Site Meter American Idol » Blog Archive » American Idol: Unfair contestant exposure

American Idol: Unfair contestant exposure

by Reed Dunn

Now that we’re seven years into American Idol, it’s time to point this out — Are some contestants getting an unfair advantage with earlier footage of their life stories?

During the first rounds of auditions, we see plenty of bad singers. But there are a few good ones, too. This week, for example, 29 singers were sent to Hollywood Week from Philadelphia and 24 from Dallas. There were not, however, clips of all 53 of those singers showcased during the two-day, four-hour premiere.

For contestants like Drew Poppelreiter and Kristy Lee Cook, though, there was extensive coverage. We already know much more about them than the other 51 people we’ll be seeing in Hollywood from this week’s premiere. Poppelreiter is a farmer, and cameras followed him back to his country home to get additional footage of him on a tractor and on the front porch with his family.

Similar exposure was given to Cook, a horse trainer and training cage-fighter living in Oregon. Her backstory already is in the front of our minds. In fact, so much so, I even said she’s one to watch.

As Idol moves forward in the season that’s promised to focus more on contestants than celebrity guests, what does this all mean? Do Drew and Kristy and others like them have a better chance of capturing America’s hearts? If you were asking me, I’d say it’s a definite “yes.”

, ,


2 Responses to “American Idol: Unfair contestant exposure”

  1. Reed Says:

    A fan of the show e-mailed me this link about Kristy Lee Cook: http://www.bmi.com/news/entry/233653

    It’s pretty interesting stuff, especially if you consider many people think of “Idol” as a singing competition for amateurs.

  2. Kelly Says:

    Here is his Number 1 fansite on myspace.
    be some of the first to join!
    http://www.myspace.com/drewpoppelreiterfansite

Leave a Reply


About American Idol

There's not a bigger show on television. That means there's always something to say about "American Idol." From updates on past contestants to the choices of today's finalists, you'll find it all right here at watchingamericanidol.com. Weigh in on your favorites, and sound off on who should go next.

American Idol Author(s)
    » Reed-Dunn

TV Channel Posts

  • Watching the View Podcast May 16th
    Here is the latest installment of what I hope will continue to be a biweekly podcast. Don't forget that you can be part of the show by e-mailing me comments or questions at [...]
  • The Office: "Goodbye, Toby"
    Well, that was fucking depressing. I suppose it's fitting that Amy Ryan, whom everything we've seen her in has been utterly tragic, makes her debut (cameo?) on the best comedy series on television, [...]
  • The View May 16th Recap: Teri Hatcher and Bernadette Peters
    Whoopi Goldberg said that she was watching television and heard about how Hugh Hefner said that when Miley Cyrus is 18, he is welcome to pose in Playboy. She wanted to clear up that he did not [...]
  • Recap delay...
    I thought I was gonna crying a whole bunch in last night's episode. But as it turns out, I did cry because of my crappy internet connection. Be right back with the recaps, photos and reactions [...]
  • Clip of the Week
    This week's clip comes from Guiding Light. This is a clip of Annie Dutton testifying that she lied about Reva pushing her down the steps. You will also see Ross in the clip. [...]
  • Recap delay....
    Hi folks, I'm having a bit of an internet problem (what timing! :P). But once this is fixed, I'm going to get right down to last night's episode. Mmmkay? [...]
  • The Real World Lives On
    The Real World will be back for its 21 season. The 7 new roommates will live in a house in Brooklyn. MTV recently changed the format of the Real World from a half hour show to an hour-long show, but [...]
  • "Desperate" Dishing
    Happy Friday, everyone! They may not be busy on the set anymore, but they’re still getting around. First, Eva Longoria-Parker was spotted shopping in France before heading to the Cannes Film [...]
  • Its a Beauty and Geek Finale
    Beauty and the Geek is down to the last three teams on the season finale - Chris and Cara, Tommy and Amanda, Matt and Leticia. Wow, all the shows I watch are ending this week, whatever will I do [...]
  • Disney Channel's Made in India Event Tomorrow Night
    Tomorrow night (May 16, 2008) the Disney Channel has a special line up ending with a special presentation of High School Musical 2. This includes special shorts about the making of the new [...]

Hot Off The Press

  • Who sets the example for your children?
    This is probably going to be a pretty random blog today... kind of my rant against the world. Hang in there with me! Non-believers, and those who would love to portray Christians in a negative [...]
  • Tom Cruise to be President Of US
      Tom Cruise is going to be the President of the United States, but no not for real. Tom Cruise was rumored a while back to be running for presidency but it seems it was all for a movies. I [...]
  • Tom Cruise Becomes a Golfer
    Tom  Cruise wants so much to bond with Katie Holmes' dad, Martin, that he just went out and purchased a membership to a very exclusive golfing club. The exclusive golf club membership cost Tom [...]
  • The View May 16th Recap: Teri Hatcher and Bernadette Peters
    Whoopi Goldberg said that she was watching television and heard about how Hugh Hefner said that when Miley Cyrus is 18, he is welcome to pose in Playboy. She wanted to clear up that he did not [...]
  • Mississippi State rallies late for big win
    STARKVILLE, Miss. - A solo home run in the seventh inning for Mississippi State gave the Bulldogs just enough offense to take down the Arkansas Razorback baseball team on Thursday night, 6-5. [...]
  • Watching the View Podcast May 16th
    Here is the latest installment of what I hope will continue to be a biweekly podcast. Don't forget that you can be part of the show by e-mailing me comments or questions at [...]
  • Weekly Forecast: What’s the Buzz? Signs and Portents That We Are Over Stimulated
    May 16, 2008 Week of May 16 to May 22 We don’t have to always look to the stars for certain signs and portents. We have concrete signs that we are over stimulated by media overload and [...]
  • Tristi Pinkston's Season of Sacrifice ~ Author Interview
    Hello and welcome to Fiction Scribe, Ms. Pinkston. Let's start with getting to know you a little better. List five things you feel define you as a person. Naps Movies Books Spending insane [...]
  • Summer Means Mango Season (Part 2)
    So continuing where I left off yesterday… I was reminiscing about mango. Anyway, here was my next thought as I heard my mom’s request to ask for mango. “What if I buy some mangoes from [...]
  • When is it Emile Hirsch's time to shine?
    Twenty three year old Emile Hirsch first appeared on television at the age of ten and has had guest stints on shows like 3rd Rock from the Sun and ER. But it wasn't until 2002 when Hirsch made a [...]