Site Meter American Idol » Blog Archive » American Idol: Unfair contestant exposure

American Idol: Unfair contestant exposure

by Reed Dunn

Now that we’re seven years into American Idol, it’s time to point this out — Are some contestants getting an unfair advantage with earlier footage of their life stories?

During the first rounds of auditions, we see plenty of bad singers. But there are a few good ones, too. This week, for example, 29 singers were sent to Hollywood Week from Philadelphia and 24 from Dallas. There were not, however, clips of all 53 of those singers showcased during the two-day, four-hour premiere.

For contestants like Drew Poppelreiter and Kristy Lee Cook, though, there was extensive coverage. We already know much more about them than the other 51 people we’ll be seeing in Hollywood from this week’s premiere. Poppelreiter is a farmer, and cameras followed him back to his country home to get additional footage of him on a tractor and on the front porch with his family.

Similar exposure was given to Cook, a horse trainer and training cage-fighter living in Oregon. Her backstory already is in the front of our minds. In fact, so much so, I even said she’s one to watch.

As Idol moves forward in the season that’s promised to focus more on contestants than celebrity guests, what does this all mean? Do Drew and Kristy and others like them have a better chance of capturing America’s hearts? If you were asking me, I’d say it’s a definite “yes.”

, ,


2 Responses to “American Idol: Unfair contestant exposure”

  1. Reed Says:

    A fan of the show e-mailed me this link about Kristy Lee Cook: http://www.bmi.com/news/entry/233653

    It’s pretty interesting stuff, especially if you consider many people think of “Idol” as a singing competition for amateurs.

  2. Kelly Says:

    Here is his Number 1 fansite on myspace.
    be some of the first to join!
    http://www.myspace.com/drewpoppelreiterfansite

Leave a Reply


About American Idol

There's not a bigger show on television. That means there's always something to say about "American Idol." From updates on past contestants to the choices of today's finalists, you'll find it all right here at watchingamericanidol.com. Weigh in on your favorites, and sound off on who should go next.

American Idol Author(s)
    » Reed-Dunn

TV Channel Posts

  • Independence Day Weekend Links
    Few notes before we get to the links. First off, we're not going to be posting twice today like we suggested yesterday. For whatever reason, it alluded us that this is 4th of July weekend and we have [...]
  • Clip of the Week
    This week's clip comes from Guiding Light. It is a clip from the Bauer BBQ of Danny and Michelle getting married. [...]
  • Happy Birthday, Thomas Gibson!
    Here's a picture of Thomas Gibson looking all smiley, which I thought was appropriate for his birthday. Wish Thomas the best, and have a happy Third and Fourth of July! Have a safe weekend and [...]
  • Ross Interviews the Women of Big Brother!
    Here you go! YAY ROSS! [...]
  • Talk Shows Galore!
    Ok, so we all know that Housecalls was canceled due to lack of a sponsor - but we will not be without a great many places to chat all things Big Brother, without the need to stay away from talking [...]
  • Retcon Patrol: 2-05 "Domestic Issues" Part 4
    Today we continue our look for inconsistent or comment-worthy moments in the Brothers & Sisters second season with a look at the second part of Episode 5. Read Part 1, 2 and 3, and then hop right in [...]
  • New Promo Vid!
    Here's another promo video from CBS! . Hahah! Ok, so Casey actually made me laugh there - and hold ya horses, before you ask OMG ARE THEY IN THE HOUSE?! - that was all green screened, [...]
  • Emily Deschanel in My Sister's Keeper?
    I haven't heard much about the movie My Sister's Keeper - some of my friends have talked briefly about the book and therefore we're now going to go see it. So I'll be off to the theater, with a pack [...]
  • First Impressions!
    So, while we're waiting for more interview videos to be posted (Ross will have the Women of Big Brother today, and we're still waiting on Mark from Reality Wanted, and BB Alumni Diane from CBS2 - and [...]
  • Kill Me Deadly with Kirsten Vangsness
    For Kirsten fans, here is a review from Backstage.com on her new production, "Kill Me Deadly" with the Theater of Note. Here is the review by Les Spindle: Playwright Bill Robens, who previously [...]

Hot Off The Press

  • Clip of the Week
    This week's clip comes from Guiding Light. It is a clip from the Bauer BBQ of Danny and Michelle getting married. [...]
  • Dear Alcohol,
              Dear Alcohol, First & foremost, let me tell you that I'm a huge fan of yours. As my friend, you always seem to be there when needed. The perfect post-work [...]
  • Mr. JM Book Review - Eon by Greg Bear
    Eon, by Greg Bear, is a book that I can only call Mind Boggling! (the capitals are deliberate) Eon is set in our near future, when Astronomers find an asteroid heading our way. If you don’t know, [...]
  • Angelina Jolie=Top Earning Actress
    That Forbes is at it again. They do love their polls and surveys. This time around it's not the most powerful title that Angelina garnered but highest paid actress. According to the financial [...]
  • Is their Relief when Eating Healthy?
    There comes a huge sense of relief when I am eating natural foods like fruits and vegetables. I don't question what I am putting into my body because it is all natural. If I had the money, I would [...]
  • Contest Alert! Win a Copy of the Ultimate Guide to G.I. Joe 1982-1994 Vol. 2
    Thanks to the fine people at Krause Publishing, I snagged a copy of The Ultimate Guide to G.I. Joe 1982-1994 to give away to one fine Toy Bender fan (or ToyBendinite as you often refer to [...]
  • Angelina Jolie Visits Walter Reed Medical Center
    So yesterday we had a bit of news about Brad, and how his motorcycle left him stranded and at the mercy of the paparazzi. Thankfully the paparazzi was there to help! And today we have a story [...]
  • Friday Free for All - Communication
    Hello and welcome to the Friday Free-for-All! Inspired by the Weekend Soiree over at Wifely Steps (and pretty much using her idea, to be honest, but you can go over there and play on her site as [...]
  • Happy Birthday, Thomas Gibson!
    Here's a picture of Thomas Gibson looking all smiley, which I thought was appropriate for his birthday. Wish Thomas the best, and have a happy Third and Fourth of July! Have a safe weekend and [...]
  • Marijuana Law Reform!
    Urge Congress To Support Marijuana Law Reform!     I'm writing you today to remind you to contact your members of Congress in support of marijuana law reform. Massachusetts Democrat [...]