David Archuleta, Syesha Mercado, David Cook, Brooke White, Carly Smithson

Mariah Carey performs during last week’s Idol Gives Back charity event. This week the Top 7 Idol finalists take on Carey’s hits.

She’s the diva to end all divas — no, I’m not talking about Paula Abdul. It’s Mariah Carey week, people. This could be amazing — or tragic — but the time has come.

7:04 p.m.

First up is David Archuleta, singing I Believe. This week was almost meant for David, who clearly can reach some notes his male counterparts don’t stand a chance of reaching. However, when he tried to hit the highest notes in his arrangement, he didn’t quite make it. Still, he shouldn’t have any trouble sailing through this week.

“I was little worried about tonight … and you probably picked one of the toughest ones,” Randy said. “… You can sing anything. That was the bomb, baby.”

“It must feel great for Mariah to be able to hear your interpretation of her song,” Paula said.

“I have to agree,” Simon said. “I thought it was very, very good. I don’t think we’re in for a lot of laughs tonight, though.”

7:13 p.m.

Carly Smithson is up next. Her Mariah song choice is Without You, which should be pretty incredible. Tonight definitely could be her chance to really shine and get herself out of the bottom three. Instead of trying to reach the heights of Mariah, Carly was smart in giving a nice, subtle performance. Still, it was entertaining and a performance deserving of keeping her around for another week.

“I liked that you challenged yourself with this big song,” Randy said. “The only thing is you’ve gotta believe and trust in yourself that you’ve got that lower range, too.”

“I actually think that, I liked that you showed some vocal restraint,” Paula said.

“I really wanted to hear you sing this song, even before Mariah week,” Simon said. “… Now, the difficult part. Could you pull it off tonight? I didn’t think you did. Sorry, Carly. I think you’re capable of it. … I thought it was an OK version.”

7:23 p.m.

Now it’s Syesha Mercado, who could really shine this week. This type of music really is best fit for her. But is she good enough to really shine? We’re about to see … Syesha chose Vanishing, which is an older Mariah tune. It’s probably a good song choice, since it’s a little less known. As far as female contestants, Syesha is closest to being able to show a range similar to the superstar mentor. I think it’s definitely a decent performance, but she’s going to lose points for the comparison factor.

“I was really afraid when I heard you were going to sing that song, but I’ll tell you something, you did a good job all things considered,” Randy said.

“This week, I think you’ve been extremely smart,” Paula said. “… You’re smart because you picked a song not many people know and you’re not compared to.”

“I think it, once again, technically, it was very, very good indeed,” Simon said.

7:32 p.m.

In a sparkling outfit, Brooke White is taking the stage. They’re milking the fact Brooke missed her sister’s wedding this weekend. Brooke chose one of the toughest Mariah songs ever, Hero. It’s one of the more recognizable songs from Mariah — perhaps her biggest song — and taking it on could prove to be a great challenge.

Brooke’s performance, including playing along on the piano, certainly is her own version. It’s good she didn’t try to mirror Mariah’s incredible talent. But, while it’s a really good performance, I’m not sure it has enough power behind it to really wow the voting public. All in all, though, it was much better than I expected. Just a little dull.

“I like the fact that you brought the whole singer/songwriter to the thing,” Randy said. “I was digging it until the bridge. … I appreciate the singer/songwriter look.”

“Every ounce of you is totally authentic to who you are,” Paula said. “You’re identifiable.”

“Brooke, I don’t think you had much choice other than to do what you did,” Simon said. “Having said that, it was a bit like ordering a hamburger and only getting the bun. In other words, the vital ingredients, the bit in the middle, was missing.”

Now it’s Kristy Lee Cook’s turn. She’s taking on Forever, which happens to be one of my favorite Mariah songs of all times. That said, I’ll try to be a fair critic. Even though she is making crazy faces, I have to say Kristy Lee really nailed this one. In fact, I think it’s the best performance of the night. I’m not sure if it’s going to be enough to garner votes from those fans who haven’t been voting for her in the past, but it certainly is a deserving performance in my opinion. No, it’s not as amazing as Mariah, but it was clean, clear and crisp.

“I didn’t think that was amazing, but I gotta tell you you definitely started stepping up at the end,” Randy said.

“You know what, it wasn’t just the end,” Paula said. “I think you’re a very smart girl. … Kristy Lee Cook … I’m like blown away.”

“You didn’t give me chills,” Simon said. “I think you managed with what you could. It was a little bit whiny at times. … It just wasn’t great.”

Maybe it wasn’t great, but it was great for Kristy Lee. And maybe that’s what I heard.

7:46 p.m.

I’ve been intrigued by what David Cook would choose to sing this week since I heard Mariah would be the guest mentor. His song choice is somewhat surprising. Choosing Always Be My Baby even surprised Mariah. I’m not sure what I would have picked for David as an alternative, but I didn’t think this was going to turn out all so well. But it actually is pretty interesting. It sounds a little like Lifehouse, but I think David certainly “worked it out” as Randy said. He really drove home the song at the end, which solidified his performance and pure, raw talent. If you’re a guy who can sing Mariah Carey songs and make them not sound like Mariah Carey songs, well, then maybe you deserve an Idol crown. I’m just saying.

“Dude, you know what? I think more than almost anyone on this show right now, you’re ready to make an album,” Randy said.

“That’s pretty awesome,” Paula said. “That song could be on a movie soundtrack right now, it really could.”

“David, it was like sort of coming out of karaoke hell into a breath of fresh air,” Simon said. “It was original. It was daring. It stood out by a mile. And this is the sign of a great potential artist, someone who takes risks.”

7:56 p.m.

Jason Castro closes out one of the most interesting episodes of the season — at least when it comes to the mentor. Mariah gave Jason some advice for his rendition of I Don’t Wanna Cry. While I have not been the biggest fan of Jason’s performance the last couple of weeks, I do think this week was full of interest. He did the best job making a Mariah Carey song not sound like a Mariah Carey song — even better than David Cook, who certainly stole the show. But this performance should really keep Jason in the competition.

“For me, I didn’t really love that,” Randy said. “I felt like I was at a weird beach luau.”

“Jason, I’d love to be at the luau, listening all night long,” Paula said. “You’re getting so confident and in that zone.”

“Jason, I’m going to have to agree with Paula,” Simon said. “I thought that wasn’t the best vocal of the night. Having said that, it was identified with you … it was a cool version.”

WHO GETS MY VOTE: Without question, the “best of the night” honor goes directly to David Cook. There’s not another David (or Jason) in the competition who can compare. If you doubted the older David in the competition deserved to win this show, tonight should have changed that.

WHO SHOULD GO: This is going to be a tough week, and it may even result in another surprising elimination. I have to say, after hearing the recap performances, Kristy Lee Cook may be in trouble. But Brooke White wasn’t exactly a standout, either.

American Idol, Mariah Carey, David Cook, Brooke White, David Archuleta, Syesha Mercado, Jason Castro, Kristy Lee Cook, Carly Smithson

Season 7 American Idol finalists perform Sunday during a taping for this week’s Idol Gives Back.

It’s the beginning of another three-episode week, and American Idol will let another singer go. And maybe raise a few million dollars in between. This is Idol Gives Back week, and each of the finalists will sing an inspirational song.

7:02 p.m.

First up is Michael Johns, who had a great week last week. His song choice is Dream On, which seems like a somewhat obvious choice for him. I have to say I’m back to the point of saying, “What’s up with this guy?” That whiny, screaming stuff? I don’t get it.

“I really believe that this is one of the important weeks for us,” Randy said. “… It had some pitch problems for me.”

“I couldn’t disagree more,” Paula said, giving praise (no shocker there) to Johns.

“You know what, Michael, I thought it was a very good performance,” Simon said. “… I don’t like it when you do an impersonation of a rockstar.”

7:11 p.m.

Syesha Mercado is committing one of the biggest sins in the Idol game — and it’s not performing a Whitney song. No, she’s performing a song from a former Idol winner, Fantasia’s I Believe. Of course, it’s not a sin when you give a great performance, and I think Syesha did just that … I’m not quite sure about that crazy high note at the end. But it was a surprise. Judges?

“It was OK, just OK,” Randy said.

“Not many people can take on songs like that,” Paula said. “You flipped it a little bit and made it all your own.”

“Syesha, to be fair, of course there’s going to be a comparison,” Simon said. “Technically, I thought you sang it very well. However, what it lacked for me, was that big, big wave of emotion.”

Now it’s Jason Castro’s turn. He has chosen Somewhere Over the Rainbow, but not the version Kimberley Locke brought to the Idol stage. This is a completely different, more Hawaiian approach. I like Jason, I really do. But I have to say, this seems a little too far off from what is expected on this show. Jason’s performance seems a little more fit for a subway station or even a not-so-crowded coffeehouse. I’m just not sure this is the type of showing that can keep him out of the bottom three.

“Yo, I tell you what,” Randy said. “Dude, Jason Castro is back … that was crazy, molten hot.”

“You have the most definitive sound,” Paula said.

Simon thought it was “fantastic.” I wouldn’t go that far. But, of course, I think we know who’s sitting in the judging chair.

7:24 p.m.

Kristy Lee Cook is this year’s chance at a true country artist, but she’s struggled to find a song that really works for her. This week she chose Martina McBride’s Anyway. It’s a perfect song for Cook’s voice. While she’s no Martina McBride, this is the type of song that allows her to showcase her vocal talents in the biggest way possible. There are plenty of notes to hold out and big notes to nail. And she did it … the best she could.

“There were a couple of little pitch moments, but I loved that,” Randy said.

“I think you outdid yourself tonight,” Paula said. “This was your best by far.”

“I thought you were very, very good indeed,” Simon said. “I also think tonight, tonight you look like a star, Kristy.”

7:32 p.m.

Our Lady Peace is one of the best bands to come from Canada. And Innocent is one of their best songs. So, it’s fitting that David Cook, one of the best finalists on Idol’s Season 7 would choose to cover the song. Of course, he did it well. It was a nice, smooth change of pace for David. That said, it wasn’t as great as his previous two weeks … but how do you top those performances?

“I’m a huge fan of yours,” Randy said. “… I’m not sure this was one of your strongest weeks right here.”

“Tonight was no exception of you being so good,” Paula said. “You are so well defined as being the whole package. You are it.”

“David, I didn’t like this performance very much at all,” Simon said. “I thought it was a teensy, weensy pompous.”

The Show Must Go On by Queen is Carly Smithson’s choice. The song certainly fits her style — unlike that wacky outfit she’s wearing tonight. But I digress. No, wait. I can’t stop with the crazy, shiny gold belt. This performance is passable, but I’m not sure it’s all that phenomenal. I do think it will be enough to get Carly through to the next round, but she may end up in the bottom three …

“It ended up OK,” Randy said. “It was just OK for me.”

“There’s something I’m actually going to agree with a little bit,” Paula said. “Your voice, as always, is pretty much pretty perfect. I just didn’t feel engaged with you.”

“Carly, you look good,” Simon said. What? Really? Um, the gold belt. Is anyone else seeing this?

“I thought it was an unusual choice of song tonight. … You did lose control of the song there at the end,” Simon said.

7:46 p.m.

It’s David Archuleta’s turn to take center stage. His inspirational song choice is Angels. I actually think this was a wise song choice for David, who takes to the piano, adding a little extra drama. It also is aging him a little bit. It seems sometimes, no, almost all the time, David is trying to perform as if he’s a much older performer. As far as the quality of tonight’s performance, it was vocally where it needed to be. While subtle, the overall performance was pretty incredible.

“You know what I loved about this performance … when you did that little refrain at the end, that’s the David Archuleta I love,” Randy said.

“Best song choice of the night,” Simon said. “I’m not going to say it was your best vocal, however. … David, I’m nitpicking here, because you are going to sail through to the next round.”

7:54 p.m.

Closing out the night is Brooke White. She’s going to perform Carole King’s You’ve Got a Friend. Tonight, Brooke is mixing it up and letting someone else handle the piano playing. This is an interesting, slightly slow, version of this song. It seems Brooke maybe slowed the tempo a little too much. Maybe that’s not it, but something just doesn’t seem quite right. The song almost seems unrecognizable, and not in a good way.  I’m a little bored with this one.

“For me, I don’t think it was your best performance,” Randy said.

“That song, I grew up to,” Paula said. “… I think it’s the perfect way to close the evening. Once again, you’re very definitive.”

“It was sort of like a pleasant walk in the park,” Simon said. “It was nice. Was it original? No. Was it pleasant? Yes.”

WHO GETS MY VOTE: It’s a tough one, but I think I may have to send this week’s honor over to David Archuleta, maybe? I actually thought Syesha Mercado provided another bright spot … but the Fantasia comparisons are going to be just a little too much for her.

WHO SHOULD GO: It maybe should be Jason Castro, based on tonight only. I definitely think Kristy Lee Cook earned her spot for one more week. But previous performances may not be forgotten.

American Idol, Brooke White, David Cook, Kristy Lee Cook, David Archuleta, Syesha Mercado, Carly Smithson, Michael Johns, Jason Castro

Ramiele Malubay was voted off of American Idol this week, leaving eight contestants to battle it out for the Season 7 title.

Last night I had a guest blogger, my friend Susan, sharing her thoughts on American Idol’s Top 9 contestants. Tonight, I’m back to share my thoughts on this week’s performances, which were mentored by Dolly Parton.

It was a great week for some — Michael Johns, Carly Smithson and Brooke White — and it was a little less exciting for others. Those others, including Ramiele Malubay and Kristy Lee Cook, just didn’t hold up. If one of these two female contestants goes home tonight, it will be no surprise.

So, let’s see how your votes came out.

7:58 p.m.

Things are getting a little bit of an early start tonight. In line with the theme, the Top 9 contestants are presenting their group performance of Dolly Parton’s 9 to 5. It’s a little less ridiculous, compared to other group performances … oh, wait. Yeah, if you’re watching, they did just gather around the judges as if they were in a high school show choir. Good grief.

8:04 p.m.

It’s time for the results. First up is Michael Johns, who had his best week to date, if you ask me. He actually proved why he was in this competition … and that’s been missing for me. To nobody’s surprise, he’s safe.

David Archuleta is up next. He, too, had one of his better weeks, at least in the last month. Obviously, he’s safe.

Now it’s Carly Smithson, who was one of my favorite singers from the night last night. It seemed she would be shown to the bottom three since she was the third contestant to hear her results tonight. But, rightfully so, Ryan sent her to safety.

8:14 p.m.

It’s time to take a few questions from fans calling into the show. Tonight’s questions are a little less interesting than in past weeks. What does Syesha miss about her home life? What other talent would David Cook want to have? Is there anyone Randy Jackson hasn’t worked with? Nothing too exciting, really.

Not only will Dolly Parton perform tonight, but the Clark Brothers also are taking the Idol stage after winning the FOX reality show The Next Great American Band. Their song choice, This Little Light of Mine, seems a little bizarre. Their entire performance is a far cry from what we’re used to hearing and see on this stage …

Now, back to the results.

There still are three spots left for the bottom three. Will David Cook take one of those spots? It’s no surprise, here, either. As it should be, David is safe.

Now it’s Ramiele Malubay’s turn. As it should be, she’s the first contestant to be sent to the bottom three. While she seems like a sweet girl, she just hasn’t hit her stride this season. I’m not sure what happened from Hollywood Week.

Kristy Lee Cook is prepared for her spot in the bottom three. Even though it was one of her better weeks, she still is headed to the bottom three. There’s no question she should be there.

8:29 p.m.

Idol returned to Nashville to see some past contestants that have gone on to make a career in country music. They caught up with Bucky Covington (Season 5) and Phil Stacey (Season 6). They also went to see rocker Bo Bice (Season 4), who credits Idol for his success.

“I’m just as proud to be a part of this alumni as can be,” Bice said.

There are just a few contestants left to find out the results. Up now is Syesha Mercado, who had a pretty good week with Dolly’s biggest song — I Will Always Love You. And the results? Syesha is safe.

That means it’s down to Brooke White and Jason Castro. Without question, Jason is the one who should round out this week’s bottom three. But that’s not how it’s going down. And wrongfully so. It’s at the point where the bottom three certainly could include some of the better contestants, but Brooke certainly has that little something different that’s really intriguing.

8:41 p.m.

Before Dolly performs or someone goes home, it’s time to promote Idol Gives Back, which begins next week. When it’s finally time for Dolly to take the stage, she performs Jesus & Gravity from her recent release, Backwoods Barbie. I’m not sure how she does it, but this woman continues to be an incredible entertainer, even at age 62. I can’t help but love me some Dolly Parton.

8:53 p.m.

Time is running out on tonight’s episode, and the journey has to end for someone. Randy thinks it will be Ramiele. Simon knows it won’t be Brooke.

The person going home tonight is … not going to be Brooke. She’s going back to safety, leaving her Idol roommates in the middle of the stage. Tonight, the journey ends for Ramiele Malubay. She just didn’t hit her stride past Hollywood Week. She certainly had a great start, but Ramiele quickly lost what it was that made her stand out in the beginning.

I’m not sure what happened — maybe it was the pressure — but I definitely think post-Idol, Ramiele will be able to record n album and make a music career for herself. Until then …

American Idol, Ramiele Malubay, Syesha Mercado, David Archuleta, Carly Smithson, Jason Castro, Michael Johns, Brooke White, Kristy Lee Cook, David Cook, Dolly Parton