‘American Idol’: Why Ramiele Malubay was voted off
Ramiele Malubay is comforted by host Ryan Seacrest on Wednesday after it was revealed she was voted off of American Idol.
It just as easily could have been Kristy Lee Cook. But it was Ramiele Malubay who was met with the end of the road this week on American Idol. So, why did the tiny contestant get the boot? I think it’s simple, really.
Even though she’s cute and charming — that was even more obvious as she wiped tears from her eyes last night — Ramiele just didn’t show up to play the game. She certainly has talent, or she never would have made it on the show.
I think Ramiele wasn’t helped by the fact she had to be locked into choosing songs from categories that just wouldn’t work for her voice. The truth is, talented or not, she doesn’t necessarily have the vocal flexibility of a seasoned singer. So choosing songs from the Beatles, or even Dolly Parton, just doesn’t work.
This isn’t an excuse, either. I think she may have faltered even if given a chance to sing whatever song her little heart desired. You could see that little bit of discomfort with each week’s performance. Ramiele seemed intimidated by the big ol’ Idol stage. And who wouldn’t be?
The truth of the matter is this: While Ramiele wasn’t my favorite contestant this season, I don’t think it will be too surprising if she eventually lands a solid record deal and makes a living at this gig. She’s been compared to former contestant Jasmine Trias, if for no other reason than race, and you should know she found post-Idol success.
So, good luck Ramiele. I’m sure you’ll do well with your cute little self. Oh, yeah, and we’ll see you on tour this summer.
American Idol, Ramiele Malubay, Jasmine Trias, Kristy Lee Cook
April 3rd, 2008 at 3:01 pm
I don’t really know why she got booted off. I find shes a good singer. But maybe not good enough to “win” American Idol. I found she picked a good song on Tuesday. Have no idea why she got booted off.
April 6th, 2008 at 11:36 am
There’s no place for karaoke princess in American Idol that’s why Ramielle got booted off. You’re right, she has the voice, but there’s nothing spectacular on the she sings . Purely karaoke!